Could Fusion Cavitation be a Possible Factor in the Sun's Reactions?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Intuitive
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Fusion Vibration
AI Thread Summary
The discussion explores the feasibility of using a levitating coil and electromagnets to vibrate an iron ball in an attempt to induce fusion reactions with deuterium. It concludes that the mass and impracticality of vibrating such a heavy object make it unlikely to achieve the necessary conditions for fusion. The core of the Sun, primarily composed of hydrogen and helium, operates under extreme temperatures and densities that are not conducive to the proposed method. Additionally, the core is a plasma, which does not vibrate in the manner suggested. The possibility of fusion cavitation as an additional process in the Sun's reactions is questioned, but traditional fusion mechanisms remain the primary focus.
Intuitive
Messages
270
Reaction score
0
If we made a custom levitating coil like this:
http://www.geocities.com/Area51/Shire/3075/globe.html
so that we could suspend a small Iron ball in the levitation coil.

Next
If we added two small but powerful electromagnets to each opposite equatorial side of the Iron ball so we could play tug of war with the Iron ball with the Electromagnets while in suspension, the two added electromagnets called Y and Z take turns, Y turns on while Z is off, Then Y shuts off and Z turns on, the process alternates between the two electromagnets.

The question is, How many times a second would the two electromagnets have to turn off and on so that a vibration in the Iron Ball begins to resinate
the Iron ball so that it begins to react with the surrounding air and what would the Iron balls vibrational velocity have to be to create a surface fusion reaction on the Balls surface from slamming into air molecules?

assume that the air is Deuterium.

Also, What would be the vibrational distance of the Iron Ball moving side to side be?
 
Last edited:
Engineering news on Phys.org
First of all, the mass of the iron balls, depending on the diameter, would be considerable. It would be impractical to vibrate iron balls to cause fusion in deuterium.

On a first principle level, the coupling between atoms of Fe and D is just impractical.

Now, consider that a 10 keV D has a speed of about 978 km/s, it does not seem practical to move a massive steel ball with a velocity of this magnitude.

Now consider that the velocity of sound in steel is on the order of 5 km/s, so the velocity of the deuteron at 10 keV is 2 orders of magnitude greater than the acoustic velocity in steel.

Now consider that 1 eV is equivalent to 11605 K, then a 10 keV deuteron has an equivalent temperature of 116 million K, and for fusion of a pure D plamsa, one would probably want a temperature of 50-100 keV. The melting point of steel is about 1700 K.
 
Astronuc said:
First of all, the mass of the iron balls, depending on the diameter, would be considerable. It would be impractical to vibrate iron balls to cause fusion in deuterium.

On a first principle level, the coupling between atoms of Fe and D is just impractical.

Now, consider that a 10 keV D has a speed of about 978 km/s, it does not seem practical to move a massive steel ball with a velocity of this magnitude.

Now consider that the velocity of sound in steel is on the order of 5 km/s, so the velocity of the deuteron at 10 keV is 2 orders of magnitude greater than the acoustic velocity in steel.

Now consider that 1 eV is equivalent to 11605 K, then a 10 keV deuteron has an equivalent temperature of 116 million K, and for fusion of a pure D plamsa, one would probably want a temperature of 50-100 keV. The melting point of steel is about 1700 K.

Thanks Astronuc.

Would you have an approximation, in hertz what the Iron core of our Sun maybe be vibrating at? This was actually the reason why I had asked the before questions, The experiment I mentioned was just a curiosity of the numbers involved and if an Iron core actually helped resinate D plasma as
part of a chain of events within the Fusion reaction itself.

Greatly appreciate the help you've given so far. :smile:
 
Last edited:
The core of the sun is not Fe. The sun is primarily H and He.

Core of Sun - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sun
At the center of the Sun, where its density reaches up to 150,000 kg/m3 (150 times the density of water on Earth), thermonuclear reactions (nuclear fusion) convert hydrogen into helium, producing the energy that keeps the Sun in a state of equilibrium. About 8.9×1037 protons (hydrogen nuclei) are converted to helium nuclei every second, releasing energy at the matter-energy conversion rate of 4.26 million tonnes per second or 383 yottawatts (9.15×1016 tons of TNT per second). Models predict that the high-energy photons released in fusion reactions take about a million years to reach the Sun's surface, where they escape as visible light. Neutrinos are also released in the fusion reactions in the core, but unlike photons they very rarely interact with matter, and so almost all are able to escape the Sun immediately.

The core extends from the center of the Sun to about 0.2 solar radii, and is the only part of the Sun where an appreciable amount of heat is produced by fusion: the rest of the star is heated by energy that is transferred outward. All of the energy of the interior fusion must travel through the successive layers to the solar photosphere, before it escapes to space.

The core is a plasma, a highly ionized gas, so it does not vibrate in the way to which was alluded in the first post.

Also, I should point out that the sun is fusing H rather than D or T, although D and T are likely present in small quantities. The temperature in the core is believed to be about 13.6 million K, 1170 ev (1.17 keV) which is relatively cool. However the particles (nuclear) density in the suns core is about a trillion times denser than the hottest magnetically confined plasmas we can produce on earth.
 
Astronuc said:
The core of the sun is not Fe. The sun is primarily H and He.

Core of Sun - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sun


The core is a plasma, a highly ionized gas, so it does not vibrate in the way to which was alluded in the first post.

Also, I should point out that the sun is fusing H rather than D or T, although D and T are likely present in small quantities. The temperature in the core is believed to be about 13.6 million K, 1170 ev (1.17 keV) which is relatively cool. However the particles (nuclear) density in the suns core is about a trillion times denser than the hottest magnetically confined plasmas we can produce on earth.

Thanks for the clear and precise answers, I appreciate it, Thanks again Astronuc. :smile:

Step 3, Would you scientifically assume that Fusion Cavitation effects as an additional process within the Suns reactions could be taking place though sonic cavitation methods as well as traditional known Fusion reactions you posted?

Thanks buddy :smile:
 
Last edited:
Hello everyone, I am currently working on a burnup calculation for a fuel assembly with repeated geometric structures using MCNP6. I have defined two materials (Material 1 and Material 2) which are actually the same material but located in different positions. However, after running the calculation with the BURN card, I am encountering an issue where all burnup information(power fraction(Initial input is 1,but output file is 0), burnup, mass, etc.) for Material 2 is zero, while Material 1...
Hi everyone, I'm a complete beginner with MCNP and trying to learn how to perform burnup calculations. Right now, I'm feeling a bit lost and not sure where to start. I found the OECD-NEA Burnup Credit Calculational Criticality Benchmark (Phase I-B) and was wondering if anyone has worked through this specific benchmark using MCNP6? If so, would you be willing to share your MCNP input file for it? Seeing an actual working example would be incredibly helpful for my learning. I'd be really...
Back
Top