What do 'nerdy' guys like in girls?

  • Thread starter Thread starter MissSilvy
  • Start date Start date
Click For Summary
The discussion centers around the qualities that 'nerdy' boys find attractive in girls, with participants sharing their experiences and preferences. Many express that intelligence, a sense of humor, and kindness are key traits they admire. There's a consensus that nerdy guys often appreciate directness and are more likely to respond positively when approached by girls. Some participants mention that physical appearance becomes less important compared to personality traits as intelligence increases. A recurring theme is the desire for mutual interests, with some emphasizing the importance of ambition and open-mindedness. The conversation also touches on the challenges nerdy boys face in dating due to shyness and social skills, with advice suggesting that girls should show interest and engage in conversations about shared interests. Overall, the thread highlights a blend of humor and earnestness in exploring what nerdy boys seek in potential partners.
  • #781
What astonishes me about this entire thread is how people here are able to speak for all nerds.

For example: "...look at all the women nerds date and 99% of them wear makeup".

Are there weekly meetings of nerds where we all gather and come to a unanimous consensus about what all nerds like? Do we have business cards that identify the official nerds from the rest of society?

I am only a white belt nerd, so humbly, I can only speak for my own tastes and actions.

:approve:
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #782
Several of our ladies are very old and have degrees in nerdy fields so spent numerous hours listening to nerds in engineering and physics study lounges. They say nothing has changed since they were in school a million years ago. The no makeup and look natural thing is pretty much male in general but nerds tend to be a bit more emphatic about it. Ignore it ladies. Nerds like good looking women who LOOK natural and not made up, not those that really ARE natural and not made up. (Of course we are excluding those men and women who are born gorgeous SIGH)

And of course there are exceptions thank goodness. One of our older male nerds has always told his lady nerd that what ever she chooses to wear, whatever makeup, hair color, always looks great. VERY smart man.
 
  • #783
netgypsy said:
awkward - makes you feel uncomfortable, you don't know how to respond in an awkward situation.

thanks netgypsy. I know it's synonyms, but there seems to be an additional shade to it I don't quite grasp. for example, I understand an awkward situation, but when people describe a person as being awkward, I think I get the right mental picture but I'm not sure. yeah, off topic, I'll eventually get it some day.
 
  • #784
sorry sorry for not quoteing right
 
  • #785
netgypsy said:
Too many nerds don't see women as people. Guys who are the most successful with women just really like them. (nazarbaz are you sure you haven't been reading John D, McDonald??) These guys can be "homely", poor and not particularly great physical specimens but they are generally well groomed, polite, funny, likeable, cute and respectful but strong in spirit. Like dogs and cats, women know a good guy when they meet one. If they have good sense they grab him. Only women with issues like TRUE bad boys. But a woman does appreciate a guy who can smack down a mugger if he grabs her purse and runs with it. That is, if she hasn't already done so. hahaha

Great dialogue - thanks. Nerds really like hot girls by the way and the degree of stupidity they will tolerate is proportional to the heat factor so if you're dumb you'd better be scorching hot or forget dating a nerd. (The same is true for nerdettes too - the guy better be really really hot if he's not too bright)
Never heard of him... I live in Paris and my english is still improving...
I find a bit odd the emphasis on "good looking girls"... Most vomen are beautiful if you know how and when looking at them... Maybe it's a talent though... I lived most of my aesthetical climax moments with girls who aren't so pretty according to normal standards... Some are still haunting me to the extent that I feel the need to draw or paint them sometimes, even if I'm not that good at it...
Women's are beautiful... End of line...
 
Last edited:
  • #786
An awkward person is physically or socially clumsy. They lack confidence. They say the wrong thing at the wrong time. A lot of nerds are socially awkward, in many cases because they really don't try. And many don't try because they think they won't be successful so why bother. Most do grow out of it.

Our nerdy old couple will tell you neither would have dated the other in high school (NOOO WAYY) but by the senior year in college both had morphed into very different people. So awkward is generally temporary. Thank goodness.
 
  • #787
nazarbaz said:
I find a bit odd the emphasis on "good looking girls"... Most vomen are beautiful if you know how and when looking at them... Maybe it's a talent though... I lived most of my aesthetical climax moments with girls who aren't so pretty according to normal standards... Some are still haunting me to the extent that I feel the need to draw or paint them sometimes, even if I'm not that good at it...
Women's are beautiful... End of line...

A friend of mine once said:

If you tell a girl she's pretty, even if she isn't, the smile on her face will make her so.

:smile:
 
  • #788
DaveC426913 said:
A friend of mine once said:

If you tell a girl she's pretty, even if she isn't, the smile on her face will make her so.

:smile:

John D. McDonald writes action adventure books that are fairly easy to read and entertaining. The hero really likes women but the ones he falls in love with are generally killed in the book, so he can have another romantic encounter in the next book. He would say something like the quote.

Anyone heard the story of the 10 cow wife (it might have been 12)??

