Music Cover songs versus the original track, which ones are better?

  • Thread starter Thread starter pinball1970
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Track
AI Thread Summary
The discussion centers around the merits of cover songs compared to their originals, exploring which covers are considered better and which should have been avoided. The subjective nature of evaluating music is emphasized, with opinions varying widely based on personal taste. Notable examples include Jimi Hendrix's cover of "All Along the Watchtower," which many argue surpasses Bob Dylan's original, and Johnny Cash's rendition of "Hurt," which evokes deep emotion. Other covers, such as those by Eva Cassidy and the Bare Naked Ladies, are praised for their unique interpretations that enhance the originals. Conversely, some covers are criticized for lacking originality or failing to add anything new, with specific songs mentioned as examples of covers that should have been left alone. The conversation also touches on the broader implications of musical interpretation, the role of the listener in evaluating art, and the complexities of genre classification, particularly in jazz. Overall, the thread highlights the rich landscape of music covers, showcasing both celebrated interpretations and those deemed unnecessary.
  • #1,101
Hornbein said:

I rather like this recording of them:

I'm not sure it's really "better than the original", but the way they turn it back around after things go wrong is just perfect.
 
Science news on Phys.org
  • #1,102
I'm not crazy about the orig by Bessie Smith, so here are two covers.





Plenty of others, BB, Freddy King, and Eric Clapton included.
 
Last edited:
  • #1,103
Ibix said:
I rather like this recording of them:

I'm not sure it's really "better than the original", but the way they turn it back around after things go wrong is just perfect.

Yep. Rock and roll is supposed to be fun.
 
  • #1,104
pinball1970 said:
Which songs were performed, arranged or produced better in a cover than the original version?
Which songs should have been left well alone?

Also, I think restricting the covers just to released singles will restrict some interesting stonkers and stinkers so album tracks are allowed.


Seether did Careless Whisper wayyyy better.



Maynard doing Rocketman was 🤌
 
  • #1,105
George Michael, take that!

I like this Rocket Man. Kate Bush looks drunk. Been studying Marilyn Monroe.

 
  • Like
Likes MotherMayhem
  • #1,106
 
  • #1,107
Hornbein said:
Orig

Catfish Blues by Muddy Waters



Cover


By golly, Evan Nicole Bell herself corrected me. "orig by robert petway in 1941, then re-interpreted by muddy waters as "rollin' stone" in 1950. my 2023 version here takes inspiration from hendrix's 1967 recording - a true testament to keeping the blues alive!"

Here's Petway's version.

 
  • #1,108
Cover of Tom Waits' Martha. How beautiful can music be?



Orig. He wrote this at age 24. "He was born old."

 
  • #1,109
https://tonymacalpine.com/
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tony_MacAlpine
MacAlpine was highly influential in the neoclassical metal genre, becoming known for his instrumental rock style of playing that displays highly advanced shred techniques;[13] one of his most oft-used techniques being 'sweep tapping', a variation of sweep picking. He has incorporated elements of classical, jazz, fusion, hard rock and heavy metal on both guitar and keyboard, and has been described as a virtuoso by Jason Ankeny at AllMusic.[14]

"Tears of Sahara" is track 3 of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maximum_Security_(Tony_MacAlpine_album)
George Lynch (from Dokken) contributed some solos.

During grad school in 1990s, I saw Tony MacAlpine perform in a bar in Chicago.



(2008) Tears of Sahara - piano cover by yokojapan


(2018) Nili Brosh Plays Tony MacAlpine - "Tears of Sahara" FULL SONG [also see the 2012 video above]

(see also the cover of Van Halen's Girl Gone Bad in #776 and Eric Johnson's Cliffs of Dover in #1068 )

(2020) Tears Of Sahara - Tony MacAlpine (keyboard cover) by Pasquale Bubbico

(has some interesting covers of Paul Gilbert/Technical Difficulties , Marty Friedman/Megadeth Tornado of Souls , and Yngwie Malmsteen/Far Beyond the Sun)

(2023) Tears of Sahara by Tony MacAlpine - Cover Song/Collaboration Video - by Steve Stine et al.



