Commutator relations of field operators

2 replies · 4K views · last reply
QuantumRose
Messages
11
Reaction score
1
Here is the question:
By using the equality (for boson)
Equation: [AB, C] = A[B, C] + [A, C]B, a commutator identity for operators A, B and C.
---------------------------------------- (1)
Prove that
Equation: the commutator of the gradient of the field operator psi-dagger at x' with the gradient of psi at x', and psi at x, equals minus the gradient of the delta function delta(x' - x) dotted with the gradient of psi at x'.


Background:
Currently I'm learning things about second quantization in the book "Advanced Quantum Mechanics"(Franz Schwabl).
Given the creation and annihilation operators(
Inline equation: the commutator-type expression a_i^† and a_i, with a dagger on the first operator and a subscript i on both.
), define field operators as
Two equations defining field operators: psi(x) equals the sum over i of phi_i(x) a_i, and psi-dagger(x) equals the sum over i of phi_i*(x) a_i-dagger.

The following 3 commutator relations are for Boson.
Three commutator relations for bosonic field operators: [psi(x), psi(x')] = 0, [psi-dagger(x), psi-dagger(x')] = 0, and [psi(x), psi-dagger(x')] = delta cubed of (x minus x').
-----------------------------------(2)

And here is my attempt (but it doesn't work):
First step, using equality (1) to expand the commutator:
Handwritten-style equation: commutator of the gradient of the field operator psi-dagger with the gradient of psi, expanded as grad psi-dagger(x) commutator with psi(x) plus commutator of psi-dagger(x) with psi(x) times grad psi(x).
-------------(3)
since the nabla operator is an operator, so I think the first term of (3)'s right-hand-side can be expressed as following
Equation: ∇ψ†(x') [∇'ψ(x'), ψ(x)] = ∇'ψ†(x')∇'[ψ(x'), ψ(x)] + ∇'ψ†(x')[∇', ψ(x)]ψ(x')

also, I expressed the second term of (3)'s right-hand-side by using the same method
Equation: [∇ψ̂†(x'), ψ(x)]∇ψ(x') = ∇[ψ̂†(x'), ψ(x)]∇ψ(x') + [∇', ψ(x)]ψ̂†(x')∇'ψ(x')

So, by inserting those commutators in (2), I found
Handwritten derivation of a commutator expansion: [∇'ψ†(x')∇'ψ(x), ψ(x)] equals 0 plus ∇'ψ†(x')[∇', ψ(x)]ψ(x') plus ∇'δ³(x' − x)·∇'ψ(x') plus [∇', ψ(x)]ψ†(x')∇'ψ(x').
 
Last edited:
Your line after (3) looks wrong to me.

Try doing this first: apply ##\nabla'## to each of the three commutator equations in (2). That will give you some extra utility formulas that you can use to simply (3) more correctly, and quicker.
 
strangerep said:
Your line after (3) looks wrong to me.

Try doing this first: apply ##\nabla'## to each of the three commutator equations in (2). That will give you some extra utility formulas that you can use to simply (3) more correctly, and quicker.

That helps me a lot! Thanks! Indeed, my calculations are wrong after (3). And I also forgot that ##\nabla'## only acts on x' !