A young man was very much in love with a young woman who was fairly ordinary in appearance. He went to her father to ask for her hand in marriage. The father thought he'd be lucky to get two cows in dowry for her as there were many other women in their village who were much prettier. Imagine his surprise when the young man offered 10 cows for her. The father was astonished but of course he agreed and they were happily married. Five years later the story teller went to see the young man who had become very wealthy and wide loved and respected. He was greeted at the door by a beautiful self confidant young woman. Yes it was the rather plain young woman he had married. When a man thinks the woman he loves and who loves him is beautiful, that's what she becomes.

But remember that when a young woman takes the time and effort to look nice for someone special and he reciprocates, it is telling both that they are important enough to look their best for. This is what "nice looking" means - worth going to the trouble to look nice for. And in a marriage, when either spouse stops doing this they are sending a message that they are either too exhausted and stressed out or they don't care any more. Either way the other partner needs to find out what's happening and fix it.
 
  • #789
The most precious beauty is the one we reveal...
 
  • #790
nazarbaz said:
The most precious beauty is the one we reveal...

As turns out this is not always true, as evidenced by my probation officer and this ankle bracelet.
 
  • #791
DaveC426913 said:
As turns out this is not always true, as evidenced by my probation officer and this ankle bracelet.

That's cute... For me, there is no such things as an ugly girl or a hierarchy of beauties... Of course, this is the last thing I can say to a woman...
Sometimes when it's very early in the morning, and you got to the bottom of a good bottle of wine after a very good night, something happens in the face and body of a woman that is indescribable... When you don't know if she's smiling or crying while she's looking strait at you... That's the only moment I let my judgment talk...
 
Last edited:
  • #792
so my love got back to me on the subject. we talked about minimum standards, dealbreakers and such when you're 1st getting to know someone. I'm sure a lot of you are familiar with the xkcd comics. he said since he saw this one:

convincing.png


when he liked a girl or managed to get a date he would always ask them
"do you label your axes?"
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #793
I don't remember, but he says he also asked me if I label my axes at one point, and I responded something like "yes I do. I can be pretty stupid when it comes to graphs, so labeling the axes conforts me since it's the easiest part about plotting".

he says I ended up passing his test not so much for answering yes, but because I didn't seem to find his random question weird. this is a guy who is a stereotypical nerd when it comes to girls, so he's a bit paranoid about women finding him weird. once again, just being relaxed will do wonders.

cheers!
 
  • #794
You posted the image correctly; there is a spurious forward slash in the actual URL, preventing the image from showing.

convincing.png


Here is the URL to the comic page, where you can pick up the obligatory rollover text:

And if you labeled your axes, I could tell exactly how MUCH better.
 
  • #795
thanks Dave, you lifesaver you
 
  • #796
LOVE it
 
  • #797
I doubt it can be safely generalized. Personally I am kind of vain and want someone who is beautiful.
 
  • #798
You're right and wrong about the generalizations. Each guy/girl has different taste in what is attractive. But there are generalities that hold true for all relationships. Anyone can be beautiful/good looking. (Stupid is forever.) The alarm bells ring when a guy or girl knows that their SO appreciates good looks a lot yet they still go around looking like a bum all the time, anywhere and everywhere.

Most of my nerdy male friends prefer hot over beautiful.
 
Last edited:
  • #799
This thread made my day, and killed time while I was sitting my my gen Ed classs (waste of time). For me although I like girls who I can spend time with and hold a good conversation or in general have a good time. The girl may be hot but if there's nothing in her head, I won't be able to stand her for a very long time which translate over to a few seconds.
 
  • #800
I agree with Shaikhob that the person needs to have something in their head. People have different types of intelligence, some may have not done the 'time' working towards a degree, masters etc. I hope I'm not defined just by my qualifications. My ex boyfriend going back some years is an accomplished musician in two instruments, he doesn't have a degree . I respect him for his talents, hard work and his potential. I'm signing up for an astrophysics masters this year. I'm not sure he understands why I love planetary sciences but I think he still respected me for my hard work.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
  • #801
And generally nerdy guys find smart girls hot.
 
  • #802
Planetary science. O.o sounds like so much fun.

My problems is that most girls I like I end up being friends with, only problem is that I never have the courage to tell them I like them or want to ruin the relationship >.<
 
  • #803
If the girl likes you in return there will be different body language, type of smile, and she'll laugh at nearly anything you say - dumb or not. Just look for the cues and when you see them, ask her to go grab a burger, coffee, tea, picnic, whatever you already know she likes. So she turns you down. Guys get turned down. Be "clean", smell good, be friendly, stay fit and trim, deal with acne missing teeth if you have them, it takes work to be attractive but anyone can do it. Yes if you have a wart on the end of your nose you get taken off. Look in the mirror and fix what you don't like. You don't have to look like a body builder but it doesn't hurt at all to be fit. If you smoke, stop. Don't chew tobacco. It's not even attractive in baseball players and cowboys. Healthy is attractive and smart is even more attractive. NERDS RULE! (You've heard the old saying to high school kids - BE NICE TO NERDS - you'll probably work for one someday)
 
  • #804
Good day friends! I beg your pardon me for my English. I live in Central Asia. And just learning English. What is attractive in a quiet brake guys? Perhaps not even the fact of their isolation, and Ping. And most of their modesty, the imaginary, the possible intelegentnost. Reliability. Who are any of you guys are offended brake? And they made you sick? They have ever laughed at you after love. The topic was asked to speak not about sex. So let the love I mean romance, festivities in the moonlight, and so on.
Such cases are much smaller than the cowboy who makes fun of his ex, or humiliates her in front of friends. ;-)
More races will forgive me for the English, and for the fact that maybe my thoughts are hard to understand ...
 
