Why do hurricanes rotate counter-clockwise?

In summary, the rotation of winds in the northern and southern hemispheres is attributed to the Coriolis effect, which causes objects in a rotating frame of reference to appear to be deflected. This effect is observed in artillery shells and hurricanes, with the rotation of the latter being counter-clockwise in the northern hemisphere and clockwise in the southern hemisphere. However, the direction of rotation is also influenced by the differential velocities of the surrounding atmosphere, with winds near the equator moving faster and those near the poles moving slower. The deflection of artillery shells due to the Coriolis effect is similar to the deflection of hurricane winds, with both being caused by the same phenomenon. Low pressure zones in the northern hemisphere rotate counter-clockwise,
  • #1
warrenchu000
14
9
In the northern hemisphere, they rotate counter-clockwise. In the southern hemisphere, they rotate clockwise. This is often attributed to the Coriolis effect, an apparent deflection of moving objects in a rotating frame of reference. While this is true for deflected artillery shells, it is NOT the reason for hurricane rotating COUNTER-CLOCKWISE. In fact, they should rotate CLOCKWISE in the same way artillery shells are deflected in the ABSENCE of the surrounding atmosphere. But it is the DIFFERENTIAL VELOCITIES of the surrounding atmosphere that CARRIES the hurricane winds in their direction, with the atmosphere moving FASTER nearer to the equator and SLOWER nearer to the pole in the west to east direction.
So in the northern hemisphere, as winds blow toward the center of the hurricane, the wind is carried (west-to-east speed sped up) westward when traveling south and carried (west-to-east speed slowed down) eastward when traveling north.
If there was no surrounding atmosphere to carry the winds, the opposite would happen. The hurricane would appear to rotate CLOCKWISE as a result of viewing it in a non-inertial frame and of the pseudo force known as the Coriolis force. Therefore it is incorrect to attribute the rotation of hurricanes to the Coriolis force.
 
Last edited:
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
An artillary shell going South in the Northern hemisphere will drift right (to the West) due to Coreolus. That is the same as the atmosphere being drawn South into a low pressure zone of a hurricane. That gives a counter-clockwise spin to a hurricane. The artillary shell drift and the hurricane spin are in agreement and both are due to Coreolus.
 
  • #3
warrenchu000 said:
it is NOT the reason for hurricane rotating COUNTER-CLOCKWISE. In fact, they should rotate CLOCKWISE
They do both. The wind near the surface flowing towards the centre and the wind at the top flowing away have opposite rotations. Since the Coriolis force on the N hemisphere results in all paths curving to the right, the direction of airflow (towards or away from the centre) results in opposite rotations.
The observation is in agreement with the physics. I'm not sure why you think it isn't.

warrenchu000 said:
In fact, they should rotate CLOCKWISE in the same way artillery shells are deflected in the ABSENCE of the surrounding atmosphere.
Shells and bullets don't fly in vacuum, but through the atmosphere, so I don't know what you're talking about here.
You can't attribute 'rotation' to Coriolis deflection of a single shell. They get deflected to the left (S) or to the right (N). You'd need to shoot two shells w/r to some common point of origin or the target, to indicate a rotating pattern, and the direction of shooting towards or away from that point will determine rotation.

Try drawing it all out.
 
  • #4
Bandersnatch said:
They do both. The wind near the surface flowing towards the centre and the wind at the top flowing away have opposite rotations. Since the Coriolis force on the N hemisphere results in all paths curving to the right, the direction of airflow (towards or away from the centre) results in opposite rotations.
The observation is in agreement with the physics. I'm not sure why you think it isn't.Shells and bullets don't fly in vacuum, but through the atmosphere, so I don't know what you're talking about here.
You can't attribute 'rotation' to Coriolis deflection of a single shell. They get deflected to the left (S) or to the right (N). You'd need to shoot two shells w/r to some common point of origin or the target, to indicate a rotating pattern, and the direction of shooting towards or away from that point will determine rotation.

Try drawing it all out.
The deflection of artillery shells is due to the Coriolis effect. They are deflected to the east when aimed south. This would be like winds in a high pressure center blowing in a counter-clockwise direction - which they do not.
 
  • #5
FactChecker said:
An artillary shell going South in the Northern hemisphere will drift right (to the West) due to Coreolus. That is the same as the atmosphere being drawn South into a low pressure zone of a hurricane. That gives a counter-clockwise spin to a hurricane. The artillary shell drift and the hurricane spin are in agreement and both are due to Coreolus.
No. The artillery shell going south would drift to towards east.
 
  • #6
warrenchu000 said:
In the northern hemisphere, they rotate counter-clockwise. In the southern hemisphere, they rotate clockwise.

