Why the Earth moves around the Sun forever and ever and ever?

  • B
  • Thread starter parshyaa
  • Start date
  • #1
307
19
why earth moves around sun forever and ever and ever.
My attempt for answer:
  • Earth wants to move in straight Line forever and ever and ever(as there is no ext. Force)but due to massive sun space get bends(according to GR) and moving earth starts moves in circle(or not perfect circle) , as it was moving in straight line forever and ever and ever it continues so in circle
I want the main answer for why earth moves forever and ever and ever,why shape do not makes any effect .​
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
russ_watters
Mentor
19,932
6,402
Newton's first law.
 
  • Like
Likes parshyaa and Bystander
  • #4
307
19
You mean my reason is correct
You mean, there is no effect of shape occured by sun in space and time, earliar it was moving in st. Line forever and ever and ever which it still continues in circle also
 
  • #5
russ_watters
Mentor
19,932
6,402
Is this homework? The wording implies two different questions at two different levels. The "forever and ever and ever" part implies to me that that is the main question, not the "why earth moves around sun" part. So I was answering that part.

The level of the second part imlpies a lower level for the first part: I would not use General Relativity as an answer to why the earth is in orbit, I'd use Newton's law of gravity. And the two parts become very related to each other when using Newton's Laws of gravity and motion.
 
  • #6
307
19
Is this homework? The wording implies two different questions at two different levels. The "forever and ever and ever" part implies to me that that is the main question, not the "why earth moves around sun" part. So I was answering that part.

The level of the second part imlpies a lower level for the first part: I would not use General Relativity as an answer to why the earth is in orbit, I'd use Newton's law of gravity. And the two parts become very related to each other when using Newton's Laws of gravity and motion.
No its not a HW question , I just wanted to know that newtons first law say that object without any force will be in motion in a straight Line forever and ever, so is it true when its path becomes circular due to bending of space by sun .
 
  • #7
sophiecentaur
Science Advisor
Gold Member
25,160
4,800
Earth wants to move in straight Line
It is essential to realise the nothing inanimate "wants" to do anything. Anthropomorphism can get in the way of understanding things. You can choose between a Newtonian explanation of orbits or a GR explanation - each one has its place.
Things will go on 'for ever and ever' unless there is some energy loss involved. The loss of energy in the Earth / Sun system is very very low and the orbit will decay by an insignificant degree in our time scale (undetectable until quite recently). But there are loss mechanisms even in astronomical processes and everything changes in time.
 
  • #8
541
145
I want the main answer for why earth moves forever and ever and ever,why shape do not makes any effect .
I'm not sure what "shape" you are referring to here. Shape of the orbit?

If space were a true vacuum, then it would move forever as there are no dissipative forces. In reality, since space is not a true vacuum, over a long time the earth's orbit would change due to collisions with particles in its path around the sun. That would be a very long time.
 
  • #9
307
19
I'm not sure what "shape" you are referring to here. Shape of the orbit?
.
yes the circular orbit , newtons law says that it will move forever and ever and ever in a straight line but here the path or orbit becomes circular then also earth moves forever and ever and ever,why??
main-qimg-65276e2942c653d621e0bd0ac1d665ef?convert_to_webp=true.png
 
  • #10
russ_watters
Mentor
19,932
6,402
The shape is due to gravity pulling it into a circular (elliptical) path. The "forever and ever" is due to there being no force opposing the motion (if we stick to circular).
 
  • #11
307
19
The shape is due to gravity pulling it into a circular (elliptical) path. The "forever and ever" is due to there being no force opposing the motion (if we stick to circular).
You mean that there is no effect of shape circular(eleptical) on newtons first law , which says that if there is no force object will move in straight line but here its path became circular.
 
  • #12
541
145
You mean that there is no effect of shape circular(eleptical) on newtons first law , which says that if there is no force object will move in straight line but here its path became circular.
There is a force here - gravity - so the earth doesn't move in a straight line.
 
  • #13
541
145
The shape is due to gravity pulling it into a circular (elliptical) path. The "forever and ever" is due to there being no force opposing the motion (if we stick to circular).
Why have to stick to circular?
 
  • #14
307
19
There is a force here - gravity - so the earth doesn't move in a straight line.
But gravity is not a force its because of shape
 
  • #15
Khashishi
Science Advisor
2,815
493
Not forever. Eventually the Sun will engulf the Earth. But that won't be for a few billion years.
 
  • Like
Likes parshyaa
  • #16
307
19
Not forever. Eventually the Sun will engulf the Earth. But that won't be for a few billion years.
Now thats what I was searching , thanks khashishi
 
  • #17
Nugatory
Mentor
13,008
5,721
But gravity is not a force its because of shape
Only if you are using general relativity, and there's no reason to do that here.

Newton developed his theory of gravity, in which gravity is a force determined by ##F=Gm_1m_2/r^2## late in the seventeenth century. Two hundred and fifty years later Einstein developed his theory of gravity, in which gravity is not a force but instead the result of spacetime curvature described by ##G_{\mu\nu}=8\pi{T}_{\mu\nu}##.

It's easy to look at that history and say that Einstein showed that Newton was wrong and gravity isn't a force - but that would be wrong. Gravity is what is, and the universe does what it does, and the two theories are two different mathematical descriptions of that behavior. Although they arrive at this result in different ways, both theories predict that the earth will move in an elliptical orbit that is very close to circular. In both theories the underlying physical explanation for why the earth can keep moving is the same: there is no friction acting on it in any significant way.

It is fair to say that Einstein's theory is better than Newton's, because it makes more accurate predictions over a wider range of physical problems than Newton's. But saying that Einstein's theory s better is not the same as saying that Newton's theory is wrong; it works just fine for planetary motions. Indeed, I'll venture a stronger statement: it is impossible to learn and understand Einstein's theory if you do not already have a solid understanding of Newton's theory.
 
  • Like
Likes dextercioby, sophiecentaur and parshyaa

Related Threads on Why the Earth moves around the Sun forever and ever and ever?

  • Last Post
Replies
3
Views
3K
Replies
20
Views
5K
Replies
4
Views
3K
  • Last Post
Replies
1
Views
6K
  • Last Post
Replies
15
Views
1K
  • Last Post
Replies
22
Views
3K
Replies
23
Views
4K
Replies
75
Views
24K
Replies
17
Views
1K
Top