Register to reply 
(Small oscillations) Finding Normal modes procedure. 
Share this thread: 
#1
May1511, 09:30 AM

P: 899

1. The problem statement, all variables and given/known data
The first part of the problem is just finding the Lagrangian for a system with 2 d.o.f. and using small angle approximations to get the Lagrangian in canonical/quadratic form, not a problem. I am given numerical values for mass, spring constants, etc. and am told to find the normal modes of oscillation and the normal coordinates. 2. Relevant equations 3. The attempt at a solution I find the eigenvalues (eigenfreq, [tex]\lambda = \omega^{2}[/tex]) by diagonalizing: V[tex]\lambda[/tex]T = 0. (V and T are matrices, also called M and K, they're the matrix of coefficients of the velocities and coordinates from the canonical Lagrangian respectively) I get 2 ugly numbers for my eigenfrequencies, approximately 0.3 and 15.7. Now I sub the first one into V[tex]\lambda[/tex]T * (a11, a21) = 0 to solve for the eigenvector (a11, a21) which are the amplitudes of oscillation of both of my 2 d.o.f.(1 and 2) for this normal mode (1). Question: plugging them in gives me a system of 2 equations of 2 variables. I am told that necessarily, one of the equations is a multiple of the other, but it doesn't seem to be true (using approximate values might have to do with this but I'm not sure). Is this correct? If I believe what I am told, I pick one of the equations (the end result depends on which one I pick!) and solve for a11 as a function of a21, then use the orthonormalization condition: (a11,a21)(transposed)*T*(a11,a21) = 1 which allows me to find one of the amplitudes, which I then use to go back and solve for the other. I am also very worried about approximating everything, at this stage of the problem I've already approximated decimal points on at least 3 occasions. Can someone PLEASE help clarify this to me? Am I on the right track? 


#2
May1511, 09:34 AM

P: 170

You are on the right track, but don't plug in numbers until the very end. For a 2x2 matrix, you can do everything analytically. If you are stuck, show some more of your calculations :)



#3
May1511, 10:05 AM

P: 899

Thanks. The problem is my eigenvalues are generally irrational numbers so in order to not drag on mistakes from finding the roots, I just approximate the eigenvalues which is what my prof does and suggests doing even for 2 d.o.f. problems.
I have a problem with the orthonormalization process, I'm never quite sure if I'm multiplying the A(transposed)TA vectors properly. Do I first calculate A(transposed)*T, giving me a column vector, which I then multiply like a scalar product with the last term A(not transposed)? 


#4
May1511, 11:42 AM

P: 170

(Small oscillations) Finding Normal modes procedure.
You must have a prof with a technical background :)
The order in which you do the multiplications doesn't matter. I prefer to first calculate T*a, which gives another vector and then take the scalar product with a transposed, but that's just because I find multiplying with a matrix from the left easier than from the right. 


#5
May1511, 11:51 AM

P: 899

The prof is actually a theoretician. :P To get the normal coordinates, once I have the general solution both coordinates q (linear combo of normal modes), I multiply each by the inverse of the A matrix? Is this the whole matrix or just the corresponding eigenvector? 


#6
May1511, 12:00 PM

P: 170

That's the whole matrix. You can use your normalization equation to simplify things:
[tex]\vec{N} = A^{1} \vec{q} = A^{\mathrm{T}} T \vec{q}[/tex] since [tex]A^{\mathrm{T}} T A = 1[/tex]. 


#7
May1511, 12:11 PM

P: 899

That 3rd expression you've got there... Didn't think of that. :P I'd much rather transpose and multiply 2 square matrices with a vector than invert a matrix any day! Thanks, I've learned how to do 2 things more efficiently today thanks to you. :)



Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Finding frequencies of normal modes with the systematic method  Introductory Physics Homework  0  
Measuring procedure for Fermi Normal coordinates  Special & General Relativity  1  
Finding Angular Frequency of Small Oscillations about an Equilibrium  Introductory Physics Homework  1  
Small oscillations (normal modes)  Advanced Physics Homework  0  
Normal coordinates (small oscillations)  Advanced Physics Homework  3 