Proof Definition and 999 Threads

  1. tellmesomething

    B How to prove this for every Arithmetic Progression?

    If i take any two APs say a=1; d=5; 1,6,11,16,21,26,31,36,41,46,51......1+(n-1)5. say a=2; d=3; 2,5,8,11,14,17,20,23,26,29,32,35,38,41......2+(n-1)3. If i pick out the common terms here, I get an AP again o common difference 15. 11,26,41....11+(n-1)15 How can i prove that the common terms of...
  2. L

    B Probability a randomly chosen natural number, which is not smaller than 𝑥, is greater than x?

    What is the probability that a randomly chosen natural number, which is not smaller than a given natural number x, is greater than x? I think it must be ##1## because there are infinitely numbers that greater than ##x## but how can I proof this? Thank you.
  3. nbafitis28

    Intelligence and math abilities improvement

    Hello, My name is Nikolaos Bafitis, and currently I am student at St. Johns College Highschool in DC. Two years ago I moved back from Italy where I stayed in for 3 years. Upon my return to the US I have noticed that I seem to be getting slower at math skills and speed after being placed in...
  4. RChristenk

    Questions about proof of upper and lower bound theorem for polynomials

    To prove the upper bound: Let ##c>0##, divide it into ##f(x)## and the coefficients in the final line of the synthetic division tableau are all non-negative. Thus ##f(x)=(x-c)q(x)+r##, where ##r \geq 0## (since the coefficients are given as all non-negative) and is a constant because it's degree...
  5. mcastillo356

    B Is this a finite argument of the countable infiniteness of the rationals?

    Hi, PF Theorem The set ##\mathbb{Q}## of the rational numbers is countably infinite. Proof The rational numbers are arranged thus...
  6. M

    I Principle of relativity in the proof of invariance of interval

    Hello! I saw such interpretation of principle of relativity when I read proof of invariance of infinitesimally small interval: "The second inertial frame of reference looks from the first in no way different from how the first inertial frame of reference looks from the second." Proof of...
  7. M

    How should I show that there exists only one solution?

    So far, I've got that ## g(a)=(c-1)a+\frac{3}{4}a^3\implies g'(a)=c-1+\frac{9}{4}a^2 ##. I know that if the first derivative of a function is positive (greater than ## 0 ##), then that function is always/strictly increasing. However, how should I construct this proof in order to show that...
  8. L

    I Proving that fractions are the same as division

    So using the multiplicative inverse axiom we have : 1) x . x^-1 = 1 2) x . (1/x) = 1 I have no idea why do mathematicians define the multiplicative inverse of a number x to be the "fraction" 1/x. But I know for sure that multiplying any number a for example by the multiplicative inverse of x is...
  9. L

    ##\lim_{x \to0} \left(\dfrac{1}{\sin^2 x}-\dfrac{1}{x^2}\right)##

    My solution is: Let ##\lim_{ x \to 0}\left(\dfrac {1}{\sin^2x}-\dfrac1{x^2}\right)=L## Let ##x=2y## ##\lim_{ y \to 0}\left(\dfrac {1}{\sin^22y}-\dfrac1{4y^2}\right)=\lim_{ y \to 0}\left(\dfrac1{4\sin^2y\cdot\cos^2y}-\dfrac1{4y^2}\right)=L## ##=\dfrac14\lim_{ y \to...
  10. H

    Eisenstein's criterion proof

    My solution: Assume it is reducible, i.e., ##a_n X^n + ... + a_0 = (b_k X^k + ...+ b_0)(c_m X^m+ ... +c_0)##. ##a_0=b_0 c_0##. Since ##p \mid a_0##, either ##p \mid b_0## or ##p \mid c_0##, but not both, because ##p^2 \nmid a_0##. Assume ##p \mid b_0, p \nmid c_0##. ##a_1=b_0 c_1+b_1 c_0##. ##p...
  11. H

    I Use of induction in the proof of the Chinese Remainder Theorem

    Consider the following proof: My question is, does it in fact use induction? It says, "Assume now that the theorem is true for k-1 elements...," but I don't think it uses this assumption to prove that it is true for k elements, which would be an induction step.
  12. mad mathematician

    A Deduce that the spectrum of a local ring is always connected

    Iv'e got this proof from some claim: Any Pure maths doctors out there who can explain to me why since ##V\ne \emptyset## that ##1\notin \mathfrak{b}##? Thanks!
  13. M

    How should I find ## x_{2}(t) ## for this nonlinear integro-differential equation?

