Can ABS Plastic Be Safely Broken Down for Recycling?

  • Thread starter Thread starter LightningInAJar
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Plastic
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the recycling and breakdown of ABS plastic, particularly in the context of 3D printing failures. Participants explore whether ABS can be safely decomposed into non-carcinogenic chemicals or its basic elements, with some expressing concern over the carcinogenic potential of its components. It is noted that while acrylonitrile, one of the monomers in ABS, is carcinogenic, the polymer itself is stable and generally considered harmless. Recycling is emphasized as a preferable option over attempting to break down the plastic, as the decomposition process could release harmful substances. Suggestions include reusing or recycling ABS, which is increasingly popular due to its cost-effectiveness in manufacturing. The conversation also touches on the challenges of recycling ABS, such as the need for higher temperatures and potential physical property degradation after multiple melts. Overall, the consensus leans towards maximizing the utility of existing plastics rather than seeking destructive methods for disposal.
LightningInAJar
Messages
251
Reaction score
33
TL;DR Summary
How?
Is there a process to break ABS plastic down into safe non carcinogenic chemicals? Maybe even down to its basic elements? Maybe an enzyme exists? I want to recycle my 3D printed objects that didn't turn out well.
 
Chemistry news on Phys.org
LightningInAJar said:
Summary:: How?

Is there a process to break ABS plastic down into safe non carcinogenic chemicals? Maybe even down to its basic elements? Maybe an enzyme exists? I want to recycle my 3D printed objects that didn't turn out well.
Is ABS carcinogenic?

To recycle, just reheat.
Or perhaps you need smaller pieces by just grinding the bad part up.
 
256bits said:
Is ABS carcinogenic?

To recycle, just reheat.
Or perhaps you need smaller pieces by just grinding the bad part up.
At least 1 of three chemicals in ABS is cancer causing. It is stable when combined hence why it can be used to make Legos. But I don't want to reuse the plastic. I would prefer there be less of it left on Earth by breaking all the bonds in it.
 
LightningInAJar said:
Summary:: How?

Is there a process to break ABS plastic down into safe non carcinogenic chemicals? Maybe even down to its basic elements? Maybe an enzyme exists? I want to recycle my 3D printed objects that didn't turn out well.

LightningInAJar said:
At least 1 of three chemicals in ABS is cancer causing. It is stable when combined hence why it can be used to make Legos. But I don't want to reuse the plastic. I would prefer there be less of it left on Earth by breaking all the bonds in it.
This is not how chemistry works. The polymer isn’t carcinogenic. Acrylonitrile is, but it’s one of the monomers. The polymer is perfectly harmless as it is, but if you were to “break down” the polymer into its constituent monomers, you’d end up with a stinky poisonous soup. Best case scenario, you burn it all completely and end up with a bunch of CO2. More likely is it wouldn’t burn completely and the fumes would contain the carcinogen that you seek to avoid. The best thing you can do is recycle or reuse the harmless plastic.
 
  • Like
Likes jsgruszynski, berkeman, BillTre and 1 other person
You could bury it as a form of carbon sequestration.
 
  • Like
  • Informative
Likes 256bits, Keith_McClary and TeethWhitener
There are too many plastics out there. At some point we will need to break it down completely. It would need to be well contained in any process to break it down. But in my mind it makes more sense to do it in a controlled fashion than have it end in the ocean or a landfill and end up in water supplies. Maybe a UV laser could break even the CO2? Or like I said before, an enzyme that can eat it and output something safer?
 
You could shoot it into the sun to reduce it to atoms.
 
LightningInAJar said:
There are too many plastics out there. At some point we will need to break it down completely. It would need to be well contained in any process to break it down. But in my mind it makes more sense to do it in a controlled fashion than have it end in the ocean or a landfill and end up in water supplies. Maybe a UV laser could break even the CO2? Or like I said before, an enzyme that can eat it and output something safer?
What makes you think there are too many plastics? And why does that make destruction a better alternative than recycling? And what makes you think that the energy and processes used in destroying that plastic will be better than letting the plastic remain?

If you think there are too many plastics, then the answer is to stop consuming things made from plastic. Are you simply never going to use your 3D printer again? Or are you just going to go out and buy more plastic to feed it instead of recycling what you already have?
 
  • Like
Likes 256bits
  • Like
Likes jim mcnamara
  • #10
TeethWhitener said:
What makes you think there are too many plastics? And why does that make destruction a better alternative than recycling? And what makes you think that the energy and processes used in destroying that plastic will be better than letting the plastic remain?

If you think there are too many plastics, then the answer is to stop consuming things made from plastic. Are you simply never going to use your 3D printer again? Or are you just going to go out and buy more plastic to feed it instead of recycling what you already have?
The more we use the more we buy. I don't know who specifically recycles ABS. I know the filament requires a higher temperature each time it is melted which causes nozzle clogs unlike PLA plastic. I don't know if recycling resets its physical properties. Who could I send old part to to make it usable again?
 
  • #11
@Keith_McClary gave an example in the post directly above yours. @BillTre gave an example of simply burying the plastic that serves as a carbon sink. The point is that you’re not going to do better decomposing the plastic than you would recycling it. It’s a noble goal to try to keep hydrocarbons in the ground, but once they’re out of the ground (in the form of ABS plastic, in your case), it’s best to use them to their full extent.
 
  • Like
Likes jsgruszynski

Similar threads

Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
1
Views
2K
Replies
8
Views
2K
Replies
20
Views
9K
Replies
5
Views
2K
Replies
8
Views
5K
Back
Top