Can entropy be used to measure time?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion explores the concept of using entropy as a means to measure time, suggesting that a device could calculate entropy in a system to provide a numerical time value. It raises questions about the reliability of such a system compared to traditional atomic clocks, emphasizing that entropy's relationship with time is qualitative rather than quantitative. Participants debate the feasibility of measuring entropy accurately enough to function as a clock, with one suggesting that any clock could be viewed through the lens of entropy change. The conversation highlights the challenges in creating a reliable entropy-based timekeeping device and the need for a consistent system to measure. Overall, the idea remains speculative and lacks a clear path to practical implementation.
dbmorpher
Messages
69
Reaction score
0
Hello dbmorpher here,
I was looking at some articles on entropy and wondered, could this be used to calculate time?
Entropy is known as the arrow of time, figurative I know but could actually be used to measure.
If there was a device that calculated the entropy in a set system couldn't it automatically calculate it and give a numerical value?
This would need a set system for all clocks but would render any other non- atomic clocks obsolete because it is based on measurements and calculations instead of gears and circuitry.

I would like to know if what I said in that last sentence could happen and if I could make one myself.

I found this
http://www.eoht.info/page/Entropy+clock
But I do not understand it very well.
 
Science news on Phys.org
This is VERY puzzling. What system do you wish to measure the entropy of that is SO reliable as to be used as a clock? And how would this be more accurate than current atomic/Cs clock?

BTW, the naive link between entropy and the arrow of time is a QUALITATIVE relationship, not a QUANTITATIVE one. Nothing here says that entropy can provide an accurate MEASURE of time.

Zz.
 
Right. I could use a pot of water on my stove as a clock, but it would be cumbersome and not all that accurate.
 
Well from what I have learned entropy is measured not observed, therefore a small calculator sized computer could be fitted to a clock and measure the entropy in the system, the only way for the clock to be inaccurate is if the laws of thermodynamics broke.
Refute me if I am wrong.
 
ZapperZ said:
What system do you wish to measure the entropy of that is SO reliable as to be used as a clock?

Can you not think of all clocks in this way? A wound clock has less microstates available to it than an unwound clock. A clock is that which measures entropy change reliably. Reliably being defined as: it progresses in some constant ratio to other clocks.
 
Back
Top