Where should philosophy be categorized?

  • Thread starter BoardTracker
  • Start date
  • Tags
    Philosophy
In summary, the conversation revolves around where philosophy should be categorized in web directories. Suggestions include placing it under Social Science, Arts & Humanities, or Science & Technology, but the general consensus is that philosophy should have its own category as it is the parent category of most fields of study. Some believe it fits best under Arts & Humanities, while others think it may fit under Social Science. The conversation also discusses how philosophy is similar to an art form and how it forms schools with different perspectives. Overall, it is agreed that philosophy should have its own category rather than being placed under a different field of study.
  • #1
BoardTracker
4
0
We recently had to reevaluate where philosophy fits in the scheme of things.
When creating a general category, as exists on some web directories on the web for example, philosophy's place is always a strange and undecided one.
Besides placing it in its own category, where would you place it?
Under: Social science > philosophy?
maybe : Arts & humanities > philosophy?
Some place it under: Science & Technology> philosophy?
Any other suggestions/thoughts/ideas?
Where do you think it fits best?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
  • #2
Well I have the often stated opinion that philosophy is an art form, like music or painting, and I adduce its propensity to form schools that never settle their differences but continue to exist side by side, and old schools occasionally are revived just like retro fashions. Also each school seems to consist of one big time name, e.g. Kant or Wittgenstein, as it were Mozart or Picasso, and a lot of imitators. Just so Classical Music and Cubism.
 
  • #3
Well, the thing is that Philosophy is really the parent category of most fields of study. The problem is that sometimes, subfields of Philosophy codify their methodology and blossom into important fields of study in their own right (such as mathematics or the physical sciences). For some reason, the customary usage of the word "philosophy" tends to exclude such subfields.
 
  • #4
But assuming people look for it under a non philosophy top-category..
Would you think it best first in
Art & Humanities - I thought about it but thought its a bit presumptuous to expect people to realize its there, but what do you think?
Social science? (I have a tiny feeling it best fitting)
another?

If you had to guess where most people will first look for it.. what do you think will be the most common guess?

if you had to guess where it is on DMoz for example - http://www.dmoz.com/
where will be your first guess?
 
  • #5
I agree with Hurkyl. Asking where it should be on that dmoz page doesn't make much sense to me-- philosophy is not properly categorized under any of those categories, and so should be a category of its own. Trying to fit philosophy into one of those categories would be like deleting science from the list and trying to fit it into one of the remaining categories. It wouldn't really work.
 

Related to Where should philosophy be categorized?

1. What is the purpose of categorizing philosophy?

Categorizing philosophy helps to organize and understand the vast and complex field of philosophical thought. It allows for easier identification and comparison of different philosophical ideas and theories.

2. How are philosophies typically categorized?

There are various ways in which philosophies can be categorized, including by time period (e.g. ancient, medieval, modern), by geographical region (e.g. Western, Eastern), by subject matter (e.g. metaphysics, ethics, epistemology), and by philosophical tradition or school of thought (e.g. existentialism, pragmatism, analytic philosophy).

3. Why do some philosophies overlap in categories?

Some philosophies may overlap in categories because they often address multiple subjects and can be difficult to neatly categorize. Additionally, some philosophies may have influenced or been influenced by other philosophies, leading to similarities and overlaps in categories.

4. How do categorizations of philosophy change over time?

Categorizations of philosophy can change over time as new philosophies emerge and existing philosophies evolve. Additionally, as societies and cultures change, the way in which philosophies are categorized may also change.

5. Are there any limitations to categorizing philosophy?

Yes, there are limitations to categorizing philosophy. Categorizations can be subjective and may not accurately capture the complexity and nuance of certain philosophies. Additionally, some philosophies may not neatly fit into any one category, making it difficult to categorize them accurately.

Similar threads

  • General Discussion
Replies
12
Views
1K
Replies
1
Views
15K
  • General Discussion
Replies
2
Views
2K
Replies
12
Views
12K
Replies
3
Views
75
Replies
19
Views
3K
  • New Member Introductions
Replies
1
Views
524
  • General Discussion
Replies
14
Views
2K
Replies
6
Views
3K
Replies
3
Views
1K
Back
Top