Classical EM vs Orbital Angular Momentum

  • #1
LarryS
Gold Member
328
23
Consider the following experiment from the point-of-view of classical mechanics and classical electromagnetism: An originally free electron then passes through a magnetic field that is oriented so that it causes the electron to turn to, say, the right. During the “turning” of the electron (a finite time interval), does it temporarily possesses classical orbital angular momentum?

As always, thanks in advance.
 

Answers and Replies

  • #2
gneill
Mentor
20,947
2,892
I'm not sure if there's any technical distinction between regular "angular momentum" and "orbital angular momentum", save that one is associated with an orbiting body.

Before the electron even enters the region of the magnetic field it already possesses angular momentum about the future center of the circular arc.

1580413195145.png
 
  • Like
Likes Dr_Nate, LarryS and vanhees71
  • #3
A.T.
Science Advisor
11,668
2,961
During the “turning” of the electron (a finite time interval), does it temporarily possesses classical orbital angular momentum?
As @gneill notes: It has angular momentum even when it's moving in a straight line, around any point not on that line.

What exactly do you mean by "classical orbital angular momentum"? There is some abiguity:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orbital_angular_momentum
 
  • #4
33,696
11,283
During the “turning” of the electron (a finite time interval), does it temporarily possesses classical orbital angular momentum?
Yes, except that it is probably much less temporary than you might assume.
 
  • #5
QLogic
44
18
Edit: Ignore referframe. I thought you meant a quantum electron

Before the electron even enters the region of the magnetic field it already possesses angular momentum about the future center of the circular arc
Not exactly, although the distinction is a pedantic one to a certain degree in such a situation. It is still the case that one might measure the electron in a basis not commuting with Angular Momentum. Only if we have an experimental set up which can measure angular momentum can we then say (assuming the wave function is reasonably "tight" about a classical path) that it has orbital angular momentum.
 
Last edited:
  • #6
gneill
Mentor
20,947
2,892
Not exactly, although the distinction is a pedantic one to a certain degree in such a situation. It is still the case that one might measure the electron in a basis not commuting with Angular Momentum. Only if we have an experimental set up which can measure angular momentum can we then say (assuming the wave function is reasonably "tight" about a classical path) that it has orbital angular momentum.
Keep in mind that this problem is posed in a "Classical Physics" domain.
 
  • #7
QLogic
44
18
Keep in mind that this problem is posed in a "Classical Physics" domain.
Well if the electron is treated as a classical object then it definitely has orbital angular momentum. I thought usage of "temporarily possesses classical orbital angular momentum" suggested the electron was being treated quantum mechanically.
 
  • #8
33,696
11,283
one might measure the electron in a basis not commuting with Angular Momentum
I guess you missed the word “classical”. He is talking about a classical point charge, not an actual electron.
 
  • #9
gneill
Mentor
20,947
2,892
Well if the electron is treated as a classical object then it definitely has orbital angular momentum. I thought usage of "temporarily possesses classical orbital angular momentum" suggested the electron was being treated quantum mechanically.
No harm, no foul. I frequently misinterpret intended situations until I stand back and look at the context.
 
  • Like
Likes Dale and QLogic
  • #10
LarryS
Gold Member
328
23
I'm not sure if there's any technical distinction between regular "angular momentum" and "orbital angular momentum", save that one is associated with an orbiting body.

Before the electron even enters the region of the magnetic field it already possesses angular momentum about the future center of the circular arc.

View attachment 256352
Thanks, I forgot just how general the definition of classical angular momentum was.
 

Suggested for: Classical EM vs Orbital Angular Momentum

Replies
3
Views
449
Replies
9
Views
571
Replies
3
Views
355
  • Last Post
Replies
12
Views
388
  • Last Post
Replies
29
Views
870
  • Last Post
Replies
2
Views
427
Replies
9
Views
704
Replies
19
Views
417
Replies
2
Views
351
Top