    Proof: Consider the nonlinear integro-differential equation ## \frac{dx}{dt}=-\lambda x(t)+\epsilon x(t)\int_{0}^{\infty}f(t-s)x(s)ds, \lvert \epsilon \rvert<<1, x(0)=A ##, where ## \lambda ## is a positive constant and ## f(z) ## is a sufficiently well-behaved function. Let ## \epsilon=0 ##...
  14. T

    Proving an Inequality: x+y>=2sqrt(xy)

    See the attached image for my attempt. My main concern is can I assume that y > x prove it for that case and then show it is equal if y = x. My whole proof is centered around y > x so if i cannot make that assumption then I have to start over. Let me know your thoughts. Thanks in advance for...
  15. M

    I Why can coefficient "a" between spacetime intervals depend on velocity between systems?

    Hello! I read Landau & Lifshitz' Classical Theory of Fields [Link to copyrighted textbook redacted by the Mentors] (see pic below) and I was confused when I saw in proof that coefficient "a" between spacetime interval (ds)2 and (ds')2 can only depend on the absolute relative velocity between...
  16. P

    I Help understanding a passage from a proof of change of variables formula

    Here's an excerpt from the proof of the change of variables formula in Folland's book (Theorem 2.47, page 76, 2nd edition, 6th and later printings): For reference, see Theorem 2.40 below. I don't understand how he is using Theorem 2.40 in the quoted passage. Which part of Theorem 2.40 is he...
  17. chwala

    Prove the given problem that involves limits

    I am self-learning analysis. My steps are as follows, For any ##ε>0##, there is a ##\delta>0## such that, ##|(x^3+2x^2-4x-8) -0|<ε## when ##0 < |x-2|<\delta## Let ##\delta≤1## then ##1<x<3, x≠2##. ##|(x^3-2x^2-4x-8) -0|=|(x-2)(x+2)^2|=|x-2||(x+2)^2| <\delta |(x+2)^2|<19\delta## Taking...
  18. L

    Stumped on mathematical proof

    From Blundell and Blundell Chapter 20 Problem 20.3. I have proved that $$1-e^{-\beta \omega}=2\sinh\left(\frac{\beta \omega}{2}\right)$$ with no problem, but I am stuck on the ##\coth## term. I have tried to solve this but it gets messy and I'd rather not include them here. Thanks!
  19. T

    Prove Continuity From Precise Definition of Limit

    I attached my attemp at the solution. I am trying to start with continuity at 0 and end up with limit of f(x) equals f(c) as x goes to c. Could someone take a look at the attached image and let me know if I am on the right track or where I went astray Sorry picture is rotated I tried but...
  20. E

    I Fundamental theorem of arithmetic from Jordan-Hölder theorem

    I was intrigued by a comment in Brilliant.org: Besides the proof provided by Brilliant, I also found a couple of other websites. But none of these proofs were entirely clear to me. So I tried to come up with my own proof. Since I am not a group theorist, I wanted to ask if the proof makes...
  21. S

    Nonlinear dynamics problem from Strogatz textbook

    For g) how should I argue this claim? To me it seems straight forward because u is linearly related to z. Then so do their derivatives. And by the description of the model, ##\dot z## is linear to y. So it's quite obvious but not sure what I should pay more attention to when I write my proof...
  22. M

    How should I show that the transformation makes the system Hamiltonian?

    Proof: Consider the transformation ## x=\frac{1}{\sqrt{1+e^{-2q}}} ## and ## y=\frac{1}{\sqrt{1+e^{-2p}}} ## with the Hamiltonian function ## H(q, p)=ap-b\cdot ln(e^{p}+\sqrt{1+e^{2p}})+cq-d\cdot ln(e^{q}+\sqrt{1+e^{2q}}) ##. Let ## \dot{x}=\frac{dx}{dt}=(a-by)x(1-x^2)=(a-by)(x-x^3) ## and ##...
  23. T

    I Help understanding proof of ds=ds' in Classical Theory of Fields

    I just decided to look at Landau & Lifshitz' Classical Theory of Fields (English version, 4th ed), and I am a bit embarrassed to be confused already on page 4&5 of this book. The book can be viewed on archive.org. The goal of this section of the book is to show ##s = s'## starting from only the...
  24. Antarres

    A Zeroth law of black hole thermodynamics

    I was looking at the proof of zeroth law of thermodynamics from the original paper by Bardeen, Carter, Hawking, which can be found here. Now, we have the Killing vector which is the generator of the horizon, we call it ##l^\mu##, and auxiliary null vector field ##n^\mu##, which we define to be...
  25. D

    B Spherical Lens Model and Proof

  26. Astronuc

    I Monumental Proof Settles Geometric Langlands Conjecture

    https://www.quantamagazine.org/monumental-proof-settles-geometric-langlands-conjecture-20240719 https://people.mpim-bonn.mpg.de/gaitsgde/GLC/ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Langlands_program https://www.quantamagazine.org/what-is-the-langlands-program-20220601/...
  27. K

    I Tough lemma on locally finite refinement

    Hello! I have some troubles diving in the proof of this lemma Lemma. Let ##S## be locally compact, Hausdorff and second countable. Then every open cover ##\lbrace U_\alpha \rbrace## of ##S## has a countable, locally finite refinement consisting of open sets with compact closures. Proof...
  28. L

    Why is the Jacobian for polar coordinates sometimes negative?

