Would space stations of sci-fi fame actually work?

In summary: I'm not sure how you'd feel at 4 times that.In summary, a spinning space station that uses centrifugal force to create artificial gravity would not work due to the lack of an effective attachment mechanism.
  • #1
F Mills
8
0
Would a spinning space station as depicted below that use centrifugal force to create artificial gravity actually work? I'm thinking that it would not, this is because the centrifugal force would not affect an astronaut inside unless he was actually fastened mechanically to the hub. The fact that it is only used in sci fi and not sci reality is another indication to me that it is not viable as an artificial gravity tool for space station inhabitants.


latest?cb=20151110142655.png
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #3
jedishrfu said:
Yes, it would work. Think of why water stays in a bucket as you spin it around.

Wikipedia as more on it:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Artificial_gravity

So i found an acceptable subject, good. I do think of it as water in a bucket, but the water in question is in zero (or micro) G. I see it as an astronaut just floating around while the space station walls are spinning around him. I just noticed you have a link, I have to post to be able to look at it. BRB
 
  • #4
Still nothing to make astronaut adhere to surface. If you are buckeled into a seat on the inside of the hub, and forced to spin with the hull, I can see you experience G at that point. Otherwise unattached you would float off the surface as it spun.
 
  • #5
F Mills said:
but the water in question is in zero (or micro) G
In the spinning bucket it is not.

The astronaut would have to move around with the station, sure. What else do you expect? You don't want to shoot through the space station at high speed (as seen by the astronaut). If the astronaut moves relative to the station at high speeds, they will experience a higher or lower effective gravity, depending on the direction. Typical space station designs for artificial gravity are so large that this effect is small for walking speeds. And if you stand on the outer surface, you feel the artificial gravity downwards, you don't need any attachment.

Existing space stations don't rotate because (a) this requires some minimal size to be useful, and this size exceeds the current space stations, (b) it is much more complex to build such a space station and (c) most space station experiments want to use the microgravity environment. A small-scale test setup was planned for the ISS but got canceled due to budget constraints. Here is another proposal.
 
  • Like
Likes F Mills
  • #6
Thanks
 
  • #7
Put simply, you would need a lateral force on the astronaut to get her spinning with the spaceship. But, once the spaceship and astronaut reach the required rotational speed, only a centripetal force is required to maintain the astronaut's circular motion. And, that force would feel much like gravity.
 
  • Like
Likes F Mills
  • #8
PeroK said:
Put simply, you would need a lateral force on the astronaut to get her spinning with the spaceship.
Consider the movie "2001: A Space Odyssey", which has a large rotating living-chamber inside a non-rotating spaceship. Astronauts enter the chamber from the rest of the ship via the axis and climb "down" a ladder towards the rim. Holding the rungs of the ladder provides the lateral force.
 
  • Like
Likes F Mills
  • #9
 
  • Like
Likes F Mills and mfb
  • #10
If there is air inside the space station then that air will move with the station. Otherwise it tends to swirl around light fixtures, doors and desks and gains speed in the process. If there are astronauts floating in the moving air then they tend to move with it. Otherwise it tends to muss their hair and speed them up in the process.

Like motes of sediment suspended in water in a test tube in a centrifuge, the astronauts then precipitate out onto the floor.
 
  • Like
Likes F Mills
  • #11
Consider a station with a 30 meter radius, and rotational speed at the rim of 10 meters per second. This would have an apparent surface acceleration of v^2/r = 10^2/30 or about 3 meters per second. Roughly Mars surface.

10 meters per second is roughly 22 mph.

Now put a bicycle track inside the station. If I ride at 22 mph with the direction of motion, I double my weight. If I ride against the rotation, I lesson my weight. Put a jump in place and do awesome tricks.
 
  • #12
Sherwood Botsford said:
If I ride at 22 mph with the direction of motion, I double my weight.
Acceleration scales with velocity squared. You experience 4g, which is quite uncomfortable.
 
  • #13
Good point. But it would be 4 times the effective non moving (relative to the local chunk of station) force or about 1.3 G.
 
  • #14
Ah, you took a Mars-like gravity as baseline, right.
1.3 g are fine.
 

Related to Would space stations of sci-fi fame actually work?

1. Can humans really live in space stations like in science fiction?

Yes, humans can live in space stations. In fact, the International Space Station (ISS) has been continuously inhabited since 2000. However, living in a space station requires specialized equipment and training to adapt to the unique environment of microgravity.

2. How are space stations powered?

Space stations are typically powered by solar panels that convert sunlight into electricity. Some space stations, such as the ISS, also have backup power sources like batteries or fuel cells in case of emergencies.

3. How do space stations maintain a livable environment for humans?

Space stations use a combination of systems to maintain a livable environment for humans. This includes air scrubbers to remove carbon dioxide and replenish oxygen, water recycling systems, and temperature control systems. The ISS also has a special module that simulates Earth's gravity for exercise and bone health.

4. Can space stations really support long-term space travel?

Space stations are designed to support long-term space travel, but they do have limitations. For example, the ISS is only designed to support a maximum of six people for a few months at a time. To support longer missions, such as travel to Mars, new technologies and systems would need to be developed.

5. How do space stations deal with waste and garbage?

Space stations have various methods for dealing with waste and garbage. Some are recycled, such as water and air, while others are stored and eventually disposed of during resupply missions. Some space stations also use compacting systems to reduce the amount of waste that needs to be stored.

Similar threads

Replies
28
Views
4K
Replies
159
Views
13K
Replies
9
Views
3K
  • Science Fiction and Fantasy Media
Replies
5
Views
3K
Replies
38
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
11
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
1K
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
2K
Back
Top