What Did I Do Wrong in Finding the Percent Yield of Alum?

Join the discussion
Ask a follow-up here, or get your own question answered by working scientists, mathematicians and engineers — people, not an autocomplete.
Real named experts · corrections over time · the nuance an AI answer skips
9 replies · 11K views
physicsnobrain
Messages
123
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


Find the percent yield of alum

In an experiment to synthesize alum I started with 0.766g of aluminum and made 8.246g of alum


Homework Equations


2Al + 6H20 + 2KOH ---> 2KAl(OH)4 + 3H2


The Attempt at a Solution



First I find the LR. Which in this experiment is Al.

I find the moles of aluminum to be 0.02838mol, next I multiply by the mole ratio and by the molar mass of alum to find the theoretical yield of alum.

Now to find the percent yield I do actual/theoretical X100%

8.246g/3.806g x 100% = 217%. I know I am wrong because this is impossible.

What did I do wrong?
 
on Phys.org
Your calculations are OK, but they are based on the incorrect alum formula - it is not KAl(OH)4. Unless you just use a wrong name of the compound.
 
Borek said:
Your calculations are OK, but they are based on the incorrect alum formula - it is not KAl(OH)4. Unless you just use a wrong name of the compound.

Well we also received another formula in this lab:

KAl(OH)4 +8H2O +2H2SO4 ---> KAl(SO4)2 * 12H20

Should I add this to the formula I listed in my first post to get a overall reaction equation?
 
physicsnobrain said:
Well we also received another formula in this lab:

KAl(OH)4 +8H2O +2H2SO4 ---> KAl(SO4)2 * 12H20

Should I add this to the formula I listed in my first post to get a overall reaction equation?

Hmm I still get a yield more than 100% after doing this. Which is physically impossible
 
Borek said:
Your calculations are OK, but they are based on the incorrect alum formula - it is not KAl(OH)4. Unless you just use a wrong name of the compound.


Is it allowed if I write the formula form the first equation except replace KAl(OH) for KAl(SO4)2
 
Borek said:
Your calculations are OK, but they are based on the incorrect alum formula - it is not KAl(OH)4. Unless you just use a wrong name of the compound.

Also, even if I use the formula u refer to I get a percent yield of 112% which is physically impossible in every sense and wrong.
 
physicsnobrain said:
Well we also received another formula in this lab:

KAl(OH)4 +8H2O +2H2SO4 ---> KAl(SO4)2 * 12H20

Should I add this to the formula I listed in my first post to get a overall reaction equation?

The formula is still wrong. Search for it on google.
 
Pranav-Arora said:
The formula is still wrong. Search for it on google.

I get 61.1% yield. is this correct?
 
physicsnobrain said:
I get 61.1% yield. is this correct?

I got this number using the fomula:

2Al +2KOH +4H2SO4 + 22H2O ---> 3H2 + 2KAl(SO4)2 * 12H2O


This was the only formula that helped produce a reasonable percent yield (61.1%). I am highly sceptical that there is an alternative to this.