Why Doesn't Earth Stop Turning?

  • Thread starter Thread starter scientifico
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Earth
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on why Earth continues to rotate despite the forces acting on it. It clarifies that centripetal and centrifugal forces are not real forces but conditions for circular motion, and the emission of radiation by accelerating charges does not significantly apply to Earth as a whole. The Earth emits gravitational waves, resulting in a minuscule energy loss of about 200 watts, which theoretically decreases its orbital radius by a tiny amount over time. Questions arise regarding the conservation of angular momentum and the relationship between energy loss and changes in mass or radius. Ultimately, the conversation emphasizes that the Earth’s rotation remains stable despite these factors.
scientifico
Messages
181
Reaction score
0
Hello, according to the classic physics a body subjected to an acceleration must dispers energy, the Earth is subjected to a centripetal and centrifugal force so why it doesn't stop to turn ?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
I'm not sure what exact law of classical physics you're referring to but it doesn't sound correct.

On a similar subject, centripetal/centrifugal 'forces' are not physically real forces like electromagnetism or gravity. The former is actually a condition for circular motion, and the latter is the result when you analyse a problem in a rotating coordinate system.
 
probably i got the law in a wrong way, i have read that according to classical physics an electron emits energy in form of radiations because of it's acceleration and should fall into the nucleus
 
Ah, yes, it is true that an accelerating charge will emit electromagnetic radiation and lose energy in the process (a result from electrodynamics). It's a result you can derive from Maxwell's equations.

I'm not sure how this applies to a planet which is, after all, rotating and made up of charged particles (though the planet as a whole is more or less electrically neutral). Perhaps the effect cancels, or the accelerations are far too minute to produce a measurable effect?

Someone else will hopefully have a better answer!
 
The Earth is extremely close to neutral, all charges are accelerated in a similar way, so we do not emit (significant) electromagnetic radiation based on our orbit around the sun.

Earth has a gravitational charge (=a mass), and emits gravitational waves. However, Earth is slow relative to the speed of light and gravity is weak, so the lost power is tiny: just ~200W. If there would be no other effects on the orbit, the radius of Earth would decrease by about 1 femtometer per day. About 2 millimeters in the whole lifetime of the solar system.
 
does emission of gravitational waves involve loss of matter ?
 
Last edited:
If you try to see the whole solar system as one object, you could say that its mass gets reduced.
However, if you consider masses in the solar system: No. It involves a loss of energy.
 
Is this loss of energy manifested as a reduction in the angular velocity of the planet? (edit- or at least a reduction in angular momentum if the radius decreases- but how does the radius decrease?)

And if so... how is angular momentum conserved? How can gravitational waves compensate for this loss of angular momentum if they're directed radially outwards?
 
Last edited:
mfb said:
However, if you consider masses in the solar system: No. It involves a loss of energy.
So why the Earth radius shoud decrease 1 femtometer per day ?
 
  • #10
The Earth loses orbital energy.

@MikeyW: No, it is independent of the rotation of earth, the 200 W come from its orbit around the sun.

How can gravitational waves compensate for this loss of angular momentum if they're directed radially outwards?
They do not have a perfect radial symmetry.
 
  • #11
why if it just loses energy it loses matter too ?
 
  • #12
Why should it lose matter?
 
  • #13
because the redius decrease... or maybe the matter doesn't lose and the radius became more compact
 
  • #14
?

The orbital radius of Earth decreases - the Earth comes closer to the sun. Why do you expect any influence on its mass?
 
  • #15
Oh, i tought it was the Earth radius :)
 
Back
Top