Amin2014
- 114
- 3
Assuming the point charge lies at the origin, what is the electric field at the origin? Zero or undefined?
I checked some books and you are right. However, I don't understand why we can't we just assign it a value of zero? After all, the charge cannot apply force on itself.BvU said:undefined
No, but it can apply force on a test charge, however close it comes...Amin2014 said:After all, the charge cannot apply force on itself
BvU said:There is the issue of size. Equal to zero for a point. Zero E would mean constant potential over some region with size. Contradiction !
I was validating your answer and completing it. The field would be zero only if the charge has dimensions.BvU said:Same difference: you refer to Gauss theorem: some charge density times zero volume. Doesn't fly when charge is within zero volume.