Cover songs versus the original track, which ones are better?

  • Context: Music 
  • Thread starter Thread starter pinball1970
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Track
Click For Summary
SUMMARY

This discussion centers on the comparative analysis of cover songs versus their original versions, highlighting specific examples such as Johnny Cash's cover of "Hurt" and Jimi Hendrix's rendition of "All Along the Watchtower." Participants argue that the quality of a cover is subjective, often depending on personal taste and the context in which the songs are experienced. Notable mentions include The Residents' cover of "(I Can't Get No) Satisfaction" and the contrasting styles of Simon & Garfunkel versus Disturbed. The conversation emphasizes the importance of interpretation and arrangement in determining whether a cover enhances or detracts from the original work.

PREREQUISITES
  • Understanding of music theory and arrangement techniques
  • Familiarity with notable cover songs and their original counterparts
  • Knowledge of subjective versus objective analysis in music critique
  • Awareness of the cultural impact of iconic artists like Johnny Cash and Jimi Hendrix
NEXT STEPS
  • Research the impact of Jimi Hendrix's "All Along the Watchtower" on music history
  • Explore the nuances of music interpretation in cover songs
  • Analyze the critical reception of Johnny Cash's "Hurt" compared to the original by Nine Inch Nails
  • Investigate the role of personal bias in music appreciation and critique
USEFUL FOR

Music enthusiasts, critics, and artists interested in the dynamics of cover songs versus originals, as well as anyone exploring the subjective nature of musical interpretation and performance.

  • #901
This is attention to detail. Love of the music.

 
Reply
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: DennisN
Science news on Phys.org
  • #902
Ok last one for these guys. They cover Steely Dan. Steely Dan are insane. Ronald Fagen specifically is insane. His chord progressions should not have melodies that work but they do. They are better than "work" they are genius and unique.
This bunch of kids know what they are doing I think. They describe the set up for recording.

 
  • #903
OK, enough is enough:



"Squeal like a Piggy!" (Bonus points to anyone who gets the joke)
 
Reply
  • Haha
  • Love
Likes   Reactions: DennisN and pinball1970
  • #904
Ok last one for these guys. They cover Steely Dan. Steely Dan are insane. Ronald Fagin
Vanadium 50 said:
OK, enough is enough:



"Squeal like a Piggy!" (Bonus points to anyone who gets the joke)

That film was very disturbing to me. Very.

There is enough beautiful music out there and kids are basking in that glory and want to at least try their best to replicate it.

Happy holidays V50.
 
  • #905
pinball1970 said:
hat film was very disturbing to me. Very.
But that's not the joke.
 
  • #906
Vanadium 50 said:
But that's not the joke.
Mm. Ok, well dueling tubas does not quite hit the spot for me and I cannot find the joke.
You have will have to tell me.
 
  • #907
DennisN said:
Laura Branigan - Gloria

Ok, here's another cover I heard for the first time a couple of days ago... by Laura Branigan again.
And on this one... well, what can I say? She takes the vocals to a whole different level... :))
The vocals are so powerful I have to say I like the cover more than the original :smile:.
Gosh, this girl could sing!

Cover: Laura Branigan - The Power of Love



The original was performed by Jennifer Rush, and it's a song I very much remember from the 1980s.
I wasn't a die-hard fan of it, but I thought it was a good song (actually there are comparatively very few ballads from the 1980s I like, but I post a link to one exception below (*)).

Original: Jennifer Rush - The Power Of Love (Official Video)



* One BIG exception is "Don't Give Up" (with Peter Gabriel and Kate Bush) which simply is a phenomenal song, in my opinon ❤️).
 
Reply
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: pinball1970
  • #908
Reply
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: pinball1970
  • #909
Vanadium 50 said:
"Squeal like a Piggy!" (Bonus points to anyone who gets the joke)
Hmm,... those tuba players are doing to the original song what the rednecks did to Ned Beatty in the film?
 
Reply
  • Haha
Likes   Reactions: DennisN, Astronuc and pinball1970
  • #910
Just now, I became aware of Diana Ankudinova (incredible range of pitch):

Cover of "Wicked Game":


Cover of one of the main Dune themes:
 
Reply
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: pinball1970
  • #911
strangerep said:
those tuba players are doing to the original song what the rednecks did to Ned Beatty in the film?
<sigh>

A "piggy" is a style of tuba. The intent is that it sounds like a big tuba, but takes up less space: tubas are not piccolos, and sometimes available space (e.g. in an orchestra pit) is at a premium.
 
Reply
  • Like
  • Informative
Likes   Reactions: Astronuc and pinball1970
  • #912
Oh, and if we are talking about covers of Jump.

 
Reply
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: pinball1970
  • #913
Vanadium 50 said:
Oh, and if we are talking about covers of Jump.


Technically this is a mash up not a cover. @Hornbein likes these.
 
  • #914
Vanadium 50 said:
A "piggy" is a style of tuba. The intent is that it sounds like a big tuba, but takes up less space: tubas are not piccolos, and sometimes available space (e.g. in an orchestra pit) is at a premium.
Given the film and given your sense of humour, I think this link is a win.
 
  • #915
pinball1970 said:
Technically this is a mash up
I disagree. Different musicians playing a different arrangement of the same song is a cover. Granted, there are differences in styles. But one could say that about Aretha Franklin's Respect (yes, that's a cover), Ike and Tina Turner's Proud Mary, or Cowboy Junkies Sweet Jane.

If you want an example where things are more ambiguous, there is Carole King.James Taylor's You've Got A Friend. Recorded by the same musicians at the same session (and possibly even the same take), released a week apart with two different vocal tracks. Who covered whom? Or who mashednup whom?
 
