What Happens When a Laser Hits a Mirror Corner?

  • Thread starter Thread starter IK0
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Laser Mirror
AI Thread Summary
When a laser beam hits the intersection of two mirrors at a perfect corner, the reflection behavior becomes complex due to the theoretical nature of the scenario. The discussion highlights that a laser beam cannot have zero width, which complicates the reflection process, as each half of the beam would reflect off the mirrors. The conversation shifts to the atomic scale, suggesting that if the mirrors were atomically flat, the interaction would involve quantum mechanics rather than classical reflection principles. This leads to the conclusion that at such a small scale, the outcome of a photon hitting an atom would be probabilistic, requiring quantum mechanics to describe the interaction accurately. Ultimately, the scenario illustrates the limits of classical physics when applied to quantum phenomena.
IK0
Messages
5
Reaction score
0
Question: If you were to theoretically shine a laser into the intersection of two mirrors, what would happen to the reflected beam? When I say 'theoretically' I mean that the beam would hit the corner perfectly.

I'm confused by this because the derivative of a sharp point on a graph is undefined, so it would seem that there would be no real reflective surface angle off of which the beam could reflect.

Also, treat the laser as if it has zero width (essentially, treat it as a line).

This is not a homework question - it's just something I thought up.
~IKnowN0thingEDIT: I thought that this would fit better over in the logic section, so I re-posted it there.
 
Last edited:
Science news on Phys.org
Let's simplify things. I have an infinitely thin laser beam. I shine it at the very edge of the mirror... does it reflect, or does it miss the mirror?
 
You can't make a laser beam of zero width. As a result each half would reflect off that mirror.
 
What if you made a single beam of electrons, and, (for sake of the question) they were to hit the corner perfectly? (The uncertainty principle aside...)
 
Well, for your mirror intersection to also be a perfect geometrical line, they each have to be atomically flat, in which case you don't really have an interface at all. So are you just asking what happens when you hit an atom with an electron head on? If things get to this length scale you need quantum mechanics for a reason.
 
IK0 said:
I'm confused by this because the derivative of a sharp point...

Derivatives assume continuity. Matter can be considered continuous on a macroscopic scale, but on the molecular scale, we all know it's made of discrete atoms. At this point, you're talking about a single photon interacting with a single atom. This is where you need QM, and the answer will be a probability distribution for the outcome.
 
Oh I see. :)

Thanks for the help, this was really bugging me.
 

Similar threads

Back
Top