 
  • #1,110
"I am a Viking" is a track #5 on https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marching_Out
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yngwie_Malmsteen
https://www.yngwiemalmsteen.com/

(see also #25 from Favorite Electric Guitar Rock Solos )




His Greatest Solo - Yngwie Malmsteen - I Am A Viking Cover - Steve Jeffrey


[Vocal & Guitar Cover] I am a Viking - Yngwie Malmsteen by 최영관의 워뮤밸[WMB]


I AM A VIKING - Alexios Anest feat. ASHA


I Am a Viking - Mezzo-soprano & Acoustic Guitar YJM Cover (Yet Another Superstrat)


Yngwie Malmsteen's "I am a Viking" (acoustic) - Ben Woods

(see also Ben Woods in Flamenco Guitars I AM A VIKING (Yngwie Malmsteen) Heavy Mellow )


 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes jack action
  • #1,111
I don't go for exact covers. But they have their advantages. The Band Geeks are known for among other things their exact covers of Yes songs. So Jon Anderson made them his backup band. Golly. Seems like a smart way to go.

 
  • #1,112


From Jakarta.
 
  • #1,113
Hornbein said:


From Jakarta.

This is Josephine Alexandra.
See also your post #93 (Sweet Child O' Mine)
and #505 (Welcome to the Jungle) and #552 (Enter Sandman).
 
  • Like
Likes pinball1970
  • #1,114


In honor of the recent Harvard students' graduation protest.

Songsmith Tom Morello is a Harvard grad.
 
  • #1,115
Ibix said:
Just wanted to say thanks to @pinball1970 for starting this thread, and to all the people who've contributed. I've heard and enjoyed a lot of stuff I wouldn't have done without it.
A mention to @Hornbein who has kept me on my toes, his first post was absolutely nuts. Check it out, "Satisfaction" by the residents.
 
  • #1,116
pinball1970 said:
A mention to @Hornbein who has kept me on my toes, his first post was absolutely nuts. Check it out, "Satisfaction" by the residents.
I once had someone openly request "bizarre music." I sent him (I Can't Get No) Satisfaction as interpreted by The Residents. I think it frightened him. He couldn't accept it. He responded "that's beyond bizarre."

Hey I'm a straightforward guy. You ask for bizarre, you get bizarre. If you're too much of a wimp to deal with it, that's your problem.
 
  • Haha
Likes pinball1970
  • #1,118
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/For_the_Love_of_God_(instrumental)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steve_Vai
https://vai.com/

  • STEVE VAI: "For The Love of God" Guitar Legends Seville 1991
    Steve Vai playing for the frst time live his song "For the Love of God" in Seville October 19th 1991 in Guitar Legends Festival."





Steve Vai - For The Love Of God - Cover by YOYO - A 10 year old girl

(see also #1068 (Cliffs of Dover) )

For The Love Of God - Steve Vai / Guitar Cover by Petty


For The Love Of God - Steve Vai - Cover by Tina S

(see also #438 (Moonlight Sonata) and #766 (Tornado of Souls) )

For the Love of God - Steve Vai - A Guitar Cover by 8 Girls (a Female Rockers collaboration)
[ Ginevra Pistolesi , Ash , Sylvya , Ariel Bellvalaire , Jimena Fosado , Andressa Mouxi , Bruna Terroni , Yuki (D_Drive) ]


【Cover】Steve Vai - For the Love of God (Violin Cover) - by Unlucky Morpheus

@StevenSiroVai1 - 8 months ago
Oh... My... Goodness... My Dear Jill, I have only just seen this performance now (Sep 23) and I am so absolutely touched by it. You did such a lovely job, thank you so much. It's always an honor and a pleasure to see another artist play one of my pieces, and that you performed it so lovely, with great intonation, wonderful use of harmonics and dynamics, and most of all, you played with your heart and soul which brings this melody so alive on the violin. What an absolute treat for me to see. It's always inspiring for me to hear my music played so beautifully. A big hug to you, and deep appreciation. Steve Vai
(see also #109 (Far Beyond the Sun) and #681 and #682 (Dance of Eternity) )
 
