Can You See a Parallel Universe Through a Black Hole?

  • Thread starter Thread starter cashflow
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Black hole Hole
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers around the theory that one might see light from a parallel universe just before crossing the event horizon of a black hole, specifically the Schwarzschild black hole. Participants express skepticism about this idea, labeling it as lacking scientific evidence and more of a speculative notion. While some mention the concept of a maximally extended Schwarzschild solution, it is noted that such theories are not considered physically realistic. The possibility of seeing another universe is linked to the concept of a Schwarzschild wormhole, but this would only occur after crossing the horizon. Overall, the consensus is that the idea of perceiving a parallel universe through a black hole is largely unfounded.
cashflow
Messages
36
Reaction score
1
I read somewhere that in a particular type of black hole, an instant before falling past the event horizon, you can see light from a parallel universe. Now I can't find the link. Was it the Schwarzschild black hole? Can't remember.

What is the validity of that theory?
 
Astronomy news on Phys.org
http://cosmology.berkeley.edu/Education/BHfaq.html#q3

not sure about the difference in what you would see through a static black hole but from the link its really nothing special. Highly doubt you would see a parallel universe regardless of any circumstance one might find themselves in.
 
cashflow said:
I read somewhere that in a particular type of black hole, an instant before falling past the event horizon, you can see light from a parallel universe. Now I can't find the link. Was it the Schwarzschild black hole? Can't remember.

What is the validity of that theory?

What you read was garbage.
 
Theres an annoying idea floating around the interwebz and even IRL that inside a black hole is a gate way to another universe. Theres no evidence for that at all, any more than the statement "inside a black hole you can find unicorn gold"
 
doesn't sound real. It is likely a 'theory' based on no scientific data (ie a guess or something someone would like to be real)
 
cashflow said:
I read somewhere that in a particular type of black hole, an instant before falling past the event horizon, you can see light from a parallel universe. Now I can't find the link. Was it the Schwarzschild black hole?

This is true for the maximally extended Schwarzschild solution. The two external universes are regions I and IV of the diagram on page 189 (pdf page 196) from the link below.
cashflow said:
What is the validity of that theory?

It is not thought to be physically realistic. For a diagram that corresponds to a black hole formed from stellar collapse, see the diagram on page 191 (pdf page 198) from the link below.

http://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9712019
 
cashflow said:
I read somewhere that in a particular type of black hole, an instant before falling past the event horizon, you can see light from a parallel universe. Now I can't find the link. Was it the Schwarzschild black hole? Can't remember.

What is the validity of that theory?

You might be talking about the Schwarzschild wormhole-

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wormhole#Schwarzschild_wormholes

Though you only see the other universe once you've crossed the horizon.
 
cashflow said:
I read somewhere that in a particular type of black hole, an instant before falling past the event horizon, you can see light from a parallel universe. Now I can't find the link. Was it the Schwarzschild black hole?

I just noticed that this is the subject of problem 25 from chapter 12 of Hartle's book Gravity: An Introduction to Einstein's General Relativity.
 
Thanks everyone for your answers. That's what I was wondering about. So, do they exist?
 
Back
Top