Register to reply 
Understanding H=U+PVby weng cheong
Tags: None 
Share this thread: 
#1
Aug1211, 09:18 AM

P: 22

it was stated on a cambridge notes that, H is a state function.
though H depends on U, which is a state function, however P and V also affect the value of H, how can H be a state function? 


#2
Aug1211, 09:50 AM

Sci Advisor
P: 3,564

P and V are also state functions, aren't they?



#3
Aug1211, 10:07 AM

P: 22

yes they are, but then why isn't work done a state function?



#4
Aug1211, 10:15 AM

HW Helper
P: 6,187

Understanding H=U+PV
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Functions_of_state 


#5
Aug1211, 10:19 AM

P: 343

The product PV is a state function because it doesn't depend on the path.



#6
Aug1211, 11:31 AM

P: 22

I like Serena
does it mean that work done is a path function, because for the same value of work done, the might be a lot of combination of pressure and volume values? Timthereaper then why are you saying that PV(the work done) is a state function? 


#7
Aug1211, 11:45 AM

HW Helper
P: 6,187

Consider for instance a combustion engine. It makes the following so called Otto cycle: During the cycle a number of transitions are made, beginning and ending at the same pV point, which is the same state. However, since the path through which work is done, has an enclosed surface, the work done is not zero, but an amount that depends on the path. 


#8
Aug1211, 08:39 PM

P: 22

alright, then H=U+PV.
we know that U is state function while PV is a path function. then how can the sum making H a state function? 


#9
Aug1211, 09:43 PM

P: 102

PV is itself a state function, not a path one. No matter how a system gets to a particular Pressure and Volume, the value PV will always be the same; it is a function only of the state variables P and V. In fact, the equation PV = constant is a state equation known a Boyle's Law. 


#10
Aug1311, 01:52 AM

HW Helper
P: 6,187

It is simply p times V, pressure times volume, which are both state variables. And yes, pV = constant is Boyle's law, but that law is only a special case of the ideal gas law, and assumes temperature is constant. In other words, in general pV is not constant. Furthermore pV is not the work done. 


#11
Aug1311, 02:41 AM

P: 84

pV = RT is a state equation known as boyle's law.hence, pV must be a state function and so (U+pV) is a state function on account of being the sum of 2 state functions or variables.



#12
Aug1311, 02:55 AM

P: 84

refer hess,s theorem on constant heat summation. enthalpy or H can be calculated using this law for any chemical equation depicting that H does not depend on how many intermediate equations were considered to obtain the result.
2C +H2>C2H2 ; H=a(say) C2H4 + H2>C2H4 ; H=B(say) then 2C+2H2>C2H4 ; H=a+b. even if it is independent of the prev. 2 steps" simply, 2H+2H2>C2H4 ; H=a+b so the eqn. as well as the enthalpy,H is independent of the path taken.It is a state function. 


#13
Aug1311, 03:48 AM

HW Helper
P: 6,187




#14
Aug1311, 05:13 AM

P: 102

And as far as p versus P, the textbook I used had used P for pressure. However, I have seen various other textbooks use one or the other. 


#15
Aug1311, 05:23 AM

HW Helper
P: 6,187

I see indeed that P is also used for pressure and that PV is referred to as a state function. Note that PV is still simply P times V, which are both state variables. 


#16
Aug1311, 08:11 AM

P: 5,462

As a mathematician, ILS may have been thinking of composition of functions when discussing PV.
However there is no reason why the composite function (PV) could not be considered as a (state) function in its own right. For instance the function 'work' is also known as Fd. go well 


#17
Aug1311, 12:05 PM

P: 84

Mathematically, you could think a state function as resultant of a exact differential, i.e., the integral form of your function is dependent only on the final and initial states.



Register to reply 
Related Discussions  
Understanding what happens to exp((6s)t) when t goes to inf  Calculus & Beyond Homework  8  
P(a1<X<a2, b1<Y<b2) Understanding  Calculus & Beyond Homework  0  
Help understanding  General Engineering  2  
Need help understanding FFT  Calculus & Beyond Homework  1  
Is understanding one branch of math conducive to understanding another?  General Math  4 