  • #916
Vanadium 50 said:
disagree. Different musicians playing a different arrangement of the same song is a cover
No. They stick two tracks together, C'mon everybody and Jump.
 
  • #917
Vanadium 50 said:
If you want an example where things are more ambiguous, there is Carole King.James Taylor's You've Got A Friend
There will be greyer areas.

What is a cover? A cover is a version where the original song is recorded, released and then copied at a later date.The original song may or may not be recorded by the artist who wrote it, all points of discussion.

A mash up is splicing different songs together.
 
Reply
  • Informative
Likes   Reactions: symbolipoint
  • #918
So I would argue that Big Daddy's Jump is a cover. They took the sheet music, made an arrangement in another style, and then recorded it. Seems pretty cut and dried.

There is also a difference between a "quote" and a :mash up". For decades, probably centuries, composers have used a bar or two of one piece in another. As in the 1812 Overture.

As far as You've Got A Friend, the case can be made that either recording was the "original".
 
  • #919
Vanadium 50 said:
So I would argue that Big Daddy's Jump is a cover. They took the sheet music, made an arrangement in another style, and then recorded it. Seems pretty cut and dried.

There is also a difference between a "quote" and a :mash up". For decades, probably centuries, composers have used a bar or two of one piece in another. As in the 1812 Overture.

As far as You've Got A Friend, the case can be made that either recording was the "original".
No. Covering a song and amalgamation of two songs or more is different.

Perhaps you want to put things into sets? The song, the cover of the song and amalgamations of the songs. Where is @fresh_42 when you need him?

Sounds like a thread?
 
  • #920
Vanadium 50 said:
There is also a difference between a "quote" and a :mash up". For decades, probably centuries, composers have used a bar or two of one piece in another. As in the 1812 Overture.
Wow. I REALLY think you know what this thread is supposed to be about.
Can I suggest you just don't do that? You did the same with the Tolkien thread

It doesn't matter, music will not change. Perhaps posters will give a few insights.
Interaction with smart posters.
 
  • #921
Call it whatever you want it, Big Daddy's Jump is not only worse than Van Halen's Jump, it's not good at all.
 
  • #922
Found nice little gems, both original and cover:


​
 
Reply
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: pinball1970
  • #923
pinball1970 said:
Can I suggest you just don't do that?
"It's my thread. I decide who can participate and what they are allowed to say. Go away." Got it.
 
  • #924
Vanadium 50 said:
"It's my thread. I decide who can participate and what they are allowed to say. Go away." Got it.
Post what you want and it will not be interrupted by my unnecessary pedantry.

Mongolian throat singing cover of YMCA or Slayers raining blood, the Las Vegas years, will all be welcome.
 
  • #925
One of the best songs from what I thought was a horrible period in pop music.

Russians.

It's in Cm so sting is hitting tenor As and Bb (A4)




Then he sang it in Russia and dropped a tone.



Then he dropped a few more to F#m, still powerful and the cello suits it.

 
Last edited:
  • #926
A Russian covering "Full house" by Kate Bush.

 
  • #927
Nirvana y Aixa ( https://www.youtube.com/@radionubeoficial - https://www.youtube.com/@radionubeoficial/shorts )


Young siblings rock out on drums and guitar - aged ten and eight | SWNS

Meet the siblings who rock out on the drums and guitar - at the ages of ten and eight.​
Nirvana Sota and her younger sister Aixa Sota have already performed at live shows and can cover famous hits like 'Enter Sandman' by Metallica or 'Creep' by Radiohead.​
Nirvana plays the guitar and Aixa the drums while dad Jussef Sota ,43, and mum Ilusión Sota, 42, play bass and piano respectively.​
The sisters have been playing since they were two years old and the family formed a band called Radio Nube two years ago.​
The family from Hermosillo, México....​



Nirvana y Aixa TOP TEN 2023


Nirvana y Aixa tocan The Trooper de IRON MAIDEN


Aixa y Nirvana tocan La Grange [by ZZ Top]


Nirvana y Aixa tocan Tom Sawyer de RUSH


Nirvana toca Ballerina 12/24 de STEVE VAI @SteveVaiHimself
 
Last edited:
Reply
  • Love
Likes   Reactions: pinball1970
  • #929
I just noticed this cover of Gollum's Song (from The Two Towers) by Alina Gingertail.



Questions: what is the 1st instrument that appears? It seems to be played with a bow and levers.

Also, what is the small compact wind instrument that appears later?
 
Last edited:
Reply
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: pinball1970
  • #930
pinball1970 said:
A mash up is splicing different songs together.

(another) case in point:
 
Reply
  • Like
Likes   Reactions: pinball1970

Similar threads

Music Songs that pay homage to deceased artists, no covers
  • · Replies 57 ·
2
Replies
57
Views
6K
Wendy Carlos's Moog-synthesized classics
  • · Replies 8 ·
Replies
8
Views
3K
Impersonation News
  • · Replies 10 ·
Replies
10
Views
2K
Are Cover Versions Better Than the Originals?
  • · Replies 167 ·
6
Replies
167
Views
27K
Band Dynamics: How to Handle Conflicts and Keep the Music Playing
  • · Replies 31 ·
2
Replies
31
Views
4K
Mini road trip: Riding the waves in the mountains
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
2K
NS Derailment, East Palestine, Ohio - 3 Feb, 2023 - Engineering Aspect
  • · Replies 9 ·
Replies
9
Views
3K
The Scientist as Hero - or not
  • · Replies 1 ·
Replies
1
Views
3K
Undergrad Wavelength to Frequency Relationship in Musical Notes
  • · Replies 11 ·
Replies
11
Views
5K
C/C++ C++ Primer or PPP Stoustrup: Which Book is Better for Beginner Programmers?
  • · Replies 5 ·
Replies
5
Views
7K