Bernoulli's Equation & Equation of Continuity

In summary, Bernoulli's equation predicts that the speed of water leaving the hose will be a constant, regardless of the size of the hose, while Torricelli's equation assumes that the hydrostatic pressure is converted to dynamic pressure and the flow rate can vary.
  • #1
Alexander83
35
0
Hi all,
I'm considering an fluids example that's giving me an apparent contradiction when I consider it from the perspective of Bernoulli's Equation vs. the Equation of Continuity.

What I'm thinking of is the common observation that putting one's thumb over a garden hose results in an increase in the velocity of the water leaving the hose. I've always understood this in terms of the Equation of Continuity under the assumption that the volume flow rate (R) is a constant.

R = v*A

Where v is the speed of the flow in the hose and A is its cross-sectional area. From this approach, the speed of water leaving the hose would increase as A is reduced by putting a thumb over the outlet of the hose.

Where I'm getting confused is in trying to apply Bernoulli's equation to explain what's going on. I'm imagining a very conceptually simple case where the water in the hose is originating from a large storage tank that is open to the atmosphere at the top. In this case, Bernouilli's equation could be used to work out the speed of the water at the hose outlet and it essentially boils down to Torricelli's theorem here and one obtains:

v = (2gh)^0.5

where h is the depth of the water in the tank feeding the hose. This equation indicates that the flow speed through the end of the hose should be a constant and independent of the diameter of the hose.

The two results clearly contradict one another, so there's clearly something I'm missing here... I suspect I'm missing something in trying to apply Bernoulli's theorem to this situation, but I can't see what it is that I'm missing.

Any help would be gratefully appreciated!

Cheers,

Alex
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
v = (2gh)^0.5
when leaving the hose would mean the water spouts up to a height equal to the level h in your water tower ! In reality the transition from tank to hose and the hose itself form resistances, so you don't reach that.

When you reduce the nozzle size you get a bigger delta P for the Bernoulli equation, so a higher speed.
 
  • Like
Likes Alexander83
  • #3
The primary issue here is that Bernoulli's Principle applies along a streamline and the two points you are comparing aren't even part of the same system. So you cannot apply it in the way you are trying to apply it.

The secondary issue, as described in the previous post, is that for water coming out of an open garden hose the frictional losses are near 100%.
 
  • Like
Likes Alexander83
  • #4
I guess I will point out that, in addition to what has been mentioned here, Torricelli's law and the garden hose example come with a different set of assumptions. For example, the garden hose example assumes a constant mass flow rate regardless of how much of the hose you cover with your finger. This turns out to be a pretty good assumption that gets worse once you cover up about 2/3 of the exit (see this thread to see where I went through the calculations on this problem; the calculation starts in post #25, though you can certainly browse the discussion in the whole thread if you'd like). Torricelli's law, on the other hand, assumes that all of the hydrostatic pressure in a tank is converted to dynamic pressure at the exit and allows the mass flow rate to float freely to accommodate the exit velocity (the accuracy of this assumption depends on your system).

As mentioned before, the addition of a hose to the system, for example, introduces significant losses and so not all of the static pressure in the system is converted into dynamic pressure. In that case, you have to take into account the losses in the system given a constant supply pressure, and according to the post I linked up there, it turns out that the constant mass-flow assumption is a very good one for most cases. In the case of Torricelli's law, the fact that it assumes a simple hole in the side of a bucket (or other storage vessel) means that the losses in the flow are very close to zero and the assumptions made in that situation are valid, namely that all of the static pressure is converted to dynamic pressure and the flow rate can vary.
 
  • Like
Likes Alexander83
  • #5
Thank you all for your responses... I think I need to do some additional reading to better understand the assumptions made in the derivation of each of these equations. Is there a particularly good introductory fluid dynamics text that you could recommend? I'm looking for something that's not too high level. I've been doing most of my reading on this topic from first-year level Physics textbooks, so something accessible with that as a starting point would be great. I'm an engineering student and would also be interested in a text that's got some good applied examples.

Thanks again for all your help! Much appreciated.

Alex
 

1. What is Bernoulli's equation and what does it represent?

Bernoulli's equation is a fundamental principle in fluid mechanics that describes the relationship between pressure, velocity, and elevation in a fluid flow. It represents the conservation of energy in a fluid system.

2. How is Bernoulli's equation derived?

Bernoulli's equation is derived from the principles of conservation of mass, momentum, and energy applied to a fluid element moving along a streamline. It assumes that the fluid is inviscid (no friction) and incompressible (constant density).

3. What is the equation of continuity and how does it relate to Bernoulli's equation?

The equation of continuity is a mathematical expression of the principle of conservation of mass in fluid flow. It states that the mass flow rate in a system is constant, meaning that the product of the fluid's density, velocity, and cross-sectional area must remain constant. The equation of continuity is a key component in the derivation of Bernoulli's equation.

4. How is Bernoulli's equation applied in real-world scenarios?

Bernoulli's equation has many practical applications, including in the design of airplanes, cars, and other vehicles that move through fluids. It is also used in the design of pipes and pumps, and in the study of weather patterns, ocean currents, and other natural phenomena involving fluid flow.

5. What are some limitations of Bernoulli's equation?

Bernoulli's equation is based on certain simplifying assumptions, such as the fluid being incompressible and inviscid. In reality, most fluids do experience some degree of viscosity and compressibility. Additionally, Bernoulli's equation only applies to steady-state, one-dimensional flow along a streamline. It may not accurately predict the behavior of turbulent or non-uniform flows.

Similar threads

  • Classical Physics
Replies
6
Views
960
  • Mechanics
2
Replies
43
Views
4K
Replies
4
Views
1K
  • Introductory Physics Homework Help
Replies
6
Views
1K
Replies
48
Views
4K
Replies
4
Views
2K
Replies
17
Views
1K
Replies
7
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
2K
  • Mechanics
Replies
5
Views
1K
Back
Top