Components of the Moons Acceleration

AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on deriving the equations for the moon's acceleration around the Earth, specifically breaking down total acceleration into its x and y components. The user initially struggles with the correct application of trigonometric functions, mistakenly using cosine and sine incorrectly. Clarifications reveal that the gravitational force formula involves the mass of the Earth, not the moon, and the correct approach is to use the angle T with respect to the x-axis for the components of acceleration. The user updates their equations to ax = a*cos(T) and ay = a*sin(T), but still needs to derive the angle T based on the moon's orbital period. The conversation emphasizes the importance of understanding the relationship between the angle and the moon's position over time.
neo32
Messages
5
Reaction score
0
Hello, I need help on deriving equations for the moon's acceleration around the earth. I've found that the total acceleration is a=Gm/r^2 (G is gravitational constant, m is mass of moon and r is the Earth to moon distance) what i need to do is split this into its x and y components, and derive equations in terms of a, r, x, and/or y. I have ax=cos(x/r) and ay=sin(y/r) but it's not working. I also have to take into account the direction of the acceleration (towards the earth)

Any help would be really appreciated.
 
Physics news on Phys.org
neo32 said:
I have ax=cos(x/r) and ay=sin(y/r) but it's not working.

Is x/r an angle ? Is y/r an angle ?
Should you take sin and cos of this quantity ?
 
well x and y are the coordinate positions from the Earth (which is at the origin) so this will make a triangle with the x-axis. Using trigonometry, x would be the adjacent side and y would be the opposite side, and r would be the hypotenuse (distance from Earth to moon). I'm supposed to use trig relationships so I would think that I need to take sin and cos of this quantity but I don't know why it won't work.
 
It won't work because it doesn't make sense! Saying you are "supposed to use trig relationships" doesn't mean you just apply sine and cosine to whatever numbers you want.
It is true that sin(\theta)= \frac{y}{r} where \theta is the angle the position vector makes with the x-axis. That is NOT
cos(\frac{y}{r})!

By the way- the "m" in your formula is mass of the earth, not the moon. The gravitational force formula involves both masses. Since that is equal to mass(of moon) times acceleration(of moon), it is the mass of the moon that cancels.
 
By the way i just noticed that those were supposed to be ASIN and ACOS. sorry. And thanks for clearing that up about the m value.

Anyways, what would i use then if I'm not supposed to apply sine and cosine? Should ASIN and ACOS work?
 
I fixed my equations: they're ax = a*cos(T) and ay = a*sin(T) where ax is the x component and ay is the y component of acceleration, r is the earth-moon distance, and T is the angle with the x axis). The problem is I need to derive T as well and plug that into the two equations. if those equations are wrong too then can someone put me on the right track? thanks
 
Last edited:
Well, T is an angle, right? What's the angle corresponding to one complete orbit of the moon about the earth? And how much time does it take the moon to perform this orbit? Using those two bits of information, can you come up with an expression that gives you the angle for any given time?

Unless your assignment specifically states otherwise, it's probably reasonable to assume that the angle T=0 at time t=0.
 
Back
Top