Teaching General Relativity to Undergraduates: AAPT Topical Conference Recap

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the teaching of General Relativity (GR) at the undergraduate level, questioning why it is not offered as a standalone course despite its significance. Participants note that GR is typically introduced in introductory modern physics classes, but many believe it should follow classical mechanics and electrodynamics, ideally before quantum mechanics. The prerequisites for GR courses vary, with some institutions allowing enrollment after completing advanced classical mechanics and relevant math courses. Experiences shared indicate that GR does not require prior knowledge of quantum mechanics, and some students find GR to be less mathematically intense compared to other upper-level physics courses. A recent AAPT Topical Conference focused on the challenges and methodologies of teaching GR to undergraduates, highlighting ongoing discussions in the academic community about its curriculum placement and pedagogical approaches.
Benzoate
Messages
418
Reaction score
0
taught at the undergraduate level? I know its introduce in the intro modern physics class you taken, but why doesn't General relativity have its on class?Shouldn't general relativity be taught after you just taken your classical mechanics and electrodynamics courses and shouldn't it be taught before you begin your quantum mechanics courses?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
At least at my college (Yale), it is. The prereqs for both quantum and GR is just advanced classical mechanics. I personally think they fit well in either order, because they do not build on each other in the slightest. They both introduce new math, and I don't think either is harder than the other, in my experience.
 
at my school (UMASS) you can take a generl relativity course which is at the 500 level (translates as either advanced undergrad or first year grad) this coming semester I will be taking it concurrently with classical mechanics, and quantum mechanics.
 
I took a GR course as a fourth-year undergrad. The pre-req's were 2nd year mechanics and math courses in ODEs and vector calculus. You definitely don't need GR to do quantum!

The professor who taught the course I took had worked with Hartle, so we were the guinea pigs for his textbook the year before it came out in print. It was actually one of the less mathematically-intense upper level physics courses I took!
 
This was the focus of a recent AAPT Topical Conference "TEACHING GENERAL RELATIVITY TO UNDERGRADUATES":
http://www.aapt-doorway.org/TGRU/

(I contributed an entry to the PF blog about it and the rest of the main AAPT meeting
https://www.physicsforums.com/blog/2006/07/30/aapt-syracuse-2006/ )
 
Last edited by a moderator:
After a year of thought, I decided to adjust my ratio for applying the US/EU(+UK) schools. I mostly focused on the US schools before, but things are getting complex and I found out that Europe is also a good place to study. I found some institutes that have professors with similar interests. But gaining the information is much harder than US schools (like you have to contact professors in advance etc). For your information, I have B.S. in engineering (low GPA: 3.2/4.0) in Asia - one SCI...
Bit Britain-specific but I was wondering, what's the best path to take for A-Levels out of the following (I know Y10 seems a bit early to be thinking about A-levels, but my choice will impact what I do this year/ in y11) I (almost) definitely want to do physics at University - so keep that in mind... The subjects that I'm almost definitely going to take are Maths, Further Maths and Physics, and I'm taking a fast track programme which means that I'll be taking AS computer science at the end...
I graduated with a BSc in Physics in 2020. Since there were limited opportunities in my country (mostly teaching), I decided to improve my programming skills and began working in IT, first as a software engineer and later as a quality assurance engineer, where I’ve now spent about 3 years. While this career path has provided financial stability, I’ve realized that my excitement and passion aren’t really there, unlike what I felt when studying or doing research in physics. Working in IT...

Similar threads

Replies
3
Views
1K
Replies
28
Views
3K
Replies
6
Views
2K
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
9
Views
2K
Replies
0
Views
2K
Replies
35
Views
10K
Back
Top