  • Love
Likes pinball1970
  • #1,119
robphy said:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/For_the_Love_of_God_(instrumental)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steve_Vai
https://vai.com/

  • STEVE VAI: "For The Love of God" Guitar Legends Seville 1991






Steve Vai - For The Love Of God - Cover by YOYO - A 10 year old girl

(see also #1068 (Cliffs of Dover) )

For The Love Of God - Steve Vai / Guitar Cover by Petty


For The Love Of God - Steve Vai - Cover by Tina S

(see also #438 (Moonlight Sonata) and #766 (Tornado of Souls) )

For the Love of God - Steve Vai - A Guitar Cover by 8 Girls (a Female Rockers collaboration)
[ Ginevra Pistolesi , Ash , Sylvya , Ariel Bellvalaire , Jimena Fosado , Andressa Mouxi , Bruna Terroni , Yuki (D_Drive) ]


【Cover】Steve Vai - For the Love of God (Violin Cover) - by Unlucky Morpheus


(see also #109 (Far Beyond the Sun) and #681 and #682 (Dance of Eternity) )

Wow, the violin version!! Amazing. Control of the harmonics just sounds crazy.
I suppose it's bread and butter to good violinist but sounds nuts to me.
EDIT. 4.32 For instance, that tone! It just comes out of nowhere. Stunning.
Pretty cool he messaged her, what a compliment.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes robphy and Klystron
  • #1,120
Born Under a Bad Sign -- Albert King


Evan Nicole Bell
Tip : 1.25 speed.
 
  • Like
Likes pinball1970
  • #1,121
pinball1970 said:
Wow, the violin version!! Amazing. Control of the harmonics just sounds crazy.
I suppose it's bread and butter to good violinist but sounds nuts to me.
EDIT. 4.32 For instance, that tone! It just comes out of nowhere. Stunning.
Pretty cool he messaged her, what a compliment.

That is very nice. As far as rock violin goes I like this. It's like getting behind the wheel of a Gran Torino, putting the petal to metal, and blasting through Hell whilst laughing like a demon. It makes my hair stand on end [horripilation]. Really.

Emilie Autumn - Organ grinder (Saw III)​




Emilie let her violin chops slide. Too much time, too little payoff. Popular music is all about the singer and songwriter so her energy went into those instead.

Emilie grew up in Malibu. She was of interest to record companies in nearby LA but they were much too controlling. She must do everything herself. Literally. She makes truly solo records through multi-tracking. She sewed her own costumes and that of her band. It's extreme. She quit classical music, also too controlling. She was in Hole(!) for a while, possibly the greatest mismatch in the history of music. Then went her own way to work her way up via the club circuit. No one makes it that way any more but I thought, if anyone can do it, Emilie can. She couldn't. Success on the club circuit but no more than that. The club circuit is a grind, you can only do it for so long then it's up or out. Emilie got out. I think the problem is that radio long ago went corporate. If you don't pony up the big bucks then you won't get on no matter how good you are. It's against the law but that's meaningless in the rules based order.

Emilie's first love is musicals. She has written one which I think contains some of the most beautiful music ever made. She announced it would be produced in London's West End, but it never happened. I think it would have been a success but something gave way before it made the stage. Maybe she couldn't share control with other actors or any director. Maybe the financial backers chickened out. As a side note, a side plot involved a deliberately engineered pandemic, this in 2012 or so.

Possibly the problem was she first performed the musical in nightclubs. It was much too heavy for that, appalling the audience who was there to have fun. Her model is horror movies, not my thing at all but I make a big exception in the case of Emilie. She acted in a small time horror film, back in real life married the leading man, and appears since to have retired from music. There's a lot more to the story, but that's enough for now. I am and shall forever remain a big fan, but if she's happy in married life then good for her.

