Why we cannot see light from a conducting wire?

  • Thread starter ggandy
  • Start date
When I connect filament(light bulb) in the electric circuit I can see the light.

but when I connect only conducting wire(copper line) in the electric circuit I couldn't see the light from the conducting wire even though conducting wire less resistant than filament.

How can I explain that phenomenon?
 
27,688
4,151
The light emitted from the wire is too low of a frequency for your eyes to detect.
 

Delta2

Homework Helper
Insights Author
Gold Member
2,090
573
Light is an electromagnetic wave but it has very big frequency ( frequency of some Terraherz).

The electric current that runs through the filament of the light bulb or the filament of the copper wire doesnt have that big frequency so normally if EM-waves were created only by current distributions, then we wouldnt have light from either case.

Then how light is created by the filament of the light bulb? It is because the free electrons that are the electric current collide with the orbiting electrons of the atoms of the fillament , and those orbiting electrons gain energy and give back some of their energy as em-waves with frequency of some Terraherz. The same happens with copper atoms but the orbiting electrons of the copper atoms cant give back em-waves in the frequencies of Terraherz. That is it depends on what exactly atoms we have as to if their orbiting electrons can produce em-waves in the frequencies of some Teraherz.
 

sophiecentaur

Science Advisor
Gold Member
23,013
3,638
The filament in a lamp is a "conducting metal". It is Tungsten, chosen because it can run at a very high temperature ('white hot') without vaporising. At such temperatures, the EM radiation is visible. A length of thin copper wire will glow brightly when it's connected across a beefy battery but it will melt and vaporise very quickly. If you try this, you have to be very careful handling the wire or you will burn a groove in your fingers. It's the sort of daft thing that I did as a boy with an old battery of my Dad's - and I burned my fingers!!!! Beware.
There is a pretty graph on this link that shows the relationship between temperature and emitted spectrum of a hot body. The spectrum is not much affected by the material used.
 
180
0
but when I connect only conducting wire(copper line) in the electric circuit I couldn't see the light from the conducting wire even though conducting wire less resistant than filament.
We need resistance to increase the temperature which in turn causes photon emission. But increased resistance also lowers current, so brighter light-bulbs actually have lower resistance, I think. I'm not sure how that works out, I guess it has to do with the filament thickness. But with constant current higher resistance should produce more light, or explosion even?
 

Physics Forums Values

We Value Quality
• Topics based on mainstream science
• Proper English grammar and spelling
We Value Civility
• Positive and compassionate attitudes
• Patience while debating
We Value Productivity
• Disciplined to remain on-topic
• Recognition of own weaknesses
• Solo and co-op problem solving
Top