Register to reply 
Analysis for calculating Ideal Opamp current without resistor 
Share this thread: 
#1
Dec1912, 02:55 AM

#2
Dec1912, 03:08 AM

P: 3

If I used nodal anaylsis, I could get two equations, but what equation should I use for a node between 4k and 12k resistor?



#3
Dec1912, 10:33 AM

Mentor
P: 11,813

Hi Hadi, Welcome to Physics Forums.
Hint: Notice that the junction of R1 and R3 connect to the () input of the opamp. What does that tell you about the currents through R3 and R1? Now suppose that the opamp is pulling some current I from the top node. Where can that current come from? Doesn't it all end up coming from the 12V supply? So if you did happen to know what I is, could you write an expression for the voltage at the () terminal? 


#4
Dec1912, 10:41 AM

P: 296

Analysis for calculating Ideal Opamp current without resistor
In the case of V1, you could change the combination of V1/R4 into a norton equivalent so that V1 becomes a current source and then a useful node equation could be written. Notice that this process removes one of the nodes  in particular the one that can't have a useful node equation written. In other words, solve a circuit without writing KCL equations at nodes where voltages are specified. opamps place special conditions on the circuit so use that to reduce the number of unknowns. For example, in this circuit you know the voltage at the  terminal of the opamp so that unknown is gone. 


#5
Dec1912, 07:36 PM

HW Helper
Thanks
PF Gold
P: 4,903

The voltage at the  input of the op amp should be obvious. olve for the two unknown nodes using KVL. 


#6
Dec2012, 04:13 PM

P: 3

Ok, thanks. I got it.
I only need two nodes, between (R1, R2, and R4) and between (R1, R3 and () terminal). 


#7
Dec2012, 04:24 PM

HW Helper
Thanks
PF Gold
P: 4,903

It should be obvious by inspection what the voltage of the second node you cite is! 


#8
Dec2112, 12:02 AM

P: 296




#9
Dec2112, 10:47 AM

HW Helper
Thanks
PF Gold
P: 4,903

Vo is his other unknown node. It's a node and it's unknown.
Let v2 = voltage at R1/R2/R4 junction. Taking advantage of knowledge of the voltage at the  input, G2(v2  Vo) + Io = G3*Vo where in general Gi = 1/Ri, i = 1,2,3 or 4 and Io = current out of op amp. Maybe this is not what you call a "nodal equation" but it sure solves the problem ... 


#11
Dec2112, 02:23 PM

P: 296

You can look up modified nodal analysis to see what is done about voltage sources. Either circuit transformation is done (norton equivalent to change a voltage source to a current source) or auxiliary equations are added to make up for additional unknowns. But MNA is mainly theoretical or for computer solvers. Nodal analysis gets you a matrix equation: I=GV. In the circuit here, writing KCL at the top of V1 (or the output of Vo but the voltage source is hidden there), you'd introduce the current I1 flowing through V1 and that would be equal to the current through R4. What does that do to the matrix equation? It means I has a redundant row and the two rows can be added together and one can be eliminated. After doing that, G is no longer square and you have to introduce another equation. That equation is V1=12V. Substituting that into I=GV, one row of V can be eliminated. So now you have a solvable square matrix after eliminating the current variable through the voltage source V1 and after removing the node equation at the top of V1 (this happened with V1=12V). So in the end, the node equations are written without including the node attached to the voltage source. This is why you can't get useful nodal equations in nodal analysis at voltage source nodes. You can choose to write the maximum number of simultaneous equations by introducing Io, I1 and KCL at the ground node, but that's more for computers. 


#12
Dec2112, 03:00 PM

Mentor
P: 11,813

Since it's the current that we're looking for, I don't see any harm in using it as a variable
If you assume that current I is being sunk by the opamp, it can only come from the 12V voltage source. That gives you one series resistor and a parallel section. You know what the voltage has to be where the opamp connects in the chain, indicated "V" in the diagram: You can use the current divider rule to find the portion of I which passes though the 8k resistor, and taking a KVL walk from the battery to the point marked V has a known potential drop. Solve for I. 


#13
Dec2112, 03:32 PM

P: 773

It's not that hard to deal with voltage sources in nodal analysis.
Label the nodes: V1 is the top of the 12 volt source. V2 is the junction of R1, R2 and R4. V3 is the  input of the opamp. Vo is the output of the opamp. The first method would be to perform a source transformation on the 12 volt source and R4. They are replaced with a current source of value 12/2000 in parallel with a 2000 ohm resistor, and we don't deal with the V1 node directly. Instead of a KCL equation at the Vo node, we use a constraint equation. Let the opamp have a finite gain of A. Then the constraint equation is Vo=A*V3. In the solution take the limit as A > ∞ to account for an ideal opamp . This solution in matrix form looks like this: The second method is to divide the constraint equation through by A, giving a new constraint equation V3=0. Now we get a solution that doesn't involve A, and we don't have to take a limit to get a final solution for an ideal opamp: The third method includes V1 explicitly and adds another constraint equation V1=12. The solution for all 4 nodes now includes the result V1=12, which we already knww: And, of course, the current the OP asked for is simply the sum of the currents through R2 and R3, which are easily calculated since we know the voltages across each of them, or it's the current through R4. 


#14
Dec2112, 04:41 PM

HW Helper
Thanks
PF Gold
P: 4,903

3 equations, 3 unknowns: G4(V1  v2) = G2(v2Vo) + G1v2 plus my other two. Solve for v2 (optional), Vo (optional) and Io. Simple. Using determinants you can restrict your effort to just finding Io. 


Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Ideal opamp output current  Advanced Physics Homework  1  
Calculating Current for Twoport Resistor Network  Engineering, Comp Sci, & Technology Homework  5  
CIRCUIT ANALYSIS: NonInverting Ideal OpAmp, 2 resistors, 1 IVS  Find Thevenin Equiv  Introductory Physics Homework  4  
CIRCUIT ANALYSIS: NonIdeal OpAmp with 2 resistors  Find Thevenin Equivalent  Introductory Physics Homework  1  
CIRCUIT ANALYSIS: 4 resistor, Current src, Voltage src, V.C.V.S.  Find node Voltages  Engineering, Comp Sci, & Technology Homework  1 