What exactly is differential geometry?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the topic of differential geometry, particularly its relevance and utility for physics majors. Participants explore the foundational concepts, necessary skills, and whether it is advisable for a college freshman to take a course on this subject. The conversation includes theoretical aspects and potential applications in physics and optimization.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Technical explanation
  • Conceptual clarification
  • Debate/contested
  • Homework-related

Main Points Raised

  • One participant expresses uncertainty about the relevance of differential geometry for a physics major and seeks advice on its usefulness.
  • Another participant explains the concept of distance in non-Euclidean geometries, using examples such as measuring distances on a sphere.
  • There is a discussion on how differential geometry relates to calculus, particularly in finding arc-length and properties of curves.
  • Some participants mention that differential geometry is not a basic subject and suggest that it may be better to wait before taking the course.
  • One participant provides an example of using differential geometry in optimization problems, highlighting the complexity of finding shortest paths in non-linear geometries.
  • Another participant encourages exploration of arc-length derivations to gain preliminary insights into the subject.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants generally agree that differential geometry is an interesting and useful subject, but there is no consensus on whether a freshman should take the course immediately or wait for more foundational knowledge.

Contextual Notes

Some participants note the complexity of differential geometry and its applications, indicating that a solid understanding of calculus and linear algebra may be necessary before tackling the subject. There are also references to the academic system and terminology which may affect understanding.

U.Renko
Messages
56
Reaction score
1
Hello.
I'm new here and I'm not sure if I should post this topic here or in general math, or anywhere else. Feel free to move the topic elsewhere if needed.

Just a bit of explanation first.
I'm not from USA (so forgive any grammar errors) and I don't understand completely your academic system with "minor-major" "freshman-senior-junior" and the such. Therefore I find it a little hard to explain "how far I am", but I guess you could call me a college freshman in a physics school (if that is how you call it).
Just to give an idea we're currently studying linear algebra, starting with multivariable calculus and finishing introductory mechanics.

Anyways, next semester my college will be offering a course on differential geometry and I want to know:

- How useful it is for physics major?
- what skills are necessary?
- should I try it or wait some more?

Well, that`s basically it.

Thanks in advance.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
U.Renko said:
Hello.
I'm new here and I'm not sure if I should post this topic here or in general math, or anywhere else. Feel free to move the topic elsewhere if needed.

Just a bit of explanation first.
I'm not from USA (so forgive any grammar errors) and I don't understand completely your academic system with "minor-major" "freshman-senior-junior" and the such. Therefore I find it a little hard to explain "how far I am", but I guess you could call me a college freshman in a physics school (if that is how you call it).
Just to give an idea we're currently studying linear algebra, starting with multivariable calculus and finishing introductory mechanics.

Anyways, next semester my college will be offering a course on differential geometry and I want to know:

- How useful it is for physics major?
- what skills are necessary?
- should I try it or wait some more?

Well, that`s basically it.

Thanks in advance.

Hello U.Renko and welcome to the forums.

Lets start off with something very basic, yet important that will help you understand this better: that is, the idea of distance.

In Cartesian geometry, it is very easy to measure the distance between two points: you use the pythagorean theorem in n dimensions.

But what happens when lines between points are not straight? You can't use the pythagorean theorem. What if you are trying to measure the difference between two points on a sphere like you do when you are measuring the distance between two cities on the opposite side of the world to each other? The distance is not a straight line distance, since you have to travel on the boundary of the sphere: you can't just go through the middle of the earth!

So how do you find the distance? Well if you do first year calculus, you learn about the concept of arc-length which allows you to find the length of a curve, and this is how you can use differential and integral calculus to find various properties of a geometry and also things like length with respect to a specific geometry, like for example a 2D sphere (like the earth) or maybe even a 3D sphere (you can't really picture that because it requires another dimension).

Now interestingly enough, relativity theory uses geometry that is not euclidean to describe space and time. Finding differences between different points is not as easy as doing a straight line calculation: it is a lot harder. But this is the theory that is used to describe these physical quantities, so physicists use this model, because so far it has been pretty good at being accurate.

With regard to other things, differential geometry can be used in optimization.

In many problems, we might want to minimize or maximize something that is dependent on a lot of constraints (mathematical rules). These things that we want to minimize or maximize might be represented with mathematical objects that are highly non-linear (think highly curved).

Now the problem may end up being a distance problem. We might have this really complicated mathematical object, it could even be in double digit dimensions. The problem will boil down to finding the shortest path from one point to the other given this highly complex object.

If we had a flat geometry, the answer is really simple: it's just the straight line path. But if its complicated and curvy, it's not so simple anymore!

I'll give you a concrete example.

Let's say you have someone that asks you what is the best route to work, and they give you a geometry that encodes the level of "resistance" when you travel along that path. You are given the geometry, and the two points, and you have to find the path that is the shortest since the shortest path will be the one that has the least amount of resistance.

You can model the above scenario in differential geometry. You could make it relatively simple or really complex by taking into account less or more variables, but the idea is still the same: minimize distance between points and find the path that gives us this solution. Also note that in some geometries, you can have more than one solution!

Now there is a lot more to differential geometry than this, but that should give you an idea of how it can be used.
 
It looks interesting and useful indeed.
according to the other threads its not a vey basic subject, so it would probably be better to wait a little bit?

Anyways, thanks a lot for the explanations
 
U.Renko said:
It looks interesting and useful indeed.
according to the other threads its not a vey basic subject, so it would probably be better to wait a little bit?

Anyways, thanks a lot for the explanations

You can still get some idea by looking at arc-length and its derivation to get an idea of finding the length of a path on some object. If you are curious you could derive the arc-length of various curves like distance between one point and another that both lie on a circle or an ellipse, and maybe if you are keen, to do it on a sphere. You don't have to find the shortest path, just use arc-length to find a path that you know what the answer will be "like a circular path", and that will help you see how calculus is used in this case.

It will get more complicated than this no doubt, but that doesn't mean that you can't get a good idea of what it is about.
 

Similar threads

  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
4K
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
2K
Replies
36
Views
11K
  • · Replies 16 ·
Replies
16
Views
4K
  • · Replies 20 ·
Replies
20
Views
3K
Replies
5
Views
4K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
6K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
2K
  • · Replies 6 ·
Replies
6
Views
3K