  • #805
Welcome zoro to a great and very international forum and a great place to practice your English. I have lived in a country that spoke a language that I did not speak or understand and I had a very difficult time but people were very helpful.

The question is asking what kind of woman the quiet studious guy likes, not the reverse. But by talking about the ways of the quiet guy you also give the type of woman the quiet guy likes. A woman who is intelligent, has a good sense of humor, is kind and romantic.

Come back again please. We thank you for sharing your ideas.

(You are misusing the word "brake" and I'm not sure what characteristic you mean for it to describe.)

Thank you again.
 
  • #806
MissSilvy said:
I figured I'd have to do that, good idea :) I was just curious about which qualities the guys find attractive in girls.

Nice line by the way!

?
the same as any other man.
you either like someone or you dont.
there is no one thing
 
  • #807
Talking from personal experience, I guess that the quiet guys lack experience and are less confident initiating a conversation, especially when there's physical attraction. Due to their inexperience, they might also have difficulties recognizing cues. They also may have difficulties understanding signals which are rather unambiguous, so you may waste a lot of energy trying to give obvious signals and as a consequence you may feel rejected when the guys is actually interested in you. If such a guy is especially nervous around you or quickly looking away when you catch him looking at you, you can be quite confident that they're interested in you.
So the best way to get their attention is to initiate a conversation in a setting where they can confidently be themselves (so not with tons of people hanging around) and ask them out on a date. When they know you're interested, most of their fears will have gone.

What kind of girls do nerdy guys like? Of course they will also want something nice to look at but since all girls are different and most girls are beautiful in one way or another, this shouldn't really be a problem. For a long term relationship however, I suppose that nerdy guys appreciate a deeper emotional and intellectual depth. I know that I do.
 
  • #808
Back when I was a single guy, I was attracted to cute girls with whom I could have an interesting conversation. The girls who I found interesting to talk to were, of course, intelligent. In the end, I married a musician whose father, as well as one grandfather and great-grandfather, were physics professors. Unlike most other girls, when I told my future wife that I had a B.S. in physics her eyes actually lit up! One should note that quite a few scientists have married the sisters and daughters of other scientists. Paul Dirac was married to Eugene Wigner's sister. Hans Bethe was married to the daughter of Paul Ewald.
 
  • #809
luitzen said:
Talking from personal experience, I guess that the quiet guys lack experience and are less confident initiating a conversation, especially when there's physical attraction. Due to their inexperience, they might also have difficulties recognizing cues.


That is so true, especially for young nerds. Older ones get over it. In my case many years ago we had time to kill between classes so she asked to go for a walk. The beach was close so we went there. After a while I decided she was nice, but we had no future together. She could not possibly like me because we had absolutely nothing in common. She a social worker and me an engineer.

As I turned to walk away she yelled:

STOP

I turned around and she said:

I'm at least going to get a hug out of you.

So she gave me a huge rib crushing hug and held it for a long time . We were both silent.

Then I said, "Goodbye."

She said:

Don't ever say that.

Say "See you later."

She then made me repeat back her phone number several times until she was sure that I had memorized it.

Looking back on it, I now know that she had been giving me subtle signs for weeks that I completely missed. I missed her not so subtle signs during our walk. But I finally got it.

Now nearly 4 decades later we are still very happily married. She is my soul mate.
 
  • #810
Pkruse said:
luitzen said:
<...>

Looking back on it, I now know that she had been giving me subtle signs for weeks that I completely missed. I missed her not so subtle signs during our walk. But I finally got it.

Now nearly 4 decades later we are still very happily married. She is my soul mate.
</...>

Yeah, nerdz is dumb. And also more desirable than a meat-bag in terms of a partner. I wonder how long she was in love with you before she lost patience and yelled at you. My little routine is the best one out there for (quite frankly) guys who lack confidence and a clue. It allows you to set the pace, and gives you a narrow window for action (8 seconds of courage is plenty).

My wife pinned me down in a tickle fight and demanded to know when I would be marrying her. I guess they would never get the decent guys if they waited around, right?

haha
 

Similar threads

Replies
1
Views
2K
  • · Replies 50 ·
2
Replies
50
Views
12K
  • · Replies 20 ·
Replies
20
Views
2K
  • · Replies 34 ·
2
Replies
34
Views
5K
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
6K
  • · Replies 62 ·
3
Replies
62
Views
75K
  • · Replies 18 ·
Replies
18
Views
8K
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
7K
  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
5K
  • · Replies 7 ·
Replies
7
Views
5K