    Proving this geometrically [1] gives ##J = r.## Why is the ##-r## one wrong? Why is ##(x, y) \rightarrow (\theta, r)## is different from ##(x, y) \rightarrow (r, \theta)##? Edit: In Paul's Notes [2] it seems like ##J## is always positive, but online says it can be negative... [1] The first...
  29. M

    A Question about existence of path-lifting property

    I'm reading "Complex Made Simple" by David C. Ullrich and here i have a problem with the proof of a theorem: Theorem Suppose that ##p : X \to Y## is a covering map. If ##\gamma : [0,1] \to Y## is continuous, ##x_0 \in X## and ##p(x_0) = \gamma(0)## then there exists a unique continuous function...
  30. L

    Proving convergence of sequence from convergent subsequences

    In the photos are two proof questions requiring proving convergence of sequence from convergent subsequences. Are my proofs for these two questions correct? Note in the first question I have already proved that f_n_k is both monotone and bounded Thanks a lot in advance!
  31. M

    Proof given ##x < y < z## and a twice differentiable function

    For this problem, My proof is Since ##f'## is increasing then ##x < y <z## which then ##f(x) < f(y) < f(z)## This is because, ##f''(t) \ge 0## for all t ## \rightarrow \int \frac{df'}{dt} dt \ge \int 0~dt = 0## for all t ##\rightarrow \int df' \geq 0## for all t ##f ' \geq 0## for all t...
  32. M

    Differentiable function proof given ##f''(c) = 1##

    For this problem, I'm confused by the implication from the antecedent ##0 < |x - c| < \delta## to the consequent. Should the consequent not be ##|f''(x) - f''(c)| < \frac{1}{2}## where ##\epsilon = \frac{1}{2}## (Since we are applying the definition of a limit for the first derivative curve)...
  33. M

    Root test proof using Law of Algebra

    For this problem, My solution is If ##c < 1##, then let a be a number such that ##c < a < 1 \implies c < a##. Thus for some natural number such that ##n \geq N## ##|x_n|^{\frac{1}{n}} < a## is the same as ## |x_n| < a^n## By Law of Algebra, one can take the summation of both sides to get...
  34. M

    Proving piecewise function is k-differentiable

    For this problem, My solution is, ##F(x)=\left\{\begin{array}{ll} e^{-\frac{1}{x}} & \text { if } x>0 \\ 0 & \text { if } x \leq 0\end{array}\right.## The we differentiate both sub-function of the piecewise function. Note I assume differentiable since we are proving a result that the function...
  35. M

    Ratio test proof

    For (a) and (b), Does someone please know how to prove this? I don't have any ideas where to start. Thanks!
  36. ergospherical

    I Final part of proof of timelike Killing w/ Frobenius --> static

    If ##V## is timelike Killing with Frobenius condition ##V_{[\alpha} \nabla_{\mu} V_{\nu]} = 0## then you can derive the equation:$$\nabla_{\mu} (|V|^2 V_{\nu}) - \nabla_{\nu} (|V|^2 V_{\mu}) = 0$$which has the solution$$V_{\alpha} = \partial_{\alpha} \phi \quad \mathrm{where} \quad \phi = x^0 +...
  37. L

    Continuous functions on metric spaces

    Hi, I don't know if I have solved task correctly I used the epsilon-delta definition for the proof, so it must hold for ##f,g \in (C^0(I), \| \cdot \|_I)## ##\sup_{x \in [a,b]} |F(x)-G(x)|< \delta \longrightarrow \quad |\int_{a}^{b} f(x)dx - \int_{a}^{b} g(x)dx |< \epsilon## I then...
  38. chwala

    Prove the given hyperbolic trigonometry equation

    I have, Using ##\ cosh 2x = 2 \cosh^2 x - 1## ##\cosh x = 2 \cosh^2\dfrac{x}{2} -1## Therefore, ##\cosh x -1 = 2 \cosh^2\dfrac{x}{2} -1 - 1## ##\cosh x -1 = 2 \cosh^2\dfrac{x}{2} -2## ##=2\left[ \cosh^2 \dfrac{x}{2}...
  39. M

