Would a meeting of local realists fill a phone booth?

  • Thread starter Thread starter wm
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Local
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers around the idea of gathering local realists to discuss quantum mechanics (QM) and whether such a meeting would attract enough participants to fill a phone booth. The initial proposal includes making a public confession akin to world leaders and drafting a membership clause that emphasizes locality and realism in the context of QM. The proposed definition of locality aligns with Einstein's views, while realism asserts the existence of an independent external reality with potentially unobservable properties. The conversation shifts to a light-hearted debate about the physical size of the phone booth and the implications for fitting participants, with humor about personal experiences and the need for fun in such discussions. Ultimately, the thread reflects on the niche nature of local realism within the broader discourse on quantum mechanics.
wm
Messages
164
Reaction score
0
I wonder: Would a meeting of dedicated local realists, to discuss QM, fill a phone booth? (We appear to be such a small minority among the great range and depth of PF participants.)

However, before gathering in the phone booth, let's each take advantage of the assembled world media and make an open public confession. (You know, like world-leaders do before their gatherings.)

In fact, what we could each do is this: We could read the rough draft that we have each brought along for our meeting. (For the first business of the meeting is to: "draft the first clause of membership". Though we have other fun purposes in mind too; including local-realist analysis of quantum experiments without one reference to a loop-hole.)

Here's what I would read, if pressed today: ''I believe that a dedicated local realist accepts something like the following combination:-- On locality: That Einstein's view of locality represents a fine starting point for a general definition of locality. On realism: That external reality exists, independent of observation, and may have properties which are unobservable.'' (I think that last bit refers to the linear polarisation of a random photon, but ... it's a rough draft, remember.)

Question: Will we fill the phone-booth?

Regards, wm
 
Last edited:
Computer science news on Phys.org
How big is the phone booth?
 
Andy said:
How big is the phone booth?

Hi Andy; from the many experiments that I've done over the years, here's my findings: It's always big enough for me and my girl-friend.

Am repeating the experiment right now ... old results confirmed OK!

So: Should I ask her to leave?

Regards wm
 
If its big enough for you and you girlfriend then i am assuming that it is quite an easy fit and that neither of you are very fat. This would lead me to conclude that you would be able to fit at least 3 people in there comfortably but many more if you started putting anorexic people in.
 
Andy said:
If its big enough for you and you girlfriend then i am assuming that it is quite an easy fit and that neither of you are very fat. This would lead me to conclude that you would be able to fit at least 3 people in there comfortably but many more if you started putting anorexic people in.

That might not fit the experimental guide lines: we need to leave some room for Fun. Also: Local realists (and Fun) tend not to be anorexic.
 
This thread is pointless.
 
In my discussions elsewhere, I've noticed a lot of disagreement regarding AI. A question that comes up is, "Is AI hype?" Unfortunately, when this question is asked, the one asking, as far as I can tell, may mean one of three things which can lead to lots of confusion. I'll list them out now for clarity. 1. Can AI do everything a human can do and how close are we to that? 2. Are corporations and governments using the promise of AI to gain more power for themselves? 3. Are AI and transhumans...
Thread 'ChatGPT Examples, Good and Bad'
I've been experimenting with ChatGPT. Some results are good, some very very bad. I think examples can help expose the properties of this AI. Maybe you can post some of your favorite examples and tell us what they reveal about the properties of this AI. (I had problems with copy/paste of text and formatting, so I'm posting my examples as screen shots. That is a promising start. :smile: But then I provided values V=1, R1=1, R2=2, R3=3 and asked for the value of I. At first, it said...
Back
Top