Derivation of Instantaneous Velocity

AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on deriving the instantaneous velocity from the position vector r(t) = (3.0 m/s²)t\hat{x} + (4.0 m/s)t\hat{y}. The user initially misinterpreted the derivative, leading to a confusion between the units of velocity and acceleration. The correct instantaneous velocity is v(t) = (6.0 m/s²)t\hat{x} + (4.0 m/s)\hat{y}, where the '6' represents an acceleration term. Clarifications were made regarding how to handle units, emphasizing that multiplying m/s² by seconds results in m/s. The conversation highlights the importance of understanding the relationship between position, velocity, and their respective units in physics.
0x5B
Messages
4
Reaction score
0
Find the instantaneous velocity where r is the position vector as a function of time:
r(t)=(3.0m/s^2)t\hat{x}+(4.0m/s)t\hat{y}

I attempted to find the derivative of this to find instantaneous velocity, but the book's solution was different. I think the author of the book may have made a mistake, but if not, I would like to know what I've done wrong.
My answer: v(t)=(6.0m/s)t\hat{x}+(4.0m/s)\hat{y}
Book's answer: v(t)=(6.0m/s^2)t\hat{x}+(4.0m/s)\hat{y}
 
Physics news on Phys.org
0x5B said:
r(t)=(3.0m/s^2)t\hat{x}+(4.0m/s)t\hat{y}

Should this be:

r(t) = 3t2 \hat{x} + 4t \hat{y}

Then

r'(t) = 6t \hat{x} + 4 \hat{y}

as you and the book found.

Units for velocity are in m/s so '6' is '6 m/s2' and '4' is '4 m/s'
so I agree with the book :)

When you multiply m/s2 by seconds, the result is m/s
 
Ah, thank you, I was unsure of how to handle the units and being in only ninth grade I wasn't so sure about calling out a university level physics book on a mistake.
 
Last edited:
0x5B said:
Ah, thank you, I was unsure of how to handle the units and being in only ninth grade I wasn't so sure about calling out a university level physics book on a mistake.

Oh, there are mistakes... later editions and more elementary level tends to reduce the number of errors.

At ninth grade the math will probably get in your way but it's good to see some early interest :)
 
Hmm... Taking a second look, I'm not sure we're on the same page. The '6t' should represent (6m/s^2), not just the '6', so it should be (6m/s^2) not (6m/s^2)*t, right? Or am I still missing something? I apologize for such a protracted conversation about something as simple as the units.
 
0x5B said:
Hmm... Taking a second look, I'm not sure we're on the same page. The '6t' should represent (6m/s^2), not just the '6', so it should be (6m/s^2) not (6m/s^2)*t, right? Or am I still missing something? I apologize for such a protracted conversation about something as simple as the units.

The x component of the velocity is x(t) = 6t so '6t' is the horizontal velocity in m/s. It is changing with time that is why the t is there. At time 0, the horizontal velocity is x(0)=0 m/s. At time t=1, the horizontal velocity is x(1)=(6 m/s2)*(1 s) = 6 m/s

The units of x(t) are m/s. 't' is in seconds so that means the units of the constant '6' must be m/s2. m/s2 * s = m/s (cancel out one of the 's')
 
Last edited:
Ah, again, thank you. In hindsight, this was such an obvious oversight on my part.
 
Back
Top