    True or false problem for double differentiable function

    For this true or false problem, My solution is, With rearrangement ##\frac{f(x) - f(a)}{x - a} > f'(a)## for ##x < a## since ##f''(x) > 0## implies ##f'(x)) > 0## from integration. ##f'(x) > 0## is equivalent to ##f(x)## is strictly increase which means that ##\frac{f(x) - f(a)}{x - a} > f'(a)...
  40. M

    Non-Differentiable Function proof

    For this problem, I am trying to prove that this function is non-differentiable at 0. In order for a function to be non-differentiable at zero, then the derivative must not exist at zero ##⇔ \lim_{x \to 0} \frac{f(x) - f(0)}{x - 0}## does not exist or ##⇔ \lim_{x \to 0^-} \frac{f(x) - f(0)}{x...
  41. M

    Proving function discontinuous at zero

    For this problem, THe solution is, However, does someone please know why from this step ##-1 \leq \cos(\frac{1}{x}) \leq 1## they don't just do ##-x \leq x\cos(\frac{1}{x}) \leq x## from multiplying both sides by the monomial linear function ##x## ##\lim_{x \to 0} - x = \lim_{x \to 0} x= 0##...
  42. T

    Eigenvalue of matrix proof by induction

    We consider base case (##n = 1##), ##B\vec x = \alpha \vec x##, this is true, so base case holds. Now consider case ##n = 2##, then ##B^2\vec x = B(B\vec x) = B(\alpha \vec x) = \alpha(B\vec x) = \alpha(\alpha \vec x) = \alpha^2 \vec x## Now consider ##n = m## case, ##B^m\vec x = B(B^{m - 1}...
  43. T

    Linear Algebra Determinant proof

    I have a doubt about this problem. (a) Show that a matrix ##\left(\begin{array}{ll}e & g \\ 0 & f\end{array}\right)## has determinant equal to the product of the elements on the leading diagonal. Can you generalize this idea to any ##n \times n## matrix? The first part is simple, it is just ef...
  44. T

    Medium Hard continuity proof Tutorial Q6

    I am trying to solve (a) and (b) of this tutorial question. (a) Attempt: Since ##c'## is at ##c'(0) = 1##, then from the definition of continuity at a point: Let ##\epsilon > 0##, then there exists ##d > 0## such that ##|x - 0| < d \implies |c'(x) - c'(0)| < \epsilon## which is equivalent to...
  45. H

    B Identity Theorem for power series

    Consider this proof: Is it a valid proof? When we divide by ##z##, we assume that ##z \neq 0##. So, we cannot put ##z=0## on the next step. IOW, after dividing by ##z## we only know that $$c_1+c_2z+c_3z^2+...=d_1+d_2z+d_3z^2+...$$ in a neighborhood of ##0## excluding ##0##.
  46. M

    Proving convergence of rational sequence

    For this problem, The solution is, However, does someone please know why this did not use ##2n ≤ 2n^2 + 2n + 1## which would give ##\frac{3n - 1}{2n^2 + 2n + 1} ≤ \frac{3n}{2n} = \frac{3}{2}##? In general, after solving many problems, it seems that when proving the convergence of a rational...
  47. M

    Coupled pendulum-spring system

    The problem and solution are, However, I am confused how the separation vector between the two masses is ##\vec x = x \hat{k} = x_2 \hat{x_2} - x_1 \hat{x_1}= l\theta_2 \hat{x_2} - l\theta_1 \hat{x_1 } = l(\theta_2 - \theta_1) \hat{k}##. where I define the unit vector from mass 2 to mass 1...
  48. I

    Proving well ordering principle from Peano Axioms

    I am trying to understand the proof given in Ethan Bloch's book "The real numbers and real analysis". I am posting snapshot of the proof in the book. I am also posting theorem 1.2.9 given in the book. Here author is trying proof by contradiction. First, I don't understand why specific...
  49. C

    B I've been trying to understand the proof for the binomial theorem

    Hello everyone, I've been trying to understand the proof for the binomial theorem and have been using this inductive proof for understanding. So far the proof seems consistent everywhere it's explicit with the pattern it states, but I've started wondering if I actually fully grock it because I...
  50. L

    I Supremum of a set, relations and order

    Hello, found this proof online, I was wondering why they defined r_2=r_1-(r_1^2-2)/(r_1+2)? i understand the numerator, because if i did r_1^2-4 then there might be a chance that this becomes negative. But for the denominator, instead of plus 2, can i do plus 10 as well? or some other number...
Back
Top