Why don’t two protons bind together?

  • I
  • Thread starter Kostik
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Protons
In summary, the lack of a stable helium-2 nucleus can be attributed to the Pauli principle and the spin coupling of nucleons. Because nucleons are fermions, the state of a two-particle system must be antisymmetric. This means that only certain combinations of isospin and spin states are allowed. It turns out that the spin-triplet state is energetically preferred, while the spin-singlet state does not lead to a bound state. This is due to the nucleon-nucleon interactions and the weak binding of deuterium. As a result, only deuterium nuclei with spin-1 exist, indicating that bound states of two protons or two neutrons are not possible.
  • #1
Kostik
58
6
TL;DR Summary
If the nuclear force is many times stronger than the electrical force, why don’t two protons form a stable helium-2 nucleus?
If the nuclear force is many times stronger than the electrical force, why don’t two protons form a stable helium-2 nucleus?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
It does not even have to do with the electrostatic repulsion of the protons. This you can simply see from the fact that there is also no bound state of two neutrons, where the electromagnetic force does not enter at all.

The reason why you do not have a helium-2 nucleus has to do with the Pauli principle and the spin coupling of the nucleons.

Because nucleons are fermions, the state of the two-particle system must be antisymmetric under swapping the two particles. The possible isospin states are

triplet (symmetric)

[tex]|pp>, |nn>, \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\bigl(|pn>+|np>\bigr)[/tex]
(the first is a helium-2 nucleus, the second a deuteron, and the third a deuterium nucleus (not really, as we will see later))

singlet (antisymmetric)
[tex] \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\bigl(|pn>-|np>\bigr)[/tex]
(a deuterium nucleus)

the possible spin states are
triplet (symmetric)

[tex]|\uparrow\uparrow>, |\downarrow\downarrow>, \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\bigl(|\uparrow\downarrow>+|\downarrow\uparrow>\bigr)[/tex]
(spin-1, all three are just related by spatial rotations)

singlet (antisymmetric)
[tex] \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\bigl(|\uparrow\downarrow>-|\downarrow\uparrow>\bigr)[/tex]
(spin-0)

Total antisymmetry of the state implies that we have to combine either an isospion-triplet with a spin-singelt or an isospin-singlet with a spin-triplet.

Now it turns out that the spin-triplet(spin-1) is energetically preferred, while the spin-singlet (spin-0) does not lead to a bound state. Unfortunately I can not really give you an explanation of this now, I would have to look it up, but you can just see it from the fact that that there does not exist a spin-0 deuterium nucleus. All deuterium nuclei have spin 1. That means that the isospion state of the the deuterium is ##\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\bigl(|pn>-|np>\bigr)## and NOT ##\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\bigl(|pn>+|np>\bigr)##.

That the spin is symmetric implies that the isospin has to be antisymmetric. But the states ##|pp>## (helium-2) and ##|nn>## (deuteron) are symmetric. So the fact that we find only deuterium nuclei with spin-1 directly tells us that we cannot have bound states of two protons or two neutrons.
 
  • Like
  • Informative
Likes Astronuc, dlgoff, DaveE and 5 others
  • #3
I don't think you can make such a claim based on just the symmetry -antisymmetry. Of course you can use it, but it will not get you to the answer. The Pauli's principle only tells you that the total wavefunction must be antisymmetric. This doesn't tell you if something is realized or not (except for if it is breaking something completely). You have also omitted the spatial momentum and thus the spatial parity which makes it a little more complicated, but the answer is in the "spin" couplings of the nucleon-nucleon interactions. The pauli's principle only let's you pick certain states to compare against each other.
What one would have to do is pick up the potential energies, get the energy eigenvalues of the configurations with [itex]T=1[/itex] (where nn, pp "live" in), do the same for [itex]T=0[/itex] (where the deuterium is) and figure out that their difference is more than 2MeV (binding energy of Deuterium)... Interested people can have a look in 6.2 here:
https://www.physics.umd.edu/courses/Phys741/xji/chapter6.pdf
about what kind of potential they could take. The big problem of "deuterium" is that a pretty weakly-bound state... If it wasn't so weakly bound, then maybe we would be able to see its "excitations" (and so even the nn/pp bound states which would be degenerate)
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes Astronuc and vanhees71
  • #4
Indeed, the deuterium potential has only one bound state.
 
  • #5
What could be stated is what the strong force resists is above all not electromagnetic repulsion, but zero point movement.
 
  • Skeptical
Likes mfb and Vanadium 50

1. Why don't two protons bind together?

Two protons do not bind together because of the repulsive force between them. Protons have a positive charge, and like charges repel each other. This repulsive force is much stronger than the attractive force between them, preventing them from binding together.

2. Can two protons ever bind together?

In certain extreme conditions, such as in the core of a star or in a particle accelerator, two protons can overcome their repulsive force and bind together. This process is known as nuclear fusion and is responsible for the energy production in stars.

3. Why do protons bind together in the nucleus?

Protons bind together in the nucleus because of the strong nuclear force. This force is much stronger than the repulsive force between protons and is able to overcome it, keeping the protons together in the nucleus.

4. How is the strong nuclear force different from the electromagnetic force?

The strong nuclear force is different from the electromagnetic force in terms of strength and range. The strong nuclear force is much stronger than the electromagnetic force, but it has a very short range and only acts on particles within the nucleus. The electromagnetic force, on the other hand, has a longer range and acts on all charged particles, including protons.

5. What happens when two protons collide?

When two protons collide, they can either scatter off each other or undergo nuclear fusion. The outcome depends on the energy of the collision. At low energies, the protons will scatter, but at high energies, they can fuse together to form a heavier nucleus.

Similar threads

  • High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics
Replies
28
Views
2K
  • High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics
Replies
2
Views
575
  • High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics
Replies
1
Views
776
  • High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics
Replies
5
Views
1K
Replies
6
Views
766
  • High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics
Replies
12
Views
1K
  • High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics
Replies
12
Views
3K
  • High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics
Replies
17
Views
2K
  • High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • High Energy, Nuclear, Particle Physics
Replies
9
Views
3K
Back
Top