Can I solve this using Kirchoff's Law?

  • #1
Paul Lasdivan
4
1
Homework Statement:
Can I solve this using Kirchoff's Law?
Relevant Equations:
Kirchoff's Law
ee.png


We were given a circuit with 7 resistors and 3 voltage sources
For emf sources, ##E_1=120V##, ##E_2=60V##, and ##E_3=30V## while for resistors in ohms,##R_1=10##, ##R_2=5##, ##R_3=20##, ##R_4=8##, ##R_5=12##, ##R_6=6##, ##R_7=8##. Nodes are indicated in small letters (a-j). Loops ##abefa##, ##abcdefa## and ##aghcdijfa## are assumed clockwise while the loop ##cbedc## is counterclockwise.

I applied Kirchoff's Current Rule in nodes ##b## and ##e##:

$$
I_1+I_3 = I_2\\
I_4+I_5 = I_2
$$

And then I apply the Voltage Rule:
Loop ##abefa##:
$$120-I_1R_1-I_2R_2-30-I_4R_4=0$$
Loop ##cbedc##:
$$60-I_3R_3-I_2R_2-30-I_5R_5=0$$
Loop ##abcdefa:##

$$120-I_1R_1+I_3R_3-60+I_5R_5-I_4R_4=0$$

Since I have 5 equations already with 5 unknows, hopefully I should solve these values.

From 1st and 2nd equations, ##I_4 = I_2-I_5 = I_1+I_3-I_5##. Setting ##I_4##, and ##I_2## in terms of ##I_1##, ##I_3## and ##I_5## only and substituting them to equations 3, 4 and 5, I get:

$$
23I_1+13I_3-8I_5=90\\
18I_1-12I_3-20I_5=60\\
5I_1+25I_3+12I_5=30
$$

Luckily my calculator supports systems of equations for 3 uknowns, but then I get a math error, which could indicate infinitely many solutions? Maybe I incorrectly applied Kirchoff's rule but I don't know where. Is it valid to apply Kirchoff's rule here?
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
FactChecker
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Gold Member
7,590
3,314
I used MATLAB and got a solution from your equations. ##I_1=0.9256; I_3=2.8863; I_5=-3.8987##. The solution checks out. So your equations seem to be solvable.

The determinant of the matrix is very small, 7.7793e-13, so your guess of multiple solutions may be essentially correct. That may mean that you have overlooked an independent equation. I don't see one.
 
  • #3
willem2
2,103
365
The abcdefa loop is just a combination of the other 2 loops, so you only have 2 equations with 3 unknowns. None of the loops involves R6 or R7 or the currents through them. I think you should end up with 4 equations and 4 unknowns
 
  • Like
Likes FactChecker
  • #4
FactChecker
Science Advisor
Homework Helper
Gold Member
7,590
3,314
Good catch. The loop aghcdijfa was listed but forgotten.
 
  • #5
rude man
Homework Helper
Insights Author
Gold Member
8,031
867
Homework Statement: Can I solve this using Kirchoff's Law?
Homework Equations: Kirchoff's Law

View attachment 248007

We were given a circuit with 7 resistors and 3 voltage sources
For emf sources, ##E_1=120V##, ##E_2=60V##, and ##E_3=30V## while for resistors in ohms,##R_1=10##, ##R_2=5##, ##R_3=20##, ##R_4=8##, ##R_5=12##, ##R_6=6##, ##R_7=8##. Nodes are indicated in small letters (a-j). Loops ##abefa##, ##abcdefa## and ##aghcdijfa## are assumed clockwise while the loop ##cbedc## is counterclockwise.

I applied Kirchoff's Current Rule in nodes ##b## and ##e##:

$$
I_1+I_3 = I_2\\
I_4+I_5 = I_2
$$

And then I apply the Voltage Rule:
Loop ##abefa##:
$$120-I_1R_1-I_2R_2-30-I_4R_4=0$$
Loop ##cbedc##:
$$60-I_3R_3-I_2R_2-30-I_5R_5=0$$
Loop ##abcdefa:##

$$120-I_1R_1+I_3R_3-60+I_5R_5-I_4R_4=0$$

Since I have 5 equations already with 5 unknows, hopefully I should solve these values.

From 1st and 2nd equations, ##I_4 = I_2-I_5 = I_1+I_3-I_5##. Setting ##I_4##, and ##I_2## in terms of ##I_1##, ##I_3## and ##I_5## only and substituting them to equations 3, 4 and 5, I get:

$$
23I_1+13I_3-8I_5=90\\
18I_1-12I_3-20I_5=60\\
5I_1+25I_3+12I_5=30
$$

Luckily my calculator supports systems of equations for 3 uknowns, but then I get a math error, which could indicate infinitely many solutions? Maybe I incorrectly applied Kirchoff's rule but I don't know where. Is it valid to apply Kirchoff's rule here?
It is ALWAYS correct to apply Kirchhoff's laws.
Even in electromagnetic circuits.
You just have to understand what "voltage" really is.
 
  • #6
Babadag
537
147
There are 7 unknown currents and 7 equations

3 loops:

aghcdijfa,abefa,cbedc

4 current enterings points:

b,f and a,d and c, and e
 

Suggested for: Can I solve this using Kirchoff's Law?

Replies
22
Views
1K
Replies
7
Views
805
  • Last Post
Replies
7
Views
320
  • Last Post
Replies
4
Views
563
  • Last Post
Replies
3
Views
1K
Replies
2
Views
216
  • Last Post
Replies
1
Views
359
Replies
2
Views
458
  • Last Post
Replies
4
Views
1K
Top