So, what is this music I claim so beautiful? Here you go. I don't know who did the recording engineering but they deserve a Nobel Prize. Oh, they don't give a prize for that? Maybe they should.



Or how about this one. I bet that every sound is EA. That entrance of the orchestra is SO ominous, so quiet and brooding yet as threatening as is a nuclear warhead.

 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes pinball1970
  • #1,122
How about THIS? I guess they are sisters?

 
  • Like
Likes pinball1970
  • #1,123

Come together - Robin Williams & Bobby McFerrin​


I Am The Walrus (sung by JIM CARREY)​


 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes robphy and pinball1970
  • #1,124
The Blue Margarets -- A Hard Day's Night/Can't Buy Me Love/Mr. Postman
 


One of the best things about Japan : no tribute bands. I haven't even seen any cover bands, though I suppose they must be out there. BUT one big exception. There are a few Beatles tribute bands. You also get to see what real J women look like, as opposed to pop stars and models.

Nice groove. It must be said though, while they rock and are cute as can be, they need to take singing lessons. And I'm sure there is some other J band out there that can do The Beatles near perfectly.

Oh, and the male prostitutes all have Beatle cuts. They service middle-aged women. There is a section of Tokyo devoted to this.
 
  • Love
Likes pinball1970
  • #1,125
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caprice_No._24_(Paganini)


(2018) Paganini 24 Hula Hoop (with Hilary Hahn) - TwoSetViolin
&t=1m00s

(see also Hilary Hahn - Paganini - Caprice 24 )


(2019) Paganini's Caprice no. 24 on One Guitar - Marcin

(see also (2024 live) Marcin Patrzalek - Caprice No.24 - Gramercy Theater - New York, NY - 6.1.24 )
(see also #589 (Kashmir) )

(2020) Paganini Caprice Capriccio No. 24 Dr.Viossy Metal Version Guitar 15 Years OLD Federica GOLISANO

(see also (2007) Dr.Viossy - Paganini, Capriccio 24 - and Viossy in #433 (Moonlight Sonata) )
(see also #760 (Tornado of Souls) )

(2022) Caprice no.24 (N. Paganini): Nikka Gershman, flute



(2016) Paganini Variations on Caprice No. 24 in A minor - Martynas Levickis accordion



(2018) Paganini in gypsy jazz style - HotClubdePiracicaba
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes pinball1970 and Frabjous
  • #1,126
Althea by The Grateful Dead



Cover by John Mayer and Bob Weir



If you want to sing this you'd better be ready to bare your soul.
 
  • Like
Likes pinball1970
  • #1,127
The Grateful Dead's Uncle John's Band.

 
  • Like
Likes pinball1970
  • #1,128
Jon Anderson covers Yes' Awaken. That band is the greatest.



I saw the official Yes in Michigan a few years ago. The keyboard player looked like he'd rather be on a Barcalounger watching TV. Couldn't he even pretend to be interested? Alan White had arthritis so bad that a young drummer played most of the show. When Alan came on, what a difference.

The gripe I have about Yes ever since the beginning is all that subtle distortion. After a while I can't stand it anymore no matter how good they may otherwise be. The Howe Yes is still that way. I need a richer deeper sound.
 
  • Love
Likes pinball1970
  • #1,129
Young Man Blues

Orig by Mose Allison



 
  • #1,130
The orig.

Peter Greenbaum went insane and had to quit Fleetwood Mac. The Mac somehow became desperate for a guitar player for a tour and begged him to return. He said OK, but we're doing everything my way. Schizophrenics are unable to focus. Playing a song would have been too much. So during said tour the Mac was a 100% improvised jam band. They said the audience responded with enthusiasm.

I recall that Peter eventually became a volunteer working in a hospital or possibly an EMT but a cursory search failed to confirm.



There are many covers by famous bands. Here's a brand new one. "My legs are thin."



