Can We Make Contact with an Anti-Matter Black Hole?

AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers on the theoretical existence of antimatter black holes and their properties compared to matter black holes. It is suggested that while antimatter black holes could theoretically exist, they would require an antimatter-dominant universe to form, which does not exist in our current understanding. If a matter black hole and an antimatter black hole were to collide, they would merge into a larger black hole without any distinguishable properties beyond mass, charge, and spin. The potential energy release from such a collision is significant, but the lack of antimatter in our universe makes the scenario unlikely. Overall, the feasibility of making contact with an antimatter black hole remains a speculative topic in physics.
chasrob
Messages
185
Reaction score
58
Is there any such thing? Or is it unphysical?

If it's physical, would making contact with a matter black hole result in E=mc^2?

Thanks.
 
Last edited:
Astronomy news on Phys.org
chasrob said:
Is there any such thing? Or is it unphysical?

If it's physical, would making contact with a matter black hole result in E=mc^2?

It's highly unlikely. In case of contact with matter (black hole or not), the reaction would take place inside, so we would never know.
 
Seems unphysical in this universe. not enough loose antimatter to go around.

But in an anti matter universe, perhaps so.

wiki answers sez:

What is an antimatter black hole?
Answer:
This is a black hole formed from antimatter, instead of matter. The only real difference thereby being that the matter within the black hole would have an opposite charge from normal matter. Other than that, an antimatter black hole, while still theoretical at this point, should have properties the same as a black hole formed from 'normal' matter.
As with a normal black hole, an antimatter black hole would be created by having enough antimatter to cause a gravitational collapse.
 
If an antimatter and a matter black hole collided, how much energy would be released?? Would it be enough to eject the gamma rays from the gravitational well?
 
You would never have an anti matter BH in a matter dominant universe. So the two would never collide.
An anti-matter BH could only form in a theoretical anti-matter universe.
google baryogenesis for more info.
 
mathman said:
It's highly unlikely. In case of contact with matter (black hole or not), the reaction would take place inside, so we would never know.

Say a solar mass BH and antiBH were involved... several FOEs of energy released, and we see nothing? Wow, hard to believe.
 
Last edited:
Let's drop the answer that there isn't antimatter in high enough concentrations to produce black holes in our universe. That's irrelevant.

Once you've formed the black hole, it has exactly three properties: Mass, charge, and spin. Whether you make it out of matter, antimatter, or unicorns, these three numbers completely describe it. So you can make a BH of antimatter and one of matter with the same mass, charge and spin and they will be IDENTICAL.

If two collide, they will do what black holes do and merge into one larger black hole. I repeat, once you've formed the black hole it's just a black hole -- no special properties besides mass, charge, and spin remain.
 
The properties of matter will be crushed out of existence in a black hole, so they will not be distinguishable one from the other. In other words, I agree with Nabeshin.
 
chasrob said:
Say a solar mass BH and antiBH were involved... several FOEs of energy released, and we see nothing? Wow, hard to believe.

Yep, that's how it works, as far as anyone knows. In the current political climate it's difficult to acquire funds for the experiment.
 

Similar threads

Replies
20
Views
2K
Replies
13
Views
3K
Replies
10
Views
2K
Replies
4
Views
3K
Replies
10
Views
2K
Back
Top