Are Cookies More Explosive Than Dynamite Based on Calories?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Nim
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Calories Food
AI Thread Summary
Comparing the calories in chocolate chip cookies to those in TNT raises questions about energy release rates and digestion efficiency. While TNT has a higher caloric value per gram, not all of its energy is released instantly during an explosion. Conversely, not all calories in a cookie may be fully absorbed by the body. The discussion highlights the importance of understanding the difference between energy and power, particularly in contexts like demolition where speed is crucial. Overall, using calories as a common measure for different energy sources can be informative, though the comparison may not be straightforward.
Nim
Messages
74
Reaction score
0
A http://muller.lbl.gov/teaching/Physics10/chapters/1-Explosions.htm listed what I have posted below. Does it make sense to compare the calories of a chocolate chip cookie to the calories of TNT? Maybe there is more calories in TNT than 1 but not all of it can be released fast enough to be apart of the explosion. Or maybe people don't digest all the calories in a cookie and so the calories listed are smaller than how much it actually contains.

Code: 
object                                Calories in one gram 

gasoline                              10
chocolate chip cookies                5
bullet (moving at speed of sound)     0.01
methane gas (CH4)                     13
battery (flashlight)                  0.01
battery (computer)                    0.1
hydrogen gas (H2) for fuel cell       26
TNT or dynamite, by convention*       1 
real TNT (trinitrotoluene)            0.651
modern High Explosive (PETN)          1.06
meteor (at 30 km/sec)                 100
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
First off, kilocalorie would seem more correct for a physics text, but food-calorie makes sense to a layperson.

Second, it explains the difference between power and energy as its rational. Its not the total energy, rather how quickly the energy is delivered.

In demolition, it seems much talk is spent on how fast things happen, seems to follow here.

Cliff
 
We commonly measure energy in calories, so it does "make sense" to compare different sources of energy with calories. As to whether or not it makes sense to compare cookies to dynamite; remember, it is an election year. -Mike
 

Hot Threads

Recent Insights

Back
Top