Differential equations particle motion

AI Thread Summary
The discussion focuses on solving a differential equation related to particle motion, specifically finding x(t) from the force function F(v) = -bV². The user initially attempts to derive x(t) but struggles with integrating and accounting for initial conditions, particularly the initial velocity. Feedback emphasizes the importance of including a constant during integration to ensure the solution aligns with initial conditions. The conversation highlights the need for careful manipulation of equations to avoid contradictions, especially at t=0, and ultimately leads to a refined expression for x(t) that satisfies the initial conditions. The final solution aims to ensure that both position and velocity are correctly defined at the starting point.
philnow
Messages
83
Reaction score
0

Homework Statement


Hey all. I have F(v) and I'm looking for x(t).

F(v) = -bV2

I'm a physics undergrad student who hasn't done diff. equations in a while, so I'm very unsure of my work so far... but here it is.

The Attempt at a Solution



I write F=ma as F(v)=mdv/dt:

-bV2=mdv/dt

-m∫ dv/v2 = -b ∫dt

-m/v = -bt
m/v = bt

v = m/bt = dx/dt

∫ dx = m/b ∫ dt/t

Finally x(t) = m/b*ln(t)

Does this look good?
 
Physics news on Phys.org
philnow said:

Homework Statement


Hey all. I have F(v) and I'm looking for x(t).

F(v) = -bV2

I'm a physics undergrad student who hasn't done diff. equations in a while, so I'm very unsure of my work so far... but here it is.

The Attempt at a Solution



I write F=ma as F(v)=mdv/dt:

-bV2=mdv/dt

-m∫ dv/v2 = -b ∫dt

-m/v = -bt
m/v = bt +constant

don't forget the constant.

Otherwise it looks alright. Also remember that ma can be written as mv dv/dx as well
 
I forgot to add that the initial position and initial velocity are both zero so I don't need to worry about constants. Thanks!
 
Are you sure the initial velocity is zero?

philnow said:
Finally x(t) = m/b*ln(t)

Differentiate that expression. Do you get dx/dt=0 at t=0?
 
I misinformed you all, the particle has an initial velocity Vo. My bad. Even still I see that if I put 0 for t in my equation, it is undefined, when it should be zero.

I don't really know how to take it from here, any hints? How do I take into account the constant?
 
philnow said:
-m∫ dv/v2 = -b ∫dt

-m/v = -bt
This is where things go awry, since the equation is contradictory to v=v0 when t=0.

rock.freak667 said:
don't forget the constant.
Yes, exactly. When you integrate, add a constant. What constant will give v=v0 when t=0?
 
How does this seem?

x(t) = m/b*ln(t) + Vo*t
 
Unfortunately, that does not give x(0)=0, due to the ln(t) term.

Also, the initial velocity appears to be infinite, again due to the ln(t) term.

If you show your work, we can help figure out what went wrong.
 
Here's my work:

-bV2=mdv/dt

-m∫ dv/v2 = -b ∫dt

(note: so the integral of 1/v^2 is -1/v, and this integral is from initial v to final v) so:

bt = m(1/v - 1/vo) where vo is initial velocity

bt/m = 1/v - 1/vo

m/bt + vo = v

m/bt + vo = dx/dt

∫(m/bt + vo)dt = ∫dx

m/b*ln(t) + vo*t = x(t)
 
  • #10
philnow said:
Here's my work:

-bV2=mdv/dt

-m∫ dv/v2 = -b ∫dt

(note: so the integral of 1/v^2 is -1/v, and this integral is from initial v to final v) so:

bt = m(1/v - 1/vo) where vo is initial velocity

bt/m = 1/v - 1/vo
Okay so far.

m/bt + vo = v
This step does not follow from the previous one. (We can tell because t=0 implies v=∞, instead of v=vo, in this equation.)

Instead, this step could have been

(bt/m) + (1/vo) = 1/v​
See if you can take if from there.
 
  • #11
(bt/m) + (1/vo) = 1/v

doesn't this mean v = m/bt + Vo?
 
  • #12
philnow said:
(bt/m) + (1/vo) = 1/v

doesn't this mean v = m/bt + Vo?

No, what it means is that v is the reciprocal of

(bt/m) + (1/vo)​

which is

\frac{1}{(bt/m) + (1/v_o)}
 
  • #13
Redbelly98 said:
No, what it means is that v is the reciprocal of

(bt/m) + (1/vo)​

which is

\frac{1}{(bt/m) + (1/v_o)}

Please tell me I've done this right:

from there:

∫dx = ∫https://www.physicsforums.com/latex_images/23/2356837-0.png

x = m/b*ln(bt/m + 1/vo) - m/b*ln(1/vo)

for t=0, x=0 and when differentiated, at t=0,v=vo
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Back
Top