Why Does Whiskey and Water Swap Despite Being Miscible?

  • Thread starter Thread starter In_Development
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Density Fluid
AI Thread Summary
The discussion explores the phenomenon of whiskey and water appearing to swap despite both being miscible due to the presence of ethanol. The key point raised is the role of density differences and how they affect the mixing process, suggesting that the specific gravity of the liquids plays a significant role. It is noted that diffusion occurs slowly, and the limited contact area between the two liquids during the trick minimizes effective mixing. The presence of stabilizers or emulsifiers in whiskey is questioned, as whiskey already contains a substantial amount of water. Overall, the interaction between density and diffusion is central to understanding this mixing behavior.
In_Development
Messages
13
Reaction score
0
Ok, my question arises after seeing this Youtube video (you need to see it to understand what I am talking about):

This may be a part physics, part chemistry question.

Now, I know that ethanol and water are miscible. I also know that in whiskey, you find both ethanol and water. How come, therefore, when he performs the trick in question such a 'swapping' occurs?

Is it because the difference in density somehow overrides the 'diffusion' of the liquids or something?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
I am not completely familiar with all of the ingredients in whiskey, but there could possibly be some kind of stabilizer or emulsifier that allows the two to be in solution together in whiskey. The trick you saw was a binary system. That makes it very easy to see the differences in specific gravity coming into play.
 
Cool trick. I think diffussion is a slow process, so what little takes place during the time the whiskey and water are in contact probably isn't noticable. Also they're only in contact only at the edges of their flows. Efficient mixing often isn't easy to accomplish. and this setup minimizes the opportunity.

I doubt if the idea of an emulsifier applies. Depending on the proof of the whiskey, there's already a fair bit of water in there.
 
So I know that electrons are fundamental, there's no 'material' that makes them up, it's like talking about a colour itself rather than a car or a flower. Now protons and neutrons and quarks and whatever other stuff is there fundamentally, I want someone to kind of teach me these, I have a lot of questions that books might not give the answer in the way I understand. Thanks
Back
Top