B What Happens When an Object on Earth Loses Mass Suddenly?

  • B
  • Thread starter Thread starter RedLine
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Earth Mass
AI Thread Summary
When an object on Earth suddenly loses mass, the effects depend on its properties. If the object is elastic, like a spring, it could expand away from the ground as potential energy is released. However, if the object is rigid, a sudden mass reduction would not cause it to rise, as the ground would also reduce its supporting force proportionately. The discussion emphasizes that while the scenario is theoretically interesting, it violates the laws of classical physics, making it difficult to provide a definitive answer. Ultimately, the behavior of elastic materials under reduced load can be predicted, but the premise of sudden mass loss remains inconsistent with known physics.
RedLine
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
Lets say a heavy object was resting on Earth and suddently it lost allot of mass.
Will the object go up? (The loss of mass happened instantly )
 
Physics news on Phys.org
RedLine said:
Will the object go up? (The loss of mass happened instantly )
If the object was being compressed by it's own weight (like a spring, the top would be compressing the lower coils) if that weight was instantly reduced the spring would expand away from the Earth as the potential energy is released from the spring.
 
On the other hand, if you simply mean an object, of mass M, sitting on the ground, reducing the mass of the object, the force of the object on the ground would be reduced but so would the force of the ground on the mass. The reduced mass would still sit on the ground, not moving.
 
However, regardless of whether or not the object is rigid or is elastic, there is no known mechanism which could cause a spontaneous loss of mass.
(Except perhaps a really tiny loss of mass over a long time if the object is radioactive and losing mass as some form of radiation.)
 
Let me rephrase the question in form of a problem.

A cube of mass 2t was sitting on some surface on Earth (so there is a force pulling it towards the center of the earth)Using the 2nd law of Newton the Earth would be pulling the objet with a force of 20kN.

And using the 3rd law of Newton the support would push the object with the same force.

If the mass of this cubic object changed to 1 kg instantly keeping the same volum.

Wouldn't the surface act as a spring at a molecular lvl and push the opject up and giving it velocity?

I understand that a suddent loss of mass can't happen but in theory what would happen?
 
RedLine said:
I understand that a suddent loss of mass can't happen but in theory what would happen?
What do the laws of physics predict if we violate the laws of physics?
That question does not have a meaningful answer.

If you put a two ton object on top of something with a mass of 1 kg, and rapidly lift the two ton object up, the 1 kg object below can jump up a bit, because the compressed floor and object will relax, pushing the object upwards.
 
  • Like
Likes Dale
RedLine said:
If the mass of this cubic object changed to 1 kg instantly keeping the same volum.
As has been pointed out, the question is not consistent with the laws of classical physics as we know them, so the question as posed cannot be answered.

However, what I think you are actually interested in can be answered: if an elastic material is compressed by a given load and if that load is suddenly reduced then the elastic material will decompress.
 

Similar threads

Back
Top