What is the binding energy needed to shatter Earth by asteroid impact?

  • Thread starter Thread starter mersecske
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Asteroid Earth
AI Thread Summary
To completely shatter Earth, an asteroid would need to overcome its Gravitational Binding Energy of approximately 2.23E32 joules, which is equivalent to the energy required to prevent the resulting fragments from rejoining. An asteroid capable of delivering this energy would need to be around the mass of Venus, or about 4E24 kg, which is significantly larger than typical asteroids. While large asteroids can cause substantial surface damage, they are unlikely to fully break apart the planet. Historical theories suggest that even a Mars-sized object colliding with Earth did not destroy it, indicating the resilience of planetary bodies. Ultimately, while theoretical discussions about asteroid impacts can explore various scenarios, the energy required to completely disintegrate Earth remains astronomically high.
mersecske
Messages
186
Reaction score
0
Which is the asteroid size or mass
which can destroy the Earth totally
(I mean, breaking apart)?
 
Astronomy news on Phys.org
I doubt one could, the Earth is ~6 billion trillion tonnes of matter. To completely break the Earth apart would require you to overcome the Gravitational Binding Energy of all the mass of the Earth, that would require 2.23E32 joules of energy. An asteroid, even a titanic sized one could only ever hope to vaporize the biosphere and perhaps break some fragments of the Earth off.
 
Fusion in the Sun

What is the time scale of the fusion (hydrogen into helium) in the Sun.
And what is the event rate?
 
I'm not sure what you mean by "event rate". In 5 billion years the sun will convert into a red giant, I believe that by this stage hydrogen fusion will be over and helium fusion will be dominant, you might want to google that though because I'm not 100% sure
 
Back to the asteroids and Earth.
My question is not about real world.
So let's see an imagenary planet, maybe smaller than Earth.
Asteroids usually cause only small demage on the surface,
but a real big one can brake the planet apart.
Maybe the size of the asteroid is comparable to the planet,
but my question is that it can be order of magnitude smaller or not?
 
mersecske said:
Back to the asteroids and Earth.
My question is not about real world.
So let's see an imagenary planet, maybe smaller than Earth.
Asteroids usually cause only small demage on the surface,
but a real big one can brake the planet apart.
Maybe the size of the asteroid is comparable to the planet,
but my question is that it can be order of magnitude smaller or not?

Well, the current theory about how the moon was generated suggests a mars-sized object had an off-centre collision with the Earth, and obviously the Earth survived that.

To take ryan_m_b's binding energy of 2.23e32 J, and typical collision velocities for objects in the solar system are on the order of 10km/s, so that means you need a mass of about 4e24 kg to provide that much energy, or roughly an object the size of Venus.
 
What is
"ryan_m_b's binding energy of 2.23e32 J"
?
 
mersecske said:
What is
"ryan_m_b's binding energy of 2.23e32 J"
?

The binding energy that ryan_m_b talked about before.
The potential energy keeping Earth together is 2.23x1032 joules, which means you fully break Earth apart, you would need to supply that amount of energy to the Earth.
 
Vagn said:
The binding energy that ryan_m_b talked about before.
The potential energy keeping Earth together is 2.23x1032 joules, which means you fully break Earth apart, you would need to supply that amount of energy to the Earth.

To be more accurate, you could shatter the Earth with less energy. The binding energy is the energy you need to impart to the Earth to prevent the resulting pieces from rejoining due to mutual gravitational attraction.
 
Back
Top