henpen
- 50
- 0
I post in the QM section as an answer in terms of photons rather than just EM waves would be better.
The discussion revolves around the nature of reflection at the microscopic level, particularly focusing on the interaction of photons and electromagnetic (EM) waves with materials. Participants explore various theoretical frameworks, including quantum mechanics and classical electrodynamics, to understand the processes involved in reflection and refraction, especially in solid-state contexts.
Participants express differing views on the best framework for understanding reflection, with some advocating for a photon-centric approach and others emphasizing classical wave descriptions. There is no consensus on the most effective model or explanation.
Participants highlight the complexity of quantum mechanical interactions in solids and the varying interpretations of classical electrodynamics, indicating that assumptions about the nature of light and materials may influence the discussion.
henpen said:I post in the QM section as an answer in terms of photons rather than just EM waves would be better.
FeynmanIsCool said:Classical Electrodynamics by JD Jackson will give you a detailed mathematical overview in terms of photons I believe
Vanadium 50 said:Have you read Jackson? There is very little in it on photons.