Can Heat Waves Be Polarized and Controlled in Direction?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion explores the concept of whether heat can be polarized and directed, similar to polarized light. It highlights that heat is generated by the vibration of molecules, which is inherently random, and questions if this vibration can be controlled directionally. The conversation notes that while phonons, which model heat transport, have polarization states, they tend to scatter quickly, distributing energy uniformly. It also emphasizes that electromagnetic radiation, such as infrared, can be polarized, but this does not allow for the creation of polarized radiation with a defined temperature. Ultimately, the idea of using polarized heat to create a highly efficient engine is proposed, though it acknowledges the theoretical limitations posed by the absence of a perfect heat sink.
shivakumar06
Messages
69
Reaction score
0
we know that heat is caused by vibration of molecules. the vibration by nature of molecules is random. but in as in polarized light can we give heat that is vibration a particular direction. then this vibration i call polarized heat has varying temp at various angles. can this be actually made true.
 
Science news on Phys.org
interestings question...
Am not an expert in this area but I suspect there are 2 parts to this question

1) in an object say a chunk of heated iron, the heat is being generated by the motion/vibration of atoms/molecules ( small scale/large scale)

2) but the radiated heat we feel is primarily infrared radiation, which is electromagnetic in nature and that can be polarised

lets see how the more knowledgeable answer this :)

Dave
 
If you model heat transport with phonons, then yes- phonons have a polarization state.
 
I would expect that those phonons scatter quickly and distribute the energy in all directions. The timescale would be similar to the damping of sound in solids (many similar phonons), so probably <1s unless some specific setups can increase it (?).
 
Heat itself doesn't have temperature.
As far as electromagnetic radiation is concerned, only isotropic blackbody radiation has a well defined temperature. You may put a polarizer in an oven, but it won't change the polarization or temperature of the blackbody radiation once it has the same temperature as the oven. So the answer is negative, you can't create polarized radiation with a well defined temperature.
 
if heat can be polarized then i believe the temperature of space occupying polarized heat will be different in different direction for every point in it. so using this concept we possibly create a engine at least in theory which will be 100% efficient.
 
This would still need a perfect heat dump at 0 temperature, which does not exist in our universe.
 
Back
Top