Winterize truck with steel plate?

Click For Summary

Discussion Overview

The discussion revolves around the safety and effectiveness of using a solid steel plate as a weight in the bed of a single cab pickup truck during winter for improved traction. Participants explore various materials and methods for adding weight to the vehicle, considering both safety and practicality.

Discussion Character

  • Exploratory
  • Debate/contested
  • Technical explanation

Main Points Raised

  • One participant describes using a solid steel plate, approximately 1 inch thick and potentially weighing around 600 pounds, to enhance traction in winter conditions.
  • Another participant raises concerns about the safety of having an unsecured heavy object in the truck bed, suggesting that sandbags might be a safer alternative.
  • Some participants discuss the potential risks of the steel plate in the event of a collision, questioning how securely it is fastened and its implications for passenger safety.
  • Several participants share their experiences with using sand or other materials, such as cat litter and concrete blocks, for weight in the truck bed, highlighting their effectiveness and safety.
  • One participant suggests bolting the steel plate down to mitigate risks associated with sudden stops or collisions.
  • Another participant provides a calculation for estimating the weight of the steel plate based on its dimensions and density, indicating a possible discrepancy in the initial weight claim.
  • Some participants advocate for using sandbags due to their versatility and safety compared to heavier materials like steel or concrete.

Areas of Agreement / Disagreement

Participants express differing views on the safety and effectiveness of using a steel plate versus other materials like sandbags. There is no consensus on the best approach, and concerns about safety remain unresolved.

Contextual Notes

Participants mention various methods of securing weights in the truck bed and the implications of different materials on safety. The discussion includes personal anecdotes and suggestions based on regional practices, but lacks definitive conclusions on the best method.

martman
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
Hi

Kind of a random question, I know, I just think this is a great place to get a answer.

Anyway, I have a single cab pickup truck. So of course I have a very light back-end, to compensate for this in the winter for more traction I have been putting in a solid steel plate my Dad bought ages ago. Now I'm wondering exactly how safe is this(for say being rear-ended).

The plat fits between my wheel wells and covers most of the bed and is about 1inch thick. The claim is that it weights about 600 pounds but in general my Dad's estimates are horrible. Considering the size and how well it works I think he might be right.

So any thoughts?
 
Engineering news on Phys.org
So you put a 1/4 ton steel blade unsecured in the back of a vehicle that you are quite likely to crash in the bad weather?

Did you see the scene in "the omen" ?

Perhaps some sand bags might be as effective and not lead to you featuring on the Darwin awards
 
Its secured with steel cable to 4 points in the bed. Don't know why you think I'm "quite likely to crash in the bad weather"...

Guess my real concerns deal with the back (fire?) wall and how secure those bed connections are. Maybe tomorrow I figure out where those 4 tie down loops goto(just the bed, frame, etc).
 
I used to carry a live load in the bed of my pickup when I spent a lot of time on Maine roads. Sand was the best. If I got a bit "stranded", I could shovel a nice bed of sand in front of my wheels and get out. Never had to get towed.
 
Forgot to address the bumper too. I haven't seen many pickups rear-ended(in real life or in pictures), but all that didn't involved big rigs seems to fair surprisingly well from what I've seen.
 
turbo-1 said:
I used to carry a live load in the bed of my pickup when I spent a lot of time on Maine roads. Sand was the best. If I got a bit "stranded", I could shovel a nice bed of sand in front of my wheels and get out. Never had to get towed.
Good point, I used cat litter to the same effect.
 
Evo said:
Good point, I used cat litter to the same effect.
Lighter and easier to spread than sand.
 
martman said:
Don't know why you think I'm "quite likely to crash in the bad weather"...
Sorry should have said - more likely to crash in bad weather

Either you skid, hit something, stop suddenly and the steel plate doesn't - so going forward through anything soft and squishy in the cab.

Or somebody else skids and hits you - pushing the steel plate forward ...
 
in my old mustang years ago, i "sandbagged" the hatch area with about 80-100 lbs of scrap lead. it fit nicely down there where the spare is kept.

i think with a big heavy plate, the best option would be to bolt it down. friction would then take care of most of the horizontal forces. and butt it up against the front of the bed, so it can't get a running start.
 
  • #10
martman said:
Its secured with steel cable to 4 points in the bed. Don't know why you think I'm "quite likely to crash in the bad weather"...

Guess my real concerns deal with the back (fire?) wall and how secure those bed connections are. Maybe tomorrow I figure out where those 4 tie down loops goto(just the bed, frame, etc).
In a wreck, I don't recommend it. Why not go with sand?
 
  • #11
We used to put a 1' x 1' x 6' concrete block in the back of our van in winter, helped a load.
 
  • #12
If your spare wheel is underneath the rear, replace it with a second fuel tank of the same dimension = approx 130-170 liters. Mount the spare on swing mount on rear. (see aus. 4x4).
if this is not enough weight catch a bus
 
  • #13
martman said:
Hi

Kind of a random question, I know, I just think this is a great place to get a answer.

Anyway, I have a single cab pickup truck. So of course I have a very light back-end, to compensate for this in the winter for more traction I have been putting in a solid steel plate my Dad bought ages ago. Now I'm wondering exactly how safe is this(for say being rear-ended).

The plat fits between my wheel wells and covers most of the bed and is about 1inch thick. The claim is that it weights about 600 pounds but in general my Dad's estimates are horrible. Considering the size and how well it works I think he might be right.

So any thoughts?

If you've a 4'x8' bed, a 1" steel plate of density 7.9 g/cm^3 would weigh roughly 1,315 lbs. Using this as a guide, simply figure out what percentage of a full 4'x8' bed you might have (cutouts for length, width, and wheel wells) and multiply the percentage by 1,315 lbs to find your plate's mass.

personal ref: calcs in /documents
 
Last edited:
  • #14
The approach here in Canukville is to load on a quarter-tonne or so of sandbags. They're great for overall traction, but can also be opened up and spread around your tires if you get caught on glare ice.
 
  • #15
Danger said:
The approach here in Canukville is to load on a quarter-tonne or so of sandbags. They're great for overall traction, but can also be opened up and spread around your tires if you get caught on glare ice.
I used the build-your own method of sandbagging. Go to a horse-owner and snag some empty grain bags (for strength) and line them with plastic trash-can liners (to keep the sand nice and dry). Here, the town highway departments generally let residents take a reasonable amount of sand for personal use in the winter. Much safer than concrete blocks, steel plates, or similar missiles.
 
  • #16
turbo-1 said:
I used the build-your own method of sandbagging. Go to a horse-owner and snag some empty grain bags (for strength) and line them with plastic trash-can liners (to keep the sand nice and dry). Here, the town highway departments generally let residents take a reasonable amount of sand for personal use in the winter. Much safer than concrete blocks, steel plates, or similar missiles.

I have a geographical advantage there. Burlap bags can be found lying about in fields all over the place, and sand is as near as your shovel. :biggrin:
 

Similar threads

Replies
4
Views
3K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
3K
Replies
9
Views
3K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
  • · Replies 4 ·
Replies
4
Views
9K
  • · Replies 13 ·
Replies
13
Views
5K
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
3K
  • · Replies 2 ·
Replies
2
Views
2K
  • · Replies 3 ·
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
2K