More generally, this is true of all cyclones.
 
  • #8
warrenchu000 said:
The deflection of artillery shells is due to the Coriolis effect. They are deflected to the east when aimed south.
warrenchu000 said:
No. The artillery shell going south would drift to towards east.
If you mean on the N hemisphere, then that's wrong. The Earth is rotating towards the east. Deflection is westwards.
 
  • #9
warrenchu000 said:
No. The artillery shell going south would drift to towards east.
Use math. The coriolis acceleration is ##2 v \times \Omega##. For a shell fired horizontally south from 45 degrees north latitude ##v## is due south and horizontal, ##\Omega## is north, but inclined 45 degrees up, so ##v \times \Omega## is horizontal and due west.
 
  • #10
Not mentioned yet is that in the northern hemisphere, low pressure zones rotate counter-clockwise, while high pressure zones rotate clockwise.
 
  • Like
Likes FactChecker
  • #11
warrenchu000 said:
No. The artillery shell going south would drift to towards east.

A shell launched straight south had a lower eastward velocity at launch than the points on the Earth's surface south of it. That is, the ground south of the shell's launch location is moving eastward faster than the ground at the launch point. An extreme example is to launch the shell from the north pole, which has zero east velocity. So as the shell flies south, it sees the velocity of the ground underneath it gradually increase from zero. So, since the ground is moving eastward from the shell's point of view, the shell is moving westward from the ground's point of view, and vice-versa when the shell is launched to the north. Thus leading to a rightward curving path, which is westward when moving south and eastward when moving north.
 
  • Like
  • Love
Likes physicsponderer and FactChecker
  • #12
warrenchu000 said:
In the northern hemisphere, they rotate counter-clockwise. In the southern hemisphere, they rotate clockwise. This is often attributed to the Coriolis effect, an apparent deflection of moving objects in a rotating frame of reference. While this is true for deflected artillery shells, it is NOT the reason for hurricane rotating COUNTER-CLOCKWISE. In fact, they should rotate CLOCKWISE in the same way artillery shells are deflected in the ABSENCE of the surrounding atmosphere. But it is the DIFFERENTIAL VELOCITIES of the surrounding atmosphere that CARRIES the hurricane winds in their direction, with the atmosphere moving FASTER nearer to the equator and SLOWER nearer to the pole in the west to east direction.
So in the northern hemisphere, as winds blow toward the center of the hurricane, the wind is carried (west-to-east speed sped up) westward when traveling south and carried (west-to-east speed slowed down) eastward when traveling north.
If there was no surrounding atmosphere to carry the winds, the opposite would happen. The hurricane would appear to rotate CLOCKWISE as a result of viewing it in a non-inertial frame and of the pseudo force known as the Coriolis force. Therefore it is incorrect to attribute the rotation of hurricanes to the Coriolis force.
My apologies to everyone. I was wrong. The above description is indeed the Coriolis effect, including the atmospheric effect. Thanks to those who made me realize my error.
 
  • Like
Likes physicsponderer, Bandersnatch, Drakkith and 3 others

1. Why do hurricanes rotate counter-clockwise?

Hurricanes rotate counter-clockwise due to the Coriolis effect. This is a phenomenon caused by the Earth's rotation, which deflects moving objects to the right in the Northern Hemisphere and to the left in the Southern Hemisphere.

2. What is the Coriolis effect?

The Coriolis effect is a force that causes objects, such as hurricanes, to appear to curve to the right in the Northern Hemisphere and to the left in the Southern Hemisphere. It is caused by the Earth's rotation.

3. Can hurricanes rotate clockwise?

Yes, in the Southern Hemisphere, hurricanes rotate clockwise due to the Coriolis effect. However, in the Northern Hemisphere, they always rotate counter-clockwise.

4. Are there any exceptions to the rotation of hurricanes?

Yes, some smaller storms, such as tropical depressions and tropical storms, may not have a clearly defined rotation due to weaker winds. However, once a storm strengthens into a hurricane, it will always rotate due to the Coriolis effect.

5. Do all hurricanes rotate the same way?

No, hurricanes in the Northern Hemisphere rotate counter-clockwise, while those in the Southern Hemisphere rotate clockwise. This is due to the opposite direction of the Coriolis effect in each hemisphere.

Similar threads

Replies
38
Views
4K
Replies
39
Views
3K
Replies
23
Views
948
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
9
Views
7K
Replies
3
Views
4K
Replies
17
Views
60K
Replies
5
Views
1K
Replies
16
Views
6K
  • Mechanics
Replies
17
Views
11K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
1
Views
2K
Back
Top