Discussion Overview
The discussion revolves around the feasibility of using a DIY capacitor made from aluminum foil and paper as a component in a circuit to light a 6VAC incandescent bulb when connected in series. Participants explore the electrical characteristics of the capacitor, including its capacitance and reactance, and consider the implications for lighting the bulb.
Discussion Character
- Exploratory
- Technical explanation
- Debate/contested
- Experimental/applied
Main Points Raised
- One participant describes constructing a capacitor using aluminum foil and paper and questions whether it can light a 6VAC bulb in series.
- Another participant calculates the capacitance to be about 200 pF and the reactance to be approximately 16 MΩ at 50 Hz, concluding that the resulting current would be insufficient to light the bulb.
- There are multiple mentions of the calculated current being around 0.4 µA, which is deemed inadequate for lighting a filament lamp.
- Some participants express skepticism about the accuracy of an online impedance calculator, suggesting it may have errors or that the input parameters were misunderstood.
- Suggestions for building larger capacitors are discussed, including the challenges of creating a capacitor with a capacitance of 100 - 1000 μF using household materials.
- One participant proposes a method for creating a capacitor using tantalum or titanium powder, while others suggest a simpler method using aluminum foil and cling film.
- There are discussions about the soldering techniques required for aluminum and the necessity of proper insulation for effective capacitor construction.
- A participant acknowledges a misunderstanding regarding their capacitor experiment and indicates they no longer need the capacitor for their project.
Areas of Agreement / Disagreement
Participants express differing views on the effectiveness of the DIY capacitor in lighting the bulb, with some agreeing on the calculated current being insufficient, while others question the accuracy of the calculations and the online tool used. The discussion remains unresolved regarding the practical application of the capacitor for the intended purpose.
Contextual Notes
There are uncertainties regarding the calculations of reactance and current, as well as the assumptions made about the capacitor's construction and its performance in the circuit. The discussion also highlights the limitations of using online calculators without clear input specifications.