Differentiating $f(F,\theta)$: Why the Answers Differ?

  • Thread starter Thread starter agnimusayoti
  • Start date Start date
  • Tags Tags
    Differentiating
agnimusayoti
Messages
239
Reaction score
23
Homework Statement
A force of 500 N is measured with a possible error of 1 N. Its component in a
direction 60◦ away from its line of action is required, where the angle is subject to an
error of 0.5◦. What is (approximately) the largest possible error in the component?
Relevant Equations
For ##f(F,\theta) \rightarrow dF= \frac{\partial f}{\partial F} dF +\frac {\partial f}{\partial \theta} d\theta ##
From the question,
$$f(F,\theta)=F \cos \theta$$

1. If I use:
$$df=dF \cos{\theta} -F \sin {\theta} d\theta$$
and using radian,
$$df=dF \cos{\theta} -F \sin {\theta} d\theta \frac {\pi}{180^\circ}=5.28 N$$

2. But, if I take logarithm to both side:
$$ln f=ln F+ln \cos{\theta}$$
differentiate both sides:
$$\frac{df}{f}=\frac{dF}{F} + \frac{\sin\theta}{\cos \theta} d\theta$$
Using radian, it gives ##df=4.28 N##My question is, why the answers are different? Thanks.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Physics news on Phys.org
Signs matter.
 
  • Like
Likes Delta2, fresh_42 and DaveE
Recheck your derivatives
 
I think it should also be added that there is no reason to assume that the errors are correlated.
 
Yeah the second should be negative ##-\tan \theta d\theta##. But then for the worst case or should be positive, because we can take d\theta ia negative then ##-\tan \theta d\theta## becomes positive.

With this condition (worst case), so the first one becomes positive and brings ##df=5.28 N##What do you mean by the errors are correlated? Could you please explain itu further? Because the book show to get relative error by the second method. But i just wonder why can't be calculated by 1st method.
 
agnimusayoti said:
Because the book show to get relative error by the second method. But i just wonder why can't be calculated by 1st method.
You can. If you divide your expression for ##df## you got using the first method by ##f##, you get the expression you found for ##df/f## using the second method.
 
  • Like
Likes agnimusayoti, joshyewa and Delta2
Uh youre right. Thanks!
 
But again what is the meaning by the errors are correlated?
 
Back
Top