Why heat can't be expressed as exact differential function?

In summary: It is also a function of any two thermodynamic coordinates because it is a state function, meaning its value only depends on the state of the system and not the path taken to reach that state. Therefore, it can be expressed as an exact differential function. In summary, the differential of internal energy is an exact differential function and can be expressed as a function of any two thermodynamic coordinates due to its nature as a state function.
  • #1
manimaran1605
60
0
(1) Why differential of work, heat can't be expressed as exact differential function?
(2) How differential of internal energy is an exact differential function and how it is a function of any
two of thermodynamics coordinates?
 
Science news on Phys.org
  • #2
manimaran1605 said:
(1) Why differential of work, heat can't be expressed as exact differential function?

Because work and heat individually depend on the path taken or process considered. There are countless examples of this all around you.

manimaran1605 said:
(2) How differential of internal energy is an exact differential function and how it is a function of any
two of thermodynamics coordinates?

Internal energy is defined to be a state function, there's nothing deeper to it. It wouldn't even make sense to call it internal energy if it wasn't a state function. Also it isn't true that the internal energy is necessarily a function of only two thermodynamic coordinates. In general ##U = U(S,x_1,...,x_n)## where ##x_i## are a set of generalized coordinates so one requires ##n+1## coordinates, including ##S## in the usual energy representation, and performing Legendre transforms to go to e.g. the Helmholtz or Gibbs representations will not change this. In the Helmholtz representation for example we would have ##F = F(T,x_1,...,x_n)## where ##F## is as usual the Helmholtz free energy. Of course the choice of ##S## for ##U## and the choice of
##T## for ##F## are just a matter of convenience for that specific thermodynamic potential and its associated fundamental relation (although not necessarily convenient for experiment). Indeed I can just as well write ##U = U(T,x_1,...,x_n)## if I wish by inverting ##S## as a function of ##T## but I still need ##n+1## variables.

Mathematically, ##U## is entirely determined by the equations of state and the heat capacity.
 
  • Like
Likes 1 person

1. Why can't heat be expressed as an exact differential function?

Heat is not a state function, meaning it is not solely dependent on the current state of a system. Instead, it is a process function, as it is dependent on the path taken to reach a certain state. This makes it impossible to express as an exact differential function, as the value of heat will vary depending on the specific path taken.

2. What is an exact differential function?

An exact differential function is a mathematical concept used in thermodynamics to represent state functions, which are properties of a system that are determined solely by the current state of the system and not how it got there. These functions can be expressed as the total differential of a quantity, meaning that the change in the quantity is independent of the path taken.

3. What are some examples of state functions?

Some examples of state functions include temperature, pressure, volume, and internal energy. These properties are determined solely by the current state of the system and are not affected by the path taken to reach that state. They can be expressed as exact differential functions.

4. How is heat different from other state functions?

Unlike other state functions, heat is not solely dependent on the current state of the system. It is a process function, meaning it is dependent on the path taken to reach a certain state. This makes it impossible to express as an exact differential function, as the value of heat will vary depending on the specific path taken.

5. Can heat be treated as a state function in any situation?

No, heat cannot be treated as a state function in any situation. While it may be possible to approximate heat as a state function in some cases, it is not a true state function and cannot be expressed as an exact differential function. Heat should always be treated as a process function in thermodynamics.

Similar threads

Replies
27
Views
426
Replies
1
Views
882
Replies
1
Views
920
  • Thermodynamics
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
2
Views
462
Replies
1
Views
824
Replies
2
Views
1K
  • Thermodynamics
Replies
5
Views
15K
Replies
3
Views
806
  • Thermodynamics
Replies
15
Views
1K
Back
Top