Why doesn't a charge repel a magnetic field in this example?

Join the discussion
Ask a follow-up here, or get your own question answered by working scientists, mathematicians and engineers — people, not an autocomplete.
Real named experts · corrections over time · the nuance an AI answer skips
7 replies · 2K views
Samson4
Messages
242
Reaction score
15
The example:
An electron is trapped in a magnetic field. The electron travels along a circle in a clockwise path. It's my understanding that there is a magnetic field around the electron also circulating in a clockwise direction perpendicular to it's path. Now if this electron was in a conductor, the conductor would have a magnetic field opposing the original magnetic field. So, why doesn't the electron?

Untitled.png
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Samson4 said:
The example:
An electron is trapped in a magnetic field. The electron travels along a circle in a clockwise path. It's my understanding that there is a magnetic field around the electron also circulating in a clockwise direction perpendicular to it's path. Now if this electron was in a conductor, the conductor would have a magnetic field opposing the original magnetic field. So, why doesn't the electron?

View attachment 111533
Does not the electron perform a spiral as a result of what you are saying?
 
tech99 said:
Does not the electron perform a spiral as a result of what you are saying?
It will spiral if it has a parallel component to it's velocity.
 
Samson4 said:
The example:
An electron is trapped in a magnetic field. The electron travels along a circle in a clockwise path. It's my understanding that there is a magnetic field around the electron also circulating in a clockwise direction perpendicular to it's path. Now if this electron was in a conductor, the conductor would have a magnetic field opposing the original magnetic field. So, why doesn't the electron?

View attachment 111533
For the case of the loop of wire, the magnetic field inside the loop points in the opposite direction to that outside it. So overall, I don't think it has a force on it.
The single electron does seem to have a resultant force causing it to spiral, because it is acting like a loop edge-on to the magnetic field.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: ORF
tech99 said:
For the case of the loop of wire, the magnetic field inside the loop points in the opposite direction to that outside it. So overall, I don't think it has a force on it.
The single electron does seem to have a resultant force causing it to spiral, because it is acting like a loop edge-on to the magnetic field.
On my second point, I don't think I am correct here. The electron has opposite fields above and below it, so presumably these cancel.
 
Normally, you neglect the effect of a particle's field on itself. If you had more than one electron, then you would have to consider the effect of the electrons' fields on each other.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Samson4
I think the electron did work against its own field when it was accelerated to its present velocity and this energy is now mostly stored in its magnetic field.
 
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: Samson4
I see now that the magnetic field of the electron is reinforced on 1 side, according to the left hand rule. This makes since for the electron to curve away from that side without experiencing a net repulsion.