Diode Question: need to understand why my approach is wrong

2 replies · 2K views · last reply
kostoglotov
Messages
231
Reaction score
6

Homework Statement



A screenshot of the problem:

Circuit schematic: 9V supply at top with R1 = 3k and a forward-biased diode ID in series to 0V; R2 = 1k connected from a node between R1 and the diode to 0V. Text: Determine the diode current, diode modelled as 0.7V in series with 30 ohm.


imgur link: https://i.imgur.com/ljtoclm.png

Homework Equations

The Attempt at a Solution



My first attempt at the solution was this:

Handwritten circuit analysis on paper: a 9V source with a diode and 1k and 2k resistors, Norton equivalent and Thevenin-style reductions with 0.0233A and 0.6796V sources, ending with i = (9 - 0.6796)/3029.13 ≈ 0.00275, about 2.75 mA.


imgur link: https://i.imgur.com/TJcvOzy.jpg

However, I have access to the worked solution, and it is this:

Handwritten circuit working: a 9V source with 3k series resistor feeding a 1k resistor and diode in parallel, Thevenin-style reduction to 2.25V source with 750 ohm resistor and 0.7V source with 30 ohm ESR, and current i = (2.25 - 0.7)/(750 + 30) ≈ 1.99mA.


imgur link: https://i.imgur.com/u0BeWiZ.jpg

I understand the worked solution. What I don't understand is what is wrong in my thinking/understanding so far as my original attempt at the solution goes? Is it not valid to use a Norton Equivalent where I tried to use one? If so, why not?
 
Attachments
  • Circuit schematic: 9V supply at top with R1 = 3k and a forward-biased diode ID in series to 0V; R2 = 1k connected from a node between R1 and the diode to 0V. Text: Determine the diode current, diode modelled as 0.7V in series with 30 ohm.
    ljtoclm.png
    6.9 KB · Views: 866
  • Handwritten circuit analysis on paper: a 9V source with a diode and 1k and 2k resistors, Norton equivalent and Thevenin-style reductions with 0.0233A and 0.6796V sources, ending with i = (9 - 0.6796)/3029.13 ≈ 0.00275, about 2.75 mA.
    TJcvOzy.jpg
    14.9 KB · Views: 405
  • Handwritten circuit working: a 9V source with 3k series resistor feeding a 1k resistor and diode in parallel, Thevenin-style reduction to 2.25V source with 750 ohm resistor and 0.7V source with 30 ohm ESR, and current i = (2.25 - 0.7)/(750 + 30) ≈ 1.99mA.
    u0BeWiZ.jpg
    28.2 KB · Views: 439
Hard to tell since your first image is illegible (too light). Try it again w/ black ink (and thicker preferably)
 
In your first case you are calculating the total current from the 9v source. In your second, the calculation is of just the current through the diode.

It seems you may have had your camera set for artificial light, but have taken the shot under sunlight? This causes the extra blue of natural light to dominate, making your white paper appear blue—and losing contrast with the blue ink.