Can we ever construct a perfect circle? (Curiousity)

  • Thread starter Thread starter icystrike
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Circle Curiousity
AI Thread Summary
Constructing a perfect circle is deemed impossible due to the nature of π, which can only be defined through infinite sums, and Zeno's paradox, which suggests that a finite length cannot be divided into infinite parts. A perfect circle is an idealized geometric object where every point is equidistant from the center, but this cannot be accurately represented in practice. The discussion highlights that the ability to construct geometric shapes depends on the operations permitted, such as using an infinite ruler and compass. While certain polygons, like a 7-gon, cannot be constructed, others, like a 17-gon, can be achieved through specific methods. Ultimately, the feasibility of constructing a perfect circle is contingent on the definitions and constraints applied.
icystrike
Messages
444
Reaction score
1

Homework Statement


As stated abv.

Since \pi can only be established by infinite sum and according to zeno's paradox we can never break a finite length into infinite pieces (loosely speaking)
 
Physics news on Phys.org
Depends on your definition of perfect. It's like getting from Point A to Point B. That paradox states we can't get from A to B because we always have to cover half the remaining distance. That's not a good excuse to tell your boss why you were late, I've found out.
 
Based on the title of your thread, no, we can't construct a perfect circle. The circle of geometry is an idealized object, every point of which is the same distance away from the center. The curve that makes up the circle is infinitessimally thin, so there's no way we can draw it.

icystrike said:
Since \pi can only be established by infinite sum and according to zeno's paradox we can never break a finite length into infinite pieces (loosely speaking)[/itex]
I don't understand what this has to do with your question.
??
 
Like everyone else said, it depends what you're "allowed" to do. A common construction people use is an "infinite" ruler and a compass. Basically, you start with two arbitrary points in R-2 space, say (0,0) and (1,0). The only operations you're allowed to make are circles with the center at one point and the circumference on another point, and lines through two points. Any intersections you get are considered new points.

Knowing this, it's actually been proven that you cannot construct a 7-gon with with this construction. However, it has been proven that you can construct a 17-gon! (The construction is messy as hell) But to answer your question, it just depends what operations you're allowed to make.
 
I picked up this problem from the Schaum's series book titled "College Mathematics" by Ayres/Schmidt. It is a solved problem in the book. But what surprised me was that the solution to this problem was given in one line without any explanation. I could, therefore, not understand how the given one-line solution was reached. The one-line solution in the book says: The equation is ##x \cos{\omega} +y \sin{\omega} - 5 = 0##, ##\omega## being the parameter. From my side, the only thing I could...
Back
Top