Calculating total derivative of multivariable function

2 replies · 2K views · last reply
halleffect
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
Homework Statement
Here is the full problem statement (with equations): https://i.imgur.com/z2SWodC.png The answer that I'm trying to derive is at the bottom.
Relevant Equations
All equations are also included in the above image (https://i.imgur.com/z2SWodC.png).
This isn't a homework problem exactly but my attempt to derive a result given in a textbook for myself. Below is my attempt at a solution, typed up elsewhere with nice formatting so didn't want to redo it all. Direct image link here. Would greatly appreciate if anyone has any pointers.

Typeset handwritten-style derivation of partial derivatives of currents i1 and i2 with respect to voltages v1 and v2 via intermediate variables vk and qk, with a note of confusion about reciprocal partial derivatives and cross terms.
Typeset handwritten-style derivation of partial derivatives of currents i1 and i2 with respect to voltages v1 and v2 via intermediate variables vk and qk, with a note of confusion about reciprocal partial derivatives and cross terms.
 
Attachments
  • Typeset derivation of a total derivative di/dv using partial derivatives of i1 and i2 with respect to v1, v2, vk and qk, followed by prose explaining why the cross terms and reciprocal partial derivative cause difficulty.
    1663624136782.png
    29.6 KB · Views: 229
Last edited by a moderator:
By ##I_0## and ##V_0## sum conditons, we know
[tex]i=2i_1-I_0=i(q_1)[/tex]
[tex]v=2v_1-V_0=v(q_1)[/tex]
They both are functions of variable ##q_1## only.
[tex]\frac{di}{dv}=\frac{\frac{di}{dq_1}} {\frac{dv}{dq_1}}=\frac{\frac{di_1}{dq_1}} {\frac{dv_1}{dq_1}}[/tex]
we can calculate it.
 
Last edited:
anuttarasammyak said:
By ##I_0## and ##V_0## sum conditons, we know
[tex]i=2i_1-I_0=i(q_1)[/tex]
[tex]v=2v_1-V_0=v(q_1)[/tex]
They both are functions of variable ##q_1## only.
[tex]\frac{di}{dv}=\frac{\frac{di}{dq_1}} {\frac{dv}{dq_1}}=\frac{\frac{di_1}{dq_1}} {\frac{dv_1}{dq_1}}[/tex]
we can calculate it.

Thanks very much for the reply; with that info:

[tex]\frac{di_1}{dq_1} = 2q_1+1[/tex]
[tex]\frac{dv_1}{dq_1} = U_T(\frac{2q_1+1}{q_1})[/tex]

And from this I get

[tex]\frac{di}{dv}=\frac{ \frac{di_1}{dq_1} }{ \frac{dv_1}{dq_1} }= \frac{q_1}{U_T}[/tex]

I'm not sure if this is correct. For one thing, I'm not sure how I could incorporate ##q_2## into the answer like the given one (which is ##\frac{2}{U_T}\frac{q_1 q_2}{q_1+q_2}##), although it does seem to make sense that it should be expressible through just one of the ##q##'s. Is there a way to show this to be equal to the given answer? (Assuming I haven't made an error here)