Which uC is Best for Your Autonomous Robotics Project?

[ionlylooklazy]

so, I've been looking into some uC projects as an extra hobby. no specific ideas yet besides a generic lil autonomous robot. but i am having dificulty deciding on what type of uC to use, and that's why I have come here :)

my thoughts:

i have experience with basic stamp, pic, and dsPIC(significant). I am also familiar with assembly(limited) & c/c++

i would prefer using a high level language like c/c++, which the pic supports. but looking at the cost of the development boards and programmers that microchip offers, it turns out to be a very expensive solution.

for the basic stamp, the actual modules themselves are expensive, but the devo boards, programmers, and the compiler (free!) are generally less expensive.

as for capabilities between the two, the basic stamp uses PBASIC, and it would suit me fine for a while, but I think the relatively limited program space would not suit me down the road, for expansionary projects.

so I am torn between power and affordability,

what do you recommend? are there any other uC's that would be appropriate for my experience/level/application?

 

[chroot]

Personally, I'd suggest the EZ-USB series from Cypress. They're a snap to connect to your computer, and they have a lot of features. I don't know how much the dev kits cost, but you may not even need one. You only need a couple of external components (oscillator, etc.) to build a complete system.

- Warren

 

[berkeman]

If you want to target the PIC 18F4455 (or similar) chip with its USB capability, you can get started for less than $200 by buying the MPLAB ICD2 PC interface unit, downloading the free compiler (it loses some functionality after 60 days if you stay with the free version, but that should be fine for you for a while), and building your own PIC circuits by hand using SMT --> through hole conversion boards (sometimes called "surf boards"). The PIC 18F4455 comes in a QFP-44 SMT package that is still pretty reasonable to hand solder. I don't know the price offhand, but building your own starter board with that chip and the two connectors for USB and the ICD2 would be way cheaper than the $200+ starter boards that Microchip sells.


Microchip MPLAB software: http://www.microchip.com/stellent/idcplg?IdcService=SS_GET_PAGE&nodeId=1406&dDocName=en019469&part=SW007002

MPLAB with ICD2 interface: http://www.microchip.com/stellent/idcplg?IdcService=SS_GET_PAGE&nodeId=1406&dDocName=en010046

Prices in US: http://www.microchipdirect.com/ProductSearch.aspx?Keywords=DV164005


We've used the PIC 18F4455 on several in-house fixtures, and it's pretty easy to work with. I also like chroot's suggestion of the EZ-USB devices from Cypress. Having a USB interface into your projects gives you a nice natural way to combine your PC with your uC projects, and also gives you great experience in programming with the very popular USB interface.

 

[xez]

Look at what I suggested in this other thread:

https://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=176494

Basically I'd say
a) embedded small PC

b) LPC ARM7 from NXP

c) MSP430 from TI; you can order the USB programmer and
software kit from TI's eStore for $20 which is sufficient
to program all the smaller parts with the SPI-BI-WIRE
interface. For the larger pinout parts with true JTAG
programming I believe you need a more expensive
programmer but it's still cheaper than a lot PICs programmers.

d) Something like the ARM9 AT91RM9200 from Atmel,
though that's a pretty big PQFP package and a VERY
powerful microprocessor, so it might be overkill if you
want something more like a PIC.

e) Look at the 68HCxxx type microcontrollers if those
are still made/used, I recall those weren't bad in cost
and programming options, though really I'd use an
ARM7 before a 68HCxxx these days.

f) The RABBIT stuff:
http://www.rabbitsemiconductor.com/products/

g) THe TINI stuff:
http://www.maxim-ic.com/products/microcontrollers/tini/

h) Other MAXIM uCs:
http://www.maxim-ic.com/products/microcontrollers/

i) Some of the Zilog and other compatible
technology (Hitachi?) Z80 stuff is easy to program since
you can use an internal bootstrap loader and/or external
standard parallel FLASH / EPROM type stuff.

The Cypress uCs can be ok too, as berkeman said.

 

[ionlylooklazy]

thanks for the recommendations