Calculating multiple magnitudes for induced electric field

1 reply · 2K views · last reply
Kerrigoth
Messages
14
Reaction score
1
Let's say I place two different size conducting loops inside of a uniform magnetic field. For the sake of the diagram I have the loops share a point, but just treat them as though they are not touching.
Then I decrease the value of the magnetic field very quickly.
[tex]\frac{dB}{dt} = \frac{1.6T}{0.3s}=5.3 T/s[/tex]
Diagram of two concentric-at-a-point circular loops in a rectangle: a large loop of 5m radius and a small loop of 2m radius touching at a green marked shared point, with red induced E arrows pointing upward at each loop's rightmost point and blue crosses marking a uniform magnetic field B going from 1.6T to 0.0T in 0.3 seconds.

Since I changed the magnitude of the uniform magnetic field, the magnetic flux going through both loops will change. According to Faraday's Law, both loops will experience induced EMFs due to the change in magnetic flux. This will result in current.
[tex]\frac{d\Phi _{m}}{dt} = A \frac{dB}{dt} = \epsilon[/tex]
[tex]\epsilon_{1} = \pi (5)^2 \cdot(5.3) = 416.26V \hspace{2cm}<br /> \epsilon_{2} = \pi (2)^2 \cdot(5.3) = 66.6V[/tex]
Regardless of whether the loops are actually present or not, the changing magnetic field will create an induced electric field.
[tex]\epsilon = \oint E\cdot ds = E \cdot2\pi r \hspace{2cm}<br /> E=\frac{\epsilon}{2\pi r}[/tex]

[tex]E_{1} =\frac{416.26}{2\pi (5)} = 13.25 V/m \hspace{2cm}<br /> E_{2} =\frac{66.6 }{2\pi (2)} = 5.3V/m[/tex]

But the magnitudes of calculated electric fields are bugging me for two reasons:

1) At the "shared point", I have two different calculated values for the electric field. The electric field at a single point can't have two different magnitudes though! I must be doing something inherently wrong in this problem.

2) Judging by my two calculated electric fields: the strength of an induced field increases as the loop's radius increases. For some reason I keep telling myself that the electric field strength should decrease to satisfy some inverse square law. Is there a more intuitive way to look at this that could help overcome my bad instinct?
 
Attachments
  • Diagram of two concentric-tangent circular loops in a uniform magnetic field square: loop #1 radius 5m, loop #2 radius 2m, touching at a green 'shared point' on the left. Red arrows show induced E #1 and E #2 pointing upward at each loop's rightmost point. Blue crosses mark B going from 1.6T to 0.0T in 0.3 seconds.
    Untitled.png
    7 KB · Views: 673
Kerrigoth said:
Regardless of whether the loops are actually present or not, the changing magnetic field will create an induced electric field.
ϵ=∮E⋅ds=E⋅2πrE=ϵ2πr​
\epsilon = \oint E\cdot ds = E \cdot2\pi r \hspace{2cm} E=\frac{\epsilon}{2\pi r}
This is the mistake. E is not spatially uniform, the curl of E is spatially uniform.