Could a coaxial cable be used for electric current instead of radio signals?

AI Thread Summary
Coaxial cables primarily transmit electrical energy through the dielectric insulator, with the Poynting vector indicating that energy flows between the conductors rather than within them. While coaxial cables are not efficient for carrying DC current due to the resistance differences between the conductors, a vacuum can theoretically be used as a dielectric, though it poses risks of moisture intrusion if compromised. Compressed dry air or inert gases are often used in larger coax cables to prevent moisture from entering if the cable is damaged. The discussion also touches on the challenges of finding examples of insulator-conductor arrangements, with Unshielded Twisted Pair being mentioned as a close alternative, although it does not meet the criteria. Overall, coaxial cables are designed for specific applications, primarily involving radio signals rather than direct electric current.
lufc88
Messages
52
Reaction score
0
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coaxial_cable
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poynting_vector
Could a coaxial cable be used for electric current instead of radio signals?

'For example, the Poynting vector within the dielectric insulator of a coaxial cable is nearly parallel to the wire axis (assuming no fields outside the cable and a wavelength longer than the diameter of the cable, including DC). Electrical energy is flowing entirely through the dielectric between the conductors. No energy flows in the conductors themselves, since the electric field strength is zero. No energy flows outside the cable, either, since there the magnetic fields of inner and outer conductors cancel to zero.'
What causes resistance in a coaxial cable is it like normal conductors or does some resistance happen in the dielectric?

Could you have a vacuum as the dielectric in a coaxial cable?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
lufc88 said:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coaxial_cable
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poynting_vector
Could a coaxial cable be used for electric current instead of radio signals?

'For example, the Poynting vector within the dielectric insulator of a coaxial cable is nearly parallel to the wire axis (assuming no fields outside the cable and a wavelength longer than the diameter of the cable, including DC). Electrical energy is flowing entirely through the dielectric between the conductors. No energy flows in the conductors themselves, since the electric field strength is zero. No energy flows outside the cable, either, since there the magnetic fields of inner and outer conductors cancel to zero.'
What causes resistance in a coaxial cable is it like normal conductors or does some resistance happen in the dielectric?

Could you have a vacuum as the dielectric in a coaxial cable?

Coax is not volumetrically efficient for carrying DC current, because of the large difference in size (and therefore resistance) of the two conductors.
 
lufc88 said:
....Could you have a vacuum as the dielectric in a coaxial cable?

yes you can, tho that can be a real problem as if the cable gets holed and a smal/large leak develops, then water will flow into the cable with ease.

Rather, large coax cables/waveguides get filled with compressed dry air or some other inert gas. That way if the cable is holed the air will continue to escape aout the hole and stop moisture from entering.

For lowest loss coax cables, the best easy dielectric is total air (gas), but that's impossible as you need something physical to keep the inner and outer conductors separated. This is often achieved by a thin spiral of teflon and ~ 90% or so of the dielectric is still air.

Dave
 
Is there any examples of an insulator, conductor, insulator arrangement
 
lufc88 said:
Is there any examples of an insulator, conductor, insulator arrangement

That would be only one wire...? What is the return path for the current?
 
lufc88 said:
Is there any examples of an insulator, conductor, insulator arrangement

google is a wonderful thing :)

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coaxial_cable

It would appear that you didnt even read through this link that you yourself gave above

scroll down there are you will even see the spiral teflon dielectric that I spoke of

cheers
Dave
 
Thanks also does anyone know of any more examples of an insulator surrounded by two conductors?
 
Unshielded Twisted Pair comes close to being that.
 
lufc88 said:
Thanks also does anyone know of any more examples of an insulator surrounded by two conductors?

there are no "more" examples, as none have and can be given so far :)
and so how are the 2 conductors insulated ?? they can't be you instead should have 2 conductors surrounded by insulation

Unshielded Twisted Pair comes close to being that.

no, you still have 2 conductors surrounded by insulation, whether there's a screen/shield and another insulator ( the sheath) is irrelevent.
In a cable, you can't have 2 conductors surrounding an insulator else the conductors will be in contact with each other
 
  • #10
cheers everyone
 
Back
Top