What is the Smallest Surface Area of a Crate Delivered by Canada Post?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion revolves around calculating the smallest surface area (SA) of a crate that Canada Post will deliver, adhering to a maximum combined length and girth of 297 cm. Participants clarify that girth is defined as 2(l + w), where l is length and w is width, and that the equation for SA is 2(wh + lw + lh). There is confusion about how to manipulate the equations to eliminate variables, with suggestions to either use derivatives or the Lagrange Multiplier method. The conversation emphasizes the need to correctly set up and solve the equations to find the optimal dimensions for the crate. Understanding the constraints and applying the right mathematical techniques is crucial for determining the smallest SA.
S.R
Messages
81
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


Canada Post will deliver parcels only if they are less than a certain maximum size: the combined length and girth cannot exceed 297 cm (Girth is the total distance around the cross-section of the parcel). Canada Post delivers a crate with the smallest SA to your house. What is the SA of the crate in square meters?

Homework Equations


Girth of a rectangular prism=2(w+h) -> Web-search
I'm still unclear on what a girth is, however. Maybe it is 2(l+w), the perimeter of the base.

The Attempt at a Solution


I set-up the equations:

l+2(w+h)=297

SA=2(wh+lw+lh)

I'm unsure how to proceed. Any help is appreciated. Thanks!

S.R
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
S.R said:

Homework Statement


Canada Post will deliver parcels only if they are less than a certain maximum size: the combined length and girth cannot exceed 297 cm (Girth is the total distance around the cross-section of the parcel). Canada Post delivers a crate with the smallest SA to your house. What is the SA of the crate in square meters?
The smallest? You say that Canada Post will not deliver packages above a certain size but they can be as small as you please. Are you asking for the smallest surface are of a package that meets the maximum sum of length and girth?

Homework Equations


Girth of a rectangular prism=2(w+h) -> Web-search
I'm still unclear on what a girth is, however. Maybe it is 2(l+w), the perimeter of the base.
Yes. assuming you are taking h as the longest side, "girth" is 2(l+ w) so the requirement is that h+ 2(l+w)\le 297.

The Attempt at a Solution


I set-up the equations:

l+2(w+h)=297
Hey, you switched h and l on me!

SA=2(wh+lw+lh)

I'm unsure how to proceed. Any help is appreciated. Thanks!

S.R
Proceed in either of two ways:
1) use l+ 2*(w+ h)= 297 (or h+ 2(w+ l)= 297) to eliminate one of the three variables leaving only two. Set the partial derivatives with respect to the two variables equal to 0 and solve the two equations.

2) Use the "Lagrange Multiplier" method. Form the gradient of the "object function", 2(wh+ lw+ lh), the gradient of the constraint, l+ 2(w+h), and set one equal to a constant (\lambda times the other.
 
HallsofIvy said:
Proceed in either of two ways:
1) use l+2*(w+ h)= 297 (or h+ 2(w+ l)= 297) to eliminate one of the three variables leaving only two. Set the partial derivatives with respect to the two variables equal to 0 and solve the two equations.

I'm not sure how to eliminate one of the three variables?
 
Last edited:

Similar threads

Back
Top