Give Tom Petty a little bit. A very little bit. Come to think of it his legs are pretty thin.



Can't resist adding this one. Such is showmanship.

 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes pinball1970
  • #1,131
Orig

Crossroads Blues by Robert Johnson



Dea Matrona covering the Cream version live at Winterland. I've listened to that maybe hundreds of times and have it memorized. Many have copied Eric's guitar. If there is ever a Best Rock Solo it will garner many votes. What makes this version special is that they also copy the wild Jack Bruce ebass counterpoint part. That adds a lot.



Jack Bruce's bass idol was JS Bach.

Eric said he didn't like his solo because he got lost in the rhythm and mistook where the downbeat was. I think I know where but it's barely noticeable and doesn't last long. Besides, Cream loved to play games with the downbeat so it fits right in with their style.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Likes robphy and pinball1970
  • #1,132
As far as cover albums that aren't worth it the award goes to Rush. Stick with originals guys. You're real good at that.

It's like when the van Halen bros tried to make it as session men. They didn't fit in. It was originals or nothing.
 
  • Like
Likes pinball1970
  • #1,133
  • #1,134
This guy can really play the guitar. Playing with pick and fingers both is called Chet Atkins style.

 
  • #1,135


Move over John. It's Her song now.
 
  • Love
Likes pinball1970
  • #1,137
 
  • Love
Likes pinball1970
  • #1,138
(1988) Morning Star from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time_Odyssey_(album)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vinnie_Moore

https://chordify.net/chords/vinnie-moore-songs/morning-star-chords
https://www.songsterr.com/a/wsa/vinnie-moore-morning-star-tab-s57782

(2017) Vinnie Moore - "Morning Star" (12/6/17)

Yesterday, on Facebook, I found a seven-year-old girl from Thailand playing this next song...
She does it better than me....
Anyway, it's called "Morning Star".
(1988 studio version)



(2017) Morning Star - Vinnie moore . cover By PettyRock 7 Year old

[ 2021 version ]
(see also #1118 For the Love of God )

(2015) Morning Star (Vinnie Moore) | Guitar Cover by Alexandra Zerner


(2020) Tommo - Morning Star - Vinnie Moore Cover. Double performance: listen with stereo headphones!


(2008) Sebastian Barrio - Morning Star (Vinnie Moore Cover)


(2011) Morning Star - Felipe Rinke (Vinnie Moore Cover) - Workshow Triade
 
Last edited:
  • Wow
Likes pinball1970
  • #1,139
 
  • Like
Likes pinball1970
  • #1,140
Hornbein said:


Move over John. It's Her song now.

I was not keen on this when it was released.
I was put off with the rock and roll feel to it. Like a 50s rock and roll ballad, leader of the pack type of a thing?
Now I just feel extremely sad as it just reminds me of the fact he was there one minute, releasing his first album/ single in years then he was dead weeks later.
Pretty certain they would have reformed and at least done another album or even tour.
I think John and Paul discussed it in the 70s.
 
  • #1,141

Wilko Johnson, Roger Daltrey - I Keep It To Myself​


 
  • #1,142
Not only was the better song the cover, it was also a live version of the song:

 
  • #1,143
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dreams_(Fleetwood_Mac_song) (1977)

Fleetwood Mac - Dreams (Official Music Video) [4K Remaster]



[not a cover, but a famous skateboarding lip-sync while drinking OceanSpray]
(Sep 2020) @doggface2086 (Nathan "Doggface" Apodaca) - Fleetwood Mac (This is the one) thanks everyone VIBE,VIBES, VIBEZZZZZZZ
(original from TikTok: 420doggface208 - Dreams )
https://newsroom.tiktok.com/en-us/d...ile-with-juice-a-skateboard-and-all-the-vibes





(Oct 2020) Lanie Gardner - Dreams by Fleetwood Mac (Cover)


(2024) DREAMS_Fleetwood Mac COVER by FAMILY BAND ‪@FRANZRhythm‬


(May 2020) Fleetwood Mac - Dreams (Reggae Cover) Artikal Sound System


(Jul 2020) Dreams | Fleetwood Mac | funk cover ft. Elise Trouw (Scary Pockets)


(Dec 2020) Fleetwood Mac - Dreams (Punk cover) Sam Zaher
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nbO4JPhsybI
 
  • Love
Likes pinball1970
  • #1,144
robphy said:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dreams_(Fleetwood_Mac_song) (1977)

Fleetwood Mac - Dreams (Official Music Video) [4K Remaster]



[not a cover, but a famous skateboarding lip-sync while drinking OceanSpray]
(Sep 2020) @doggface2086 (Nathan "Doggface" Apodaca) - Fleetwood Mac (This is the one) thanks everyone VIBE,VIBES, VIBEZZZZZZZ
(original from TikTok: 420doggface208 - Dreams )
https://newsroom.tiktok.com/en-us/d...ile-with-juice-a-skateboard-and-all-the-vibes





(Oct 2020) Lanie Gardner - Dreams by Fleetwood Mac (Cover)


(2024) DREAMS_Fleetwood Mac COVER by FAMILY BAND ‪@FRANZRhythm‬


(May 2020) Fleetwood Mac - Dreams (Reggae Cover) Artikal Sound System


(Jul 2020) Dreams | Fleetwood Mac | funk cover ft. Elise Trouw (Scary Pockets)


(Dec 2020) Fleetwood Mac - Dreams (Punk cover) Sam Zaher
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nbO4JPhsybI

Loved it. Two chords!? That's it! I adore the guitar solo if you can call it that, nothing to it but it just fits.
Not sure which version I like best!
When a song is that good, you can do anything to it.


As you may know that album was an absolute car crash of their lives at that point.
Affairs, relationships ending, broken hearts, pain and cocaine.
"Dreams" was Stevie Nicks breaking away from Lindsey Buckingham. "You can go your own way" was Lindsey Buckingham staying, "you are leaving me? Well you can jolly well sod off. I don't need you anyway!"
Obviously he did. He was broken by that and it took years for him to get through it.
Besides those guys fighting it out I always felt for the bass player, John McVie. "You make lovin' fun" was about his wife having "fun" with someone else.
They divorced soon after.
 
  • #1,145
Mick Fleetwood said they would end their show with Christine McVie at a piano playing Songbird. The men in the wings would sob over how they had blown it.
 
  • Like
Likes robphy and pinball1970
  • #1,146
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Just_What_I_Needed (1978)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Cars

(1978) Just What I Needed - The Cars | The Midnight Special - (more from The Cars)




(2018) Cover of The Cars "Just What I Needed" - DoronW

@donnasweetpurplejune6335 - 4 years ago
Love this! It was shared in a Cars fan group today, and Elliot Easton (lead guitarist for The Cars) picked it up and posted it on his personal page. He loves it, too! <3

(2020) Just what I needed Cover : The cars - Patee Sarasin


(2020) Just What I Needed by The Cars Cover by The Fantastic Plastics


(2012) Punch Brothers - Just What I Needed (The Car's Cover) [ with a violin and a banjo ]
&t=1m10s


(2021) Aodhan covers The Cars 'Just What I Needed' for Like A Version


(1999) Lunachicks live at the Square Harlow 1999
(&t=42m30s)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=10bFTG9gS4o&t=2550s
 
  • #1,147
This comes under the "never to be touched" category for me. The whole album.
I listened to this because Foxes and Fossils are excellent.
Unfortunately it is too different for me.

 
  • #1,148
 
  • Like
Likes robphy and pinball1970
  • #1,149
  • Like
Likes pinball1970
  • #1,150

1st RECORDING OF: Land Of 1000 Dances - Chris Kenner (1962)​




"Can you do the fist"?

I looked forward to doing these dances but by the time I grew up it was all over.
 
  • Like
Likes